4 Best Italian Restaurants in Montauk

Alimentari Beach Montauk Italian • $$
752 Montauk Hwy, Montauk

Customers` Favorites

Gluten Free Spaghetti Pomodoro
Burrata Pizza with Prosciutto
Whipped Ricotta and Meatballs
Sausage and Peppers Pizza
Pasta with Marinara Sauce
Pizza Prosciutto E Funghi
Meatball Appetizer
Bruschetta Rustica
Pizza Margherita
Crispy Artichokes

“BEST pizza ever, made with the finest ingredients. Delightful staff in a charming setting. Don't miss out!“

4.2 Good160 Reviews
Menu
Harvest On Fort Pond Italian • $$$
11 S Emery St, Montauk

Customers` Favorites

Calamari Salad with Red Pepper Vinaigrette
Fresh Fruit Ice Cream Sandwich
Linguine with White Clam Sauce
Braised Boneless Short Rib
Grilled Marinated Lamb Ribs
Flourless Chocolate Cake
Linguini with Clam Sauce
Cucumber Mint Lemonade
Garlic Mashed Potatoes
Harvest Caesar Salad

“Great porterhouse and considerate and friendly employees“

4.4 Superb184 Reviews
Menu
Kenny's Castaways Italian • $$
432 W Lake Dr Ground floor, Montauk

Customers` Favorites

Montauk Edgar's Penne Vodka

“Great food amazing lasagna great service. Mario made our night so special. We will see you next year. A hidden gem for sure.“

4.4 Superb31 Reviews
Menu
Pizza Village Pizza • $
700 Montauk Hwy, Montauk

Customers` Favorites

White Pizza with Ricotta and Pizza with Tomatoes
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie
Buffalo Chicken Pie
Cheese Pizza Slice
Vegetarian Pizza
Grilled Chicken
Margherita Pie
Meat Lovers Pie
Garlic Knots
Plain Pizza

“Great pizza!!!🍕 love this place for a quick bite to eat!“

3.4 Good81 Reviews
Menu

Italian Restaurants Nearby

Enjoy More Tastes In Montauk

You May Also Like

Restaurants in Montauk, NY