Home
NY
Mahopac
Italian Restaurants

13 Best Italian Restaurants in Mahopac

Browse menus, reviews and photos of Italian Restaurants in Mahopac.

Showing 13 of 13 restaurants

Italian · $$
1 Trattoria Sei

4.6 Superb 290 Reviews

597 US-6, Mahopac
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Nutella Pizza with Strawberry
- Ceasar Salad with Shrimp
- Pappardelle Bolognese
- NY Style Cheesecake
“Enjoyed a wonderful dinner with my sister, we started with steamed mussels in red sauce & divine bread. We ordered their Sunday sauce with Meatball,sausage,spare rib, bracelets on rigatoni W/a dollop of Ricotta cheese. Couldn’t finish all of it took the rest home. It was excellent!! served with crispy garlic bread. No room for desert. Service was excellent. Can’t wait to go back.”
Menu Order
Italian · $$
2 Benvenuto's of Mahopac

4.6 Superb 223 Reviews

35 Secor Road, Mahopac
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Dinner Salad with House Dressing on Side
- Peanut Butter Pie with Apples Whip Cream
- Calamari Fra Diavolo over Linguini
- Rigatoni Ala Matriciana
“This place is one of my family's favorite restaurants for many years. We all refer to it as B's. There are so many great and delicious choices between the specialty pizza slices, salads, and pasta and chicken dishes. Rocky and team has always gone above and beyond for us whenever we order out, dine in, cater for a party or host a party in the back. We've never had a bad meal here and highly recommend it.”
Menu Order
Italian · $$
3 Arturo's Tavern

4.4 Superb 195 Reviews

878 US-6, Mahopac
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Skirt Steak with Potato Chips Onions and Sweet or Hot Peppers
- Chicken Valdostano with Potato or Vegetable
- Cappuccino and Gluten Free Chocolate Cake
- Chicken Valdostano over Fried Potatoes
“We love Arturo’s…it’s our go to for dinner with friends or just as a couple. the BEST martini menu we’ve ever seen and tasted. Food is always delicious and the service is always great. If you’ve never been, GO!!!!”
Menu Order
Italian · $
4 Eduardo's Trattoria

4.3 Superb 147 Reviews

115 Secor Road, Mahopac
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Assorted Specialty Pizza by the Slice
- Fried Dough with Hazelnut
- Eggplant Caprese Panini
- NY Style Cheese Pizza
“This was my first time eating at Eduardo’s, and it definitely won’t be my last. The food was absolutely outstanding—every bite was fresh, flavorful, and cooked perfectly. The service was just as exceptional, with a staff that was attentive, welcoming, and made the entire experience enjoyable. I’ve known Jose for years, so it was great to finally experience what he’s built. It’s obvious how much pride and passion goes into this restaurant, and it shows in both the food and the atmosphere. If you’re looking for incredible food, top-notch service, and a place that truly cares about its customers, I highly recommend Eduardo’s. Looking forward to coming back!”
Menu Order
Italian · $
5 Mario's Wood Fired Neapolitan Pizza & Pasta

4.2 Good 140 Reviews

225 US-6, Mahopac
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Chocolate Molton Lava Alla Mode
- Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Pizza
- Arugula & Prosciutto Pizza
- New York Style Cheese Pizza
“look at the size of this slice of cake. 🥲 it is beautiful and just as delicious! i needed to try it before diving into the pizza because come on.. cake. i always like what i get from mario’s and was not disappointed with our door dash order. hooray pizza! hooray huge slices of chocolate cake! i feel like bruce from matilda right now.”
Menu Order
Italian · $
6 Dante's Trattoria

4.2 Good 163 Reviews

135 US-6, Mahopac
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Ravioli with Marinara Sauce
- Mozzarella Sticks Lunch
- Italian Panini Lunch
- Eggplant Parmigiana
“First time there. The food was good, the portions were large and the staff were very friendly and polite but with that being said, the service wasn't all that great. Drove up from the Bronx and even though it was enjoyable, I won't be going back. Why? Because I hate to be "nickel & dimed" ...I never question prices. I order what I want but when the check is upwards of $70 but I see I was charged for both cups of coffee, it's a turn-off! A little advice: let your customers be aware that there are no free refills on a cup of coffee instead of surprising them with a $10 charge for coffee. Good luck!”
Menu Order
Italian · $$
7 IL Villaggio Authentic

