4 Best Burger Restaurants in Montauk

“It was four of us, two adults two 16 year olds. We ordered, Texas Ruben burger, blue cheese burger, chicken tacos and chicken Cesar salad.
Burgers were great! Fries were warm more on the cold side. Salad was good, good amount of chicken. Chicken tacos come with 3. It’s literally just tacos no rice no sides nothing, a little disappointing.
Prices were reasonable for the area for sure. Shirley temple tasted gross so don’t get that. Moonshine drink was ok, lots of ice so it watered down quick and for $16, that’s crazy.
Service was slow once we finally our food. Felt a little forgotten about, when our food took over 20 minutes to get to us. I guess it explains the cooler temps.
Overall it was a good easy spot that didn’t require a reservation or cost $200.“

“Great breakfast spot, highly recommend the home fries and French toast… went twice during my stay and had Phillip/Danny as waiters, both were great and the owner made sure we were seated almost immediately despite it being crowded (my girlfriend and I are on the younger side and I noticed it effects our service at some nicer places on vacation)…. A lot of the restaurants in Montauk cater towards people with money but this place is great for normal people… spent about $50 (including tip) both times and got great service/food….“

“Cool old school atmosphere. Old man at the counter is just the sweetest. Food is very.....meh. It was all cooked to order which is nice. Fried chicken was seasoned well but very dry. Everything else seemed like it came straight out of a freezer at Costco.

Service and ambiance saves the place. Next time im out ill give the chicken another try.“

“Yummmmmmmmmy! Best milkshakes in the universe!“