Italian Restaurants near West Haverstraw

“It’s been very hard to find good cheese anywhere. The Fiore di Sardegna is fresh and abundant here! The frozen dinners tasted fresh after heating, olives and mozzarella were amazing, olive oil was full flavored, and the homemade pasta is outrageous! Love this place! I Left a lot poorer than I was when I walked in.“

“I have ordered from Papa's several times and I'm surprised at all the bad reviews on here. I will say that I always go to pick up my pizza though, so I don't have delivery problems, I guess. The pizza is really good! I have a picky family and everyone in my house likes their pizza. It's always done by the time I get there and it's hot and fresh. I've also ordered salad from here and been happy with it, it was nice and fresh and the salad dressing was good too. One of these days we'll order wings and I'll update my review. We'll keep ordering from here.“

“Gave this place a couple of tries in the past couple of months. Tried various specialty slices and found them all to be excellent. I can't rate excellent until I try the regular cheese pie. I see a lot of complaints on pricing but I have to say the specialty slices are absolutely huge and I didn't think the price was unfair. Will give it another go soon.“

“Family run business with owners who try to please their customers. The pizza & salads are outstanding & there is nothing that compares to what they are serving in rockland county.Vegetarian options: Outstanding salads & plenty of vegetable choices to add to your pizza.Dietary restrictions: They will try to please you & accommodate any dietary restrictions.Parking: Plenty of available spaceKid-friendliness: Family style restaurant“

“My wife and I had never been to Tarrytown before, but on a whim got a reservation for our anniversary at Bistro 12. We couldn't recommend it more! We ate the lobster bisque, calamari and a Caesar salad to start. I had the seafood risotto and my wife had the Ravioli Tartufata, both very delicious. Both the food and service were fantastic, would return in a heartbeat.“

“Huge selection of sandwich options, made with high quality ingredients. I couldn’t believe the size of the sandwiches and at such an affordable price point. The staff was also very friendly and attentive. This place is a gem. I can’t wait to go back!“

“I come here every once in a while. It's quite nice, the food is really good and reasonably priced. They also have a nice selection of gluten-free menu options. I'm not gluten-free, but recently, it's been something I look out for and notice because I love someone who is Celiac. Most recently, I came for my birthday, and they were able to modify items on the menu to custom create what I was looking for! (always a plus)Dietary restrictions: They have gluten free optionsKid-friendliness: Very kid friendlyWheelchair accessibility: It's on one level with no steps but tight might be hard to navigate with a chair“

“My good friend and myself stumbled into Dolce Vita not too long ago when it was the only restaurant in Nyack that was opened very late. We struck gold. We have been back several times and the food, the service, the owner, the atmosphere are the very best . All are wonderful.“

“This little pizzeria has the cutest little front. It's across the street from the library and it has little seats outside. You could sit and have a nice cuppa coffee or slice of pizza. We like the chicken buffalo and a lot of the margarita pizzas. I love the calzones everything has been pretty good.“

“UPDATE AT THE END;I ordered online ahead of time to have my order ready on time, when I arrived in the store, the worker at the counter was choosing his priorities of personal life over the customers.He left me waiting there while my food was getting soggy more and more by the minute..He was busy catching up with some friends..When I spoke up and asked if my order is ready, the friend backed off to let me through to the counter, but this lovely worker took the opportunity to now call another friend over Video call to show him who just came in to the store.......To the business owner, if you want to have a good name, please make sure to talk to the worker that worked at the counter on March 30th at 11:45 - 11:55 pm.----UPDATE.A few minutes after posting the review, I got a reply from the owner that he will look into this.The next morning I got a call from him that he looked at the CCTV footage and wants to hear more details from me.I gave him the full story and he said that he will talk to the worker.I got a call from him not too long after the initial call, and he clarified what the story was and that the company is taking full responsibility on this.Now, after this I can proudly say, the customers service is 10 out of 5, awesome and amazing to deal with responsible people, a mistake is a mistake.“

