Agnello's Pizza
CLOSED$$ •
Agnello's Pizza Reviews
shocked looking at the other reviews! agnello's has some of the BEST pizza. The flavor and the crust is unbeatable. The croutons on the caesar salad are also amazing. The lunch deals they provide are nice serving sizes and are delicious. You can watch them make the pizza right in front of you which makes it extra fun for kids too!
Ordered a pie, the service was prompt. The crust is not too thin and the cheese was delicious. What I didn’t like was that the sauce was very watery and dripping out of every bite. Don’t think I would go back.
Ratings
Menu
People in New City Also Viewed
Agnello's has been our family go to for the best coal fired, brick oven pizza for the past 15 years. The taste of the dough, the sweetness of the sauce and the freshness of the Mutz rank higher than any NYC or Brooklyn place. (they have a direct family lineage to Patsy's and Grimaldi's) This was our go to place for real pizza. Besides pizza they had the best Caesar salad with incredible homemade croutons. Not to mention the fam favorite dessert Zeppoli with Nutella and strawberry....read full review