50 Best Italian Restaurants near Peekskill

“Massages at the spa with my beautiful daughter then on to meet the guys at the restaurant. It was excellent from the starters through the mains to the desserts. Will definitely go back. Ambiance and great food, what a good combination. You usually only get one or the other this place had it all. Service was excellent too.“

“Wonderful food and great service!“

“I meant to leave a review the first I ate here, but forgot. Well, my white pizza was so good, I had to return for more. Customer service was great both times. The first time I walked in and the second time I called it in. I was very please with the phone order because the young man on the phone told me how much my order was if I was paying in cash or card (up charge for card). And the first time I went the person behind the counter had a conversation with me that I enjoyed. I will be back.“

“We ended up here for pizza before a show at the Paramount, Owner & his staff were incredibly gracious, Pizza was awesome, great variety of oversized slices readily available & reasonably priced!
Don’t miss this great spot !!
eat here before the shows!!“

“It was awesome and enough for two people. Great service.“

“Gleason's was very nice.
There was a live band that played their own songs, as well as hits from the past.

My bartenders Rachel and Michael were very welcoming, as well as mixing a great drink.

You are met by Tommy at the door, and you know it will be all right ?.

Gleason's has a nice menu with a great selection of wood fired pizzas, or you can design what you want.

They have a nice menu of classic cocktails as well as a beer and wine ? list.“

“I went here last night with my girlfriend. I was blown away by the food. I haven't had a dinner this good in a long time. The main course pizza was amazing. The service was top notch and the atmosphere was beautiful and romantic. Everything we ordered passed my high expectations. The garlic Zeppoli's 10/10.Snow white and margherita pizza 10/10. The cannoli's and tiramisu were the best I have ever had. Truly an all around 5 star experience.
-The live music was also 10/10. Luigi is a very talented singer!“

“Let's now discuss the pizza, which is the true star of the show. Tutto Pizza offers a variety of delectable alternatives, all of which are meticulously prepared. Each pizza is a true work of art, from the traditional Margherita, which displays the ideal mix of acidic tomato sauce, creamy mozzarella, and aromatic basil, to their creative gourmet combinations.A special note should be made of their crust, which is the prefect combination of chewy and crispy and provides as the excellent backdrop for the delectable toppings. Whether you like a fluffy, thick crust or one that is thin and crispy, Tutto Pizza has you covered.“

“Outstanding service and everything we ordered was excellent and delicious.“

“The pizza is delicious and the atmosphere is fabulous!!“

“Great food at family owned restaurant“

“The bus boy is very cute“

“Exceptional food and service!!! Wait person was accommodating and warm and friendly.“

“Exceptional! Jason and the staff at Fino orchestrated the perfect birthday party for my boyfriend. The food was absolutely delicious; the atmosphere was warm and comfortable yet eloquent. The entire family enjoyed the evening! My son can’t wait to go back!“

“I have been going there since I moved to Cold Spring and the food is delicious. Family owned and you can get homemade Mexican food also. The people are very friendly and are willing to make the customers happy with special orders. Great place.“

“Been ordering from for a bit now, when I was in Suffern to now Wesley Hills, and never had an issue until tonight. But the issue was immediately and more importantly graciously resolved by the manager on hand. I wish this was the case with all restaurants but sadly it’s not. So this says more about this establishment than anything else.“

“We traveled to NY from Alabama and after leaving the city, driving the Taconic Pkwy up to Albany, we happened to stop in this quaint town. We decided on pizza for lunch and were not disappointed. The owner was amazingly nice and friendly. The pizza was AMAZING!!! Thank you for serving us today! Excellent!!!!!“

“I eat in this great spot many times a year! This is the best place to pass a nice evening. I visit this place at least once a month. The cooking is of high quality, the staff is friendly and the rates are reasonable. I enjoy being in this restaurant for a decent supper.“

“Excellent food and service“

“Personable, Professional, and courteous establishment. Very clean work at a decent price..“

“A friend recommended this restaurant to our family to celebrate a birthday. The food and service were exceptional. We had two very hungry and restless kiddos with us and the staff went above and beyond to get their orders going. Our drinks and appetizers ( Bruschetta) were delicious and our waiter Eddie was extremely friendly, professional and caring. The scallop risotto was the best I've had in a long time. We'll be back!“

“Food was great and we loved our waitress She was wonderful ❤️“

“Great food at Orfinos. Great brick oven pizza. Come and eat.“

“We started with great cocktails and then had great appetizers. The portions are large, the presentation is beautiful and the taste is great. For a main course I had an out of this world filet mignon. The service was very kind and the wine at the meal was very good. Ask for the tiny donuts with the sweet dips for dessert. It was a great culinary experience and we will definitely go back there. Thanks to Audrey and Sol the owners who took care of every detail.“

“We had a delicious meal at 901 last night. The pasta, pizza, and shrimp dishes were delicious. Scrumptious appetizers of calamari and Brussels sprouts. Great drinks —my first espresso martini—-and desserts . Theresa— our server— also was amazing! Haven’t been here in a while. So glad I made it back. Has always been delicious.“

“Great atmosphere. comfortable not snotty“

“Food was amazing! My in-laws took us here a long time ago. They are no longer with us but loved eating here. I’m Not from this area. We were at a swim meet in Yonkers and passed Spaccarelli’s by accident. Guess it was meat to be! Service was top notch! Had a great experience.“

“Anything you order from them you will not be disappointed. Very friendly staff and the owner gets to know his customers.“

“I literally can't recommend this place enough! we stayed in cold spring for 4 nights and got food here everyday haha! we tried pretty much everything and EVERYTHING was delicious! freshly cooked, with love! the staff are super friendly and welcoming too. absolutely 5 stars!“

“It was a wonderful dinner as always. We celebrated my brother’s 60th birthday and they couldn’t be nicer! Thanks for a wonderful time.“

“First of all, we are from NYC, and everyone knows NYC has some of the best pizzas in the world. This place has AMAZING PIZZA, not for nothing. Even just a plain Jane slice of cheese pizza is so tasty, and as my wife says, "ooey-gooey"

Second of all, the employees are helpful and polite. They have a great selection of fresh made pizzas and drinks to choose from. We had the Buffalo chicken slice, a plain cheese, and a Sicilian pizza with tomato, fresh muzz, and basil. It's absolutely incredible for pizza that's not "from the city"

Third of all there is plenty of parking and clean bathrooms.