“Had a wonderful experience at al di la! We arrived a little before 12 pm and was empty so we got to enjoy the quiet but it got filled up while we were sitting. The atmosphere is calm. There isn't a very bug menu but the food is really good. We had their famous salad pizza and didn't disappoint! We also ordered a hot coca which was perfect for this cold rainy day and a delicious salmon pizzaoili. The Eggplant rollantini was good as well. Will definitely be coming back here!“

“After a night of no sleep and a rough work day I dreaded the thought of going home to cook dinner. I didn't want to order fast food garbage. I went into my Facebook page and saw this fabulous photo of trays of chicken caprese. Wow. It looked amazing. Having never tried it and Doms being on my way home, I figured I'd give it a try. I was greeted by Michael who was super nice and even asked me how my day was! So sweet. I brought my tray home happy to warm it up and serve up to my family. They loved it! I loved it too. It warmed up nicely and hubby and I were able to have some for lunch the next day! A home cooked meal on a busy week night for $40? I'm sold. 4 meals at McDonald's is about $40 these days or more! Hello Doms, Goodbye Fast Food.“

“Came here to celebrate my mom's birthday. Absolutely fabulous from start to finish! The staff is warm and friendly yet professional. Eduardo, our server was attentive and on top of everything throughout the course of our dinner. From apps to entrees not a detail was overlooked. Now the food... I can't put into words how the flavors and quality of food are by far top notch. Sooo good!!! This place is a hidden gem and the food, drinks and service is amazing! Definitely will be back!!“

“It's been a while since I could get back to Alfredo's restaurant in New City, and I'm happy I did. The staff were very courteous and attentive. Our party of 6 each ordered a different meal and we all thoroughly enjoyed their selection. I highly recommend trying out Alfredos in New City.“

“I have dined in many times. The service is always pleasant and friendly. I had a girls get together with my cousins on 2/24/24. The food was delivered timely. The eggplant parmagiana and the chicken saltimboca was excellent. The spinach rolls and cold cut stromboli we had as appetizers were also very good. As always Andrew thank you!“

“We used Sansotta for their Thanksgiving catering. We purchased their full Thanksgiving package and couldn’t be happier with how easy and tasty everything was. Our guests were very pleased with the food and I can’t imagine not using them again next year. Highly recommend!“

“This is a real pizza place. The pizza is awesome. They have all kinds of fancy slices during the day. The prices are on par with the area. The staff is great and will take care of your needs. Give them a try. You won't be disappointed.“

“I have passed this place thousands of times, but never ate here. I stopped in tonight and was pleasantly surprised. We ordered pizza, 2 heroes and some cannoli's to go. The pizza was excellent and in my opinion, better than the pizza at other nearby restaurants! The heroes also got great reviews!! Although I'm not a huge fan of cannoli's, they were very good and hit the spot :) I have no idea why it took me so long to try this place out, but I will def. be back! The staff was also super friendly.“

“Delicious!Amazing variety!Kindest owners. Helpful and friendly. They make you feel like family.Nice decor, good location, great vibe.My whole family loved eating pizza there after a walk around Rockland Lake. Had an amazing spread from there at a toddlers bday party which prompted the post park visit.Vegetarian options: It's pizza“

“The pepperoni rolls here are somehow the most amazing food on Earth. They had went downhill for a bit - which was still superior to most - but somehow have made a comeback to perfection. Only downside is that I do not live in Croton anymore, and the 50 we bought to take home are now having to be shared with the kids because they too have realized how great they are! Plus the pizza is superb. The soda fountain wasn't great, but honestly that's a tiny blip.Parking: Small number of spots but it lines up fine with amount of seating as long as it's not at capacityKid-friendliness: Great for kidsWheelchair accessibility: Seems easily accessible“

“My family eats out often and lately have been disappointed. Mario's is a true hidden gem. TRUE Italian food, the food & drinks AMAZING ! Our server Gabby was so attentive & amaxing as well! We found a great place to enjoy food & family!“

