Tillie's

Name: Tillie's
Address: 290 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, New York, 11954, US
Telephone: (631) 668-1729
Price range: $$
Rating: 3.5

$$$ • American, Comfort Food, New American

Hours:
290 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk
(631) 668-1729

About Tillie's

Tillie's, a restaurant located with a beautiful ocean view, offers a pleasant dining experience. The ambiance and setting are praised, with the dining area being clean and spacious, allowing for easy movement. The service has received mixed reviews, with some servers being attentive and helpful, while others were slow and indifferent to customer requests.

The menu features a variety of dishes, from the well-received mussels and wasabi-crusted tuna to the less impressive crab cake Benedict and French toast. The pastry basket is a highlight, offering a great value and delicious assortment. The egg white omelet with apple sausage and apple bacon, as well as the turkey club, are highly recommended. The sweet potatoes and potatoes are very delicious, and the steel-cut oatmeal is also very tasty. The world-class lobster roll and rose pairing are notable highlights. However, the charcuterie board is considered overpriced for the portion and variety, and some dishes like the burger and tuna tacos received mixed reviews, with the tacos being small but flavorful.

Overall, Tillie's provides a delightful dining experience with stunning ocean views, delicious food, and some standout menu items. While the scenery and some dishes impress, the service and quality of certain items can be inconsistent, and some experiences have noted issues with service and food quality.