9 Best Italian Restaurants in New City

Mille Luci Pizzeria Italian • $$
170 N Main St, New City

Customers` Favorites

Prosciutto E Burrata Pizza
Vodka Margherita Pizza
Meatball Panuozzo
San Daniele Pizza
Snow White Pizza
Meat Lover Pizza
Fried Brussels
Caesar Salad
House Salad
Rucola Salad

“Family run business with owners who try to please their customers. The pizza & salads are outstanding & there is nothing that compares to what they are serving in rockland county.Vegetarian options: Outstanding salads & plenty of vegetable choices to add to your pizza.Dietary restrictions: They will try to please you & accommodate any dietary restrictions.Parking: Plenty of available spaceKid-friendliness: Family style restaurant“

4.9 Superb127 Reviews
Leonardo's Italian Deli & Catering Deli • $
14 N Main St, New City

Customers` Favorites

Chopped Cheese Sandwich
Gabagool Egg & Cheese
Eggplant Parmigiana
Italian Combo
Chicken Cutlet
Chicken Parm
Burrito Bowl
The Crooner
Turkey Club
Roll

“Huge selection of sandwich options, made with high quality ingredients. I couldn’t believe the size of the sandwiches and at such an affordable price point. The staff was also very friendly and attentive. This place is a gem. I can’t wait to go back!“

4.8 Superb66 Reviews
Michael's on Main American • $$$
381 S Main St, New City

Customers` Favorites

Linguini with Clam Sauce
Angry Lobster Tail
Chicken Parmigiana
Grilled Pork Chop
Chicken Milanese
Chicken Marsala
Lobster Risotto
Shrimp Cocktail
Beef Wellington
Patatas Bravas

“Came here to celebrate my mom's birthday. Absolutely fabulous from start to finish! The staff is warm and friendly yet professional. Eduardo, our server was attentive and on top of everything throughout the course of our dinner. From apps to entrees not a detail was overlooked. Now the food... I can't put into words how the flavors and quality of food are by far top notch. Sooo good!!! This place is a hidden gem and the food, drinks and service is amazing! Definitely will be back!!“

4.6 Superb59 Reviews
Alfredo’s Restaurant Italian • $$
189 S Main St, New City

Customers` Favorites

Veal and Eggplant Parmigiana
Linguini in Clam Sauce
Pasta Primavera
Chicken Marsala
Spicy Calamari
Bread Dip
Tiramisu
Menu

“It's been a while since I could get back to Alfredo's restaurant in New City, and I'm happy I did. The staff were very courteous and attentive. Our party of 6 each ordered a different meal and we all thoroughly enjoyed their selection. I highly recommend trying out Alfredos in New City.“

4.6 Superb35 Reviews
Napoli's Pizza & Catering Pizza • $
48 Germonds Rd, New City

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Cutlet with Lettuce Tomato and Mayo
Chicken Fingers and French Fries
Plain Slice of Cheese Pizza
Penne Vodka with Chicken
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Chicken Wings
Garlic Knots
White Pizza

“I have a medically problematic love of pizza. When I move to a new place, I try all the pizzas, highly rated or lowly rated, try all the take-out and dine-in pizza. Thus far, Napoli's is best pizza in Rockland County. Easily holds it's own in NYC or New Haven, even“

4.3 Superb27 Reviews
Ella New York Pizza and Pasta Italian • $$
137 S Main St, New City

Customers` Favorites

Greek Salad with Chicken
Chicken Parmigiana
Fettuccine Alfredo
Chicken Francese
Pepperoni Pizza

“We went to Ella New York Pizza & Pasta for my dad's birthday and we had a nice time celebrating with great food and good service. The space itself felt relatively home-y which was nice, for sure. I myself had the Waldorf Chicken Salad with salmon as well and it was the perfect portion with a good ratio of protein to greens! I will definitely be coming back!Parking: Parking spots are definitely tight as it seems they tried to fit as many spaces as possible. Be careful pulling in!Wheelchair accessibility: There is a small step that leads into the restaurant space, but it's nothing having some assistance can't help.“

4.2 Good37 Reviews
La Terrazza Italian • $$
291 S Main St, New City

Customers` Favorites

Fussilli with Grilled Shrimp
Filet Mignon with Mushrooms
Crabmeat & Mango Salad
Chicken Scarpariello
Tortellini Carbonara
Rigatoni Bolognese
Roasted Vegetables
Stuffed Mushrooms
Salmon with Pesto
Chicken Marsala

“La Terrazza has become a Rockland County staple with wonderful, intimate ambiance that works well for working lunch, to a date night right to an intimate family party. I’ve never experienced a bad meal; and they have classics rarely seen like Chicken Scarpriello and veal saltimbacca. The service is seamless and always courteous. The management has their hands on because in the dozen odd years I’ve frequented La Terrazza, the facilities are always spotless, the food is genuine and delicious and the service is wonderful.And they are at a perfect price point for what you are getting and being offered.Parking: Plenty of free parkingKid-friendliness: Always kid friendlyWheelchair accessibility: Not an issue whatsoever“

4.1 Good66 Reviews
Paisanos Pizza Pizza • $
730 NY-304, New City

Customers` Favorites

Plain Cheese Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Slice of Pizza

“Good, tasty takeaway pizza prepared in a new-ish, clean pizzeria. The vegetarian pizza is our favorite, with a nice crust and onions, tomatoes, and zucchini. With severalpizza choices available, good crust, good varietal toppings and good sauce, we are regulars!“

4 Good38 Reviews
Norcina Italian • $$
186 N Main St, New City

Customers` Favorites

Rigatoni Ragu
Meatballs

“The food was absolutely incredible here. When we got there, there was almost no one in the dining room. While we were waiting for our food, the entire restaurant filled up with kids and their parents celebrating some kind of sports thing. It became incredibly loud and chaotic. Despite this, the lasagna was one of the best dishes I've ever had. It had short rib and prosciutto in it, and it was worth sitting through all of the noise.“

3.7 Good50 Reviews
Loading...

Discover More Cuisines In New City

map Map