“I recently had the pleasure of dining at Hollywood Pizza, and I must say, it exceeds my expectations. Let's start with the star of the show: the pizza. Each slice was a delectable masterpiece, bursting with flavor and fresh ingredients. From the perfectly crispy crust to the mouthwatering toppings, every bite was a delight.But what truly sets Hollywood Pizza apart is the exceptional service. The staff were not only efficient but also incredibly friendly, making me feel welcomed from the moment I walked in. Their warmth and attentiveness added an extra layer of enjoyment to my dining experience.And let's not forget about the inviting atmosphere created by the owners. Their passion for good food and hospitality shines through in every aspect of the restaurant. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice or settling in for a leisurely meal inside or outside on a beautilful day, you'll feel right at home at Hollywood Pizza.Overall, I can't recommend Hollywood Pizza enough. It's the perfect spot to satisfy your pizza cravings while basking in a welcoming environment created by passionate owners and friendly staff.“

“The pizza is phenomenal and the service is pretty good. They're on time with their estimates and the prices are good too. The atmosphere feels more like a grab and go, I wouldn't stay in the restaurant too long because the kids can be pretty rowdy.Vegetarian options: It's a pizza place with good pizza.“

“We travel from several towns away to eat here, it is that good! I very much appreciate being welcomed like old friends whenever we dine here, as well as the professional and friendly staff, delicious food, and my personal favorite, the chocolate martini! Freshly baked bread for the table, exquisite salads and appetizers followed by an array of entrees such as chicken fratelli (my favorite) or several seafood and pasta dishes. While there is usually a crowd, the acoustics are such that you can have a pleasant conversation at your table. There is a lovely seating area with floor to ceiling windows which feels like you are almost eating outdoors, as well as outdoor seating in season.“

“I stumbled upon this gem unexpectedly and was pleasantly surprised! I tried their BBQ chicken and cheese pizza, along with a small salad, garlic knots, and a calzone to go. The wait (4 minutes) was worthwhile, as the food was incredibly flavorful. The staff was friendly, and although though the place is small, the deals are substantial. This place is perfect for those late-night cravings, as they're open until 2 am. Can't wait to come back! :)“

“A wonderfully ambient cafe with a respectable-sized menu of various delectable offerings combined with friendly and efficient service, and central location, to make for an excellent choice for those looking for a fancy dairy restaurant.Vegetarian options: Good choice ?Dietary restrictions: Milchig, under the השגחה of the CRC.“

“I love Beni's! Their sauce is very similar to my mother's. I love to take my grandchildren to eat there. Their pizzettas are delicious! It's just a great place to go have a nice Italian meal with a glass of wine in a very comfortable atmosphere. I'm sure you'll enjoy what they have to offer.“

“Good food. Hardly speak English when calling to place an order. Plus how do you have Mexican people running an Italian restaurant??? That just doesn't make any type of sense! I have to keep repeating my order several times before it sunk in. I'd recommend just going there to eat. But overall the pricing is good and the food is great even though it's Spanish people taking over the art of great Italian cooking. It's still a decent place. Better than Mariella's Pizza.“

“Late ⏰ review but overall the pizza ? was amazing visited here about a month ago. Restaurant was closed but there is a food truck they have outdoors that sells the best chicken and slices. So we had to eat in the car. The atmosphere was great and a nice vibe in the area will surely keep you comfy with scenery to enjoy your food. Thank you ☺️“

“The new owners are basically doing their best to try to create a little music venue on the weekends. Jungle Love was on tonight and the place was hopping. We've eaten here a couple of times in the food's been good. I was a little disappointed in the chicken scarp as the potatoes were cold in the middle was kind of strange. Otherwise everything there is excellent“