4.6 Superb 186 Reviews

947 S Lake Blvd, Mahopac
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Fried Calamari & Caesar Salad
- Gnocchi Bolognese Pasta
- Zuppe De Cozze Mussels
- Pistachio Panna Cotta
“Love the fact they have so many gluten free options. I had a delicious chicken parm dinner with pasta. It was the best one I had in years ❤️”
Menu Order
Italian · $
8 d'Berto Pizzeria

4.1 Good 114 Reviews

995 US-6, Mahopac
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Penne a La Vodka with Shrimp
- Creamy Square Spinach Pizza
- Pasta Fagioli Soup
- Chicken Parmigiana
“This is the Best pizza in Mahopac”
Menu Order
Deli · $
9 Mimi's Kitchen

4.7 Superb 59 Reviews

928 South Lake Boulevard, Mahopac
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Pupusas de Pollo Con Queso
- Pupusas De Chicharron
- Empanada de Pollo
- Tamales de Pollo
““Exquisite pupusas that stand unrivaled in the region. The harmonious blend of chicken, beans, and cheese achieves absolute perfection, complemented by the staff’s gracious hospitality!!!”
Menu Order
Pizza · $
10 Cacciatori Pizza & Pasta -Mahopac

4.5 Superb 188 Reviews

941 South Lake Boulevard, Mahopac
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Eggplant Rollatini
- Mozzarella Sticks
- Fried Calamari
- Slice of Pizza
“Had the best Chicken Bacon Ranch Roll ever. The dough was perfect, the chicken was tasty and the melted cheese mixed with the ranch just put it over the top. Well done. Can’t wait to come back for another one.”
Menu Order
Deli · $$
11 Arthur Avenue Deli

4.5 Superb 115 Reviews

926 US-6, Mahopac
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Chicken Cutlet blt Panini
- The Hammer
- The Patriot
- Wedges
“Ordered sandwiches and antipasto tray for my daughter’s sweet 16 party and everyone said how fresh the meat was. The sandwiches were made perfect they did not fall apart and were cut perfect size. The antipasto tray was fresh as well. First time I went to deli as I’m new in town. Highly recommend. Cannot wait to go back. Thank you to Arthur Avenue Deli!!”
Menu Order
Pizza · $$
12 Marios Wood Fired Mobile Pizza Truck

4.5 Superb 43 Reviews

225 US-6, Mahopac
- Take-Out
- Delivery
“look at the size of this slice of cake. 🥲 it is beautiful and just as delicious! i needed to try it before diving into the pizza because come on.. cake. i always like what i get from mario’s and was not disappointed with our door dash order. hooray pizza! hooray huge slices of chocolate cake! i feel like bruce from matilda right now.”
Menu Order
Pizza · $
13 Mike & Joe's Wood Fired Pizza & Pasta

4.2 Good 194 Reviews

944 US-6, Mahopac
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Apple Cranberry Walnut Salad
- Chocolate Brownie Lava Cake
- Meatball Parmigiana Wedge
- Spaghetti & Meatballs
“I can not say enough good things about Mike and Joe's! The staff is friendly and efficient, they learn their customers and always greet you warmly! They are quick, often delivering faster than expected and the food is always great! If something is wrong they are happy and quick about making it right and they treat their customers so well and generously! I order delivery often and recently ordered catering last minute! Not only were they on time , the food was DELICIOUS, and they gave a sweet something extra! Mike and Joe's always goes the extra mile they are my favourite pizza place now and always! Thank you guys for absolutely everything and being so hardworking and friendly every single day! You guys are wonderful! I'll forever be a Mike and Joe's regular ! 💞”
Menu Order