We will definitely be coming back here each time we visit Ossinning.“

“Relaxed atmosphere with dog friendly outdoor seating!!!! Fresh ingredients are used and it shows. Great food and service!! What a wonderful find in this quaint town!!!! If you are in this town, this is a must stop!!!!!“

“The pizza is definitely the best anywhere around. Perfectly cheesy, the crust is crisp, and the sauce is a real star. The gelato is delicious as well. The employees seem to be still learning the ropes, but everyone in my family agrees that this is our first choice for pizza anytime it’s on the table.

Dietary restrictions: Kosher“

“Very consistent good Italian food. A nice menu. My go to for penne a vodka, chicken sorrentino. They do close early. There prices recently for pasta went through the roof almost no difference between getting a pasta dish or a chicken dish. I would definitely lower the pasta prices, come on pasta is free. But with that being said It is good food but just not a everynight spot bc of the prices“

“Absolutely outstanding experience at Eduardo’s! From the moment we walked in, the ambiance was warm and inviting. Kayleigh, our server, bartender, and restaurant manager, was the highlight of our visit. Her friendly demeanor made us feel right at home. The food was exquisite, the pizza and pasta dishes hit amazing everytime, but Kayleigh’s exceptional service truly made the evening unforgettable. Highly recommend Eduardo’s!“

“Maria's pizza the best in town!!“

“This restaurant is obviously chef driven Food is on point. Everything on the menu is good never had a bad meal here. Specials are off the charts. Must try.“

“A great staff. Always friendly and not to mention great food !!!“

“Everything is always fresh! Just breakfast today 3 egg whites, onions, peppers, mushrooms, and broccoli on toasted roll.. very good!“

“I’ve lived in Croton for over three years. Should have stopped by sooner“

“I love Beni's! Their sauce is very similar to my mother's. I love to take my grandchildren to eat there. Their pizzettas are delicious! It's just a great place to go have a nice Italian meal with a glass of wine in a very comfortable atmosphere. I'm sure you'll enjoy what they have to offer.“

“incredible food, incredible staff. my best friend brought me here 9 years ago when I went home to visit. I came back to visit this week, ate here twice and brought rice balls home from vacation. awesome awesome awesome place!!! ♥️“

“Good food. Hardly speak English when calling to place an order. Plus how do you have Mexican people running an Italian restaurant??? That just doesn't make any type of sense! I have to keep repeating my order several times before it sunk in. I'd recommend just going there to eat. But overall the pricing is good and the food is great even though it's Spanish people taking over the art of great Italian cooking. It's still a decent place. Better than Mariella's Pizza.“

“We visit this restaurant every time we are in Cold Spring. The staff is fantastic and very accommodating. The food is delicious and freshly made. They are able to accommodate my allergies (dairy and gluten). We have probably eaten here 5-6 times and the food has been consistently delicious. I have tried everything from the fish, the pastas and the appetizers.

Dietary restrictions: Gluten free
Dairy free
Vegetarian
Vegan“

“Primavera Pizzería is more than just amazing pizza. They have a fantastic menu of all the Italian classics the home country is known for! Done in or take out, you will never be disappointed. The staff, from the openers to the waiters, are so sweet and attentive. You don’t just feel like a guest. You feel like “famiglia”. And the food?!?! To die for. I travel 20 minutes past many a restaurant to eat here. It’s a must visit!“

“We brought the whole family for my sons 14th birthday and it was perfect. You cannot beat this pizza locally and it’s amazing fresh out of the oven. The rigatoni Ragusa was unbelievable. The kids had their ice cream at the end and it was perfect. The owners hands on service is what I remember from restaurants as a kid. I almost forgot, the music is great. We’ll be back.“

“Been coming here for years ever since I was a little kid im a lifelong verplanck resident and i love there pizza and the chicken rice and beans is unbeatable if you want an awesome meal and great service u should go here marcello's will always be my go to pizza“

“First time customer. They had an array of gourmet slices available but I stuck with the plain on this trial run. It was excellent. Thin, very crispy crust, folded with a snap and no flop, a very good sauce but not overwhelming, and a good cheese balance. Service was friendly and my slices were served very hot, which is the only way I like my pizza. I will return for a whole specialty pie to go.“

“We had a lovely dinner here! The staff, especially our server, were wonderful and the food delicious ? Highly recommend the shrimp scampi entree (which came with a delicious side salad) and the vanilla ice cream with avocado and biscotti sundae (accompanied by espresso).“

“Gilligan's is an awesome Grill, my compliments the night my fiancé Mary Elizabeth O'Keefe Goodin and I had dinner there was to both Front of House and Back of House. Service was brilliant, food was brilliant, the staff were brilliant. If I was living in the area I'd make Gilligan's a regular venture for awesome cuisine.“