“We went with another couple this time so there were more items ordered. I had the Mimosa Salad again and also repeated my entree having the Parledelle Bosca with Mushrooms. Hubby had a special, which included Filet Mignon, Lobster Tails and Prawns. Our friends had a Snapper special and Crab cakes. Everyone loved the food. The only thing we noticed is that those who had the Calamari and the salads felt like they tasted a little too much salt. We believe the salads may have been that way due to the strong cheeses in them.The service was very good as usual. Jason seems to be the head waiter. He loves what he does and knows so much about the food and the drinks. He is very accommodating and wants everyone to be happy. He has an over the top personality which can be fun, but for some may be a little too much. All worth the visit. We will go again. ?Vegetarian options: They have a dish called Parledelle Bosca with Mushrooms that is delicious and I've had it each time I've been there. They will customize our create a dish for you, which I love.“

“Fabulous! That's all I can say. We were looking for a spot to grab a quick bite before heading to the Great Jack O'Lantern Blaze and happened to pass this deli. My son lives in PA now and LOVES delis, so we went in and were totally wowed by all the options and the friendly people! I don't know how I've not been to this gem before, but I have it on my list of MUST HAVES now!Our sandwiches were amazing, and I don't say that lightly! They also have a lot of baked goods, so I had to try a few of their cookies, and they were delish! Seriously going back for more soon!“

“For the past year I have been coming here. The food has so much flavor and the portions are huge. They have an extensive menu with lots of choices. From apatizers, pizza and main dishes you can’t go wrong. Great selection and fantastic food! Thanks for being a great place.“

“We went to Ella New York Pizza & Pasta for my dad's birthday and we had a nice time celebrating with great food and good service. The space itself felt relatively home-y which was nice, for sure. I myself had the Waldorf Chicken Salad with salmon as well and it was the perfect portion with a good ratio of protein to greens! I will definitely be coming back!Parking: Parking spots are definitely tight as it seems they tried to fit as many spaces as possible. Be careful pulling in!Wheelchair accessibility: There is a small step that leads into the restaurant space, but it's nothing having some assistance can't help.“

“Haven’t been here in a LONG time since they switched owners. Finally stopped by to pick up dinner and it is wayyyy better than it used to be, even with the old owners. The salad was so fresh nothing came soggy. The bread was nice and soft. I was so impressed, excited to be a regular again!!!“

“I’ve finally tried their white pie and I have to say it’s the The Best white pie I have EVER had. Finally a white pie that’s got the perfect amount of garlic! Worth Every Penny! And don’t forget to grab a Sweet&Salty’s cookie too!“

“Here is the easiest way to describe this place. STRAIGHT UP HOMEMADE ITALIAN FOOD! This is 5-STAR Italian deliciousness! I was last here about 20 years ago but to be honest, like most, I have zero reason to ever be in Verplanck. This evening I was down there and made the immediate decision to dine-in the second I saw their big sign on Broadway. The place looks basically the same as I remember, very neat, clean and of course with a stellar menu. I observed Carmine (at the bar) preparing some amazing looking cocktails! Great service, well priced, friendly staff and great dishes! One thing I want to point out is how the first forkful of my cold antipasto salad appetizer immediately tasted soooo different. I wasn't expecting fresh, 'sharp' provolone -- no sliced ham here kids. Tonight was an unexpected treat! I will again grab my passport and cross the border into Westchester to spend more time here! Mangia!“

“I have a medically problematic love of pizza. When I move to a new place, I try all the pizzas, highly rated or lowly rated, try all the take-out and dine-in pizza. Thus far, Napoli's is best pizza in Rockland County. Easily holds it's own in NYC or New Haven, even“

“This joint is all about no-frills dining; they even charge extra for napkins and mark up one-dollar Arizona drinks to two bucks. The evening shift operator oozes an arrogant kind of charm, but one thing remains consistently good—the pizza. It's always deliciously greasy, folded up neatly into a paper bag. They don't skimp on quality, using top-notch ingredients and embodying that classic Italian flair blended with New York charm. These two brothers have been making pizza here day and night for close to 50 years. If you grew up in Northern Westchester, you know Napolis pizza, and you know these two legends.“