14 Best Italian Restaurants in Mahopac

My Cousin's American • $$$
954 US-6, Mahopac

Customers` Favorites

Braised Beef Short Rib
Eggplant Bruschetta
Smothered Pork Chop
Eggplant Rollantini
Chicken Milanese
Potato Leek Soup
Fried Calamari
Fried Zucchini
Artichoke Dip
Burrata Salad

“We chose My Cousin's for Mom's surprise 90th Birthday party and I can't rave enough about the professionalism, the Food, and the attention to detail!We met with Alyssa initially in December and she was a delightful pleasure to work with. Subsequent meetings and conversations were equally productive.The day of, Alyssa and David were both on hand assuring that this celebration moved forward like a precision time piece.Additionally! A huge thank you to Mary for her outstanding professionalism and customer care. And lastly the back of house for a delicious meal!“

4.7 Superb125 Reviews
Trattoria Sei Italian • $$
597 US-6, Mahopac

Customers` Favorites

Nutella Pizza with Strawberry
Ceasar Salad with Shrimp
Pappardelle Bolognese
Chicken Scarpariello
NY Style Cheesecake
Eggplant Parmigiana
Chicken Parmigiana
Gnocchi Bolognese
Chicken Milanese
Lobster Risotto

“First time at Trattoria Sei. The inside was nicely decorated, warm ambiance. The food was delicious, very generous portions. I had the Rigatoni Bolognese made with ground beef and veal. Highly recommend it. We also got a salad which was one of the specials and had pickled beets, blueberries, crumbled blue cheese, and it was very delicious! I also have to commend our server, Sophia, who was very attentive to us!“

4.6 Superb75 Reviews
IL Villaggio Authentic Italian • $$
947 S Lake Blvd, Mahopac

Customers` Favorites

Gnocchi Bolognese Pasta
Calamari & Caesar Salad
Zuppe De Cozze Mussels
Roasted Beet Insalate
Spaghetti Carbonara
Argula Insalate
Calamari Fritti
Arugula Salad
Roasted Beets
Penne Vodka

“Last week, my wife and I had the pleasure of dining at Il Villagio. The restaurant was highly recomended to us by my wife's coworker. We were greeted warmly and sat promptly. We had a 6:30 reservation. The service from start to finish was warm, friendly and professional. We started with a crisp tender fried calamari and the roasted beet salad. So many times calamari is a hit or miss. This was an excellent version. The beet salad was tender, earthy and sweet. The crunchy pistacios and orange vinaigrette were a nice touch. My wife ordered Chicken Millanese and I ordered Gnocchi Bolognese. Both were excellent. The chicken was crisp and tender. The arrugula was peppery with a drizzle of lemon and virgin olive oil. Great balance. The Gnocchi was a great choice as there was a chill in the air. My definition of comfort food. Recently I have notice some resturants are going with a cheaper grated cheese, not Il Villagio. The Peccorino was perfectly salty and sharp. During our meal several people came over to check on us including the owner. I told he should be very proud of his staff. This restaurant is doing a great job. The provide quality service, excellent food and a warm friendly staff. It was a 25-30 drive for us. A drive I will be doing again real soon. Thank you to all“

4.4 Superb85 Reviews
Marios Wood Fired Mobile Pizza Truck Pizza • $$
225 US-6, Mahopac

“A cozy Italian-American in Mahopac on Route 6, that is worth a trip from anywhere! The review, may sound like hyperbole, but it's not! A friend mentioned it had good food, great prices, and table service and he was going down there, so we all stopped in for lunch. Great decision. The prices are very reasonable! One of the best Italian-American restaurant/pizzerias I've found in years; and I've eaten more than my share of pizza in many countries. Only top quality ingredients are used! We each ordered a different 12" pizza, one for each of us. In hindsight, we could've ordered one pizza that the three of could have shared and would we have been satiated! My significant other ordered a prosciutto and arugula pizza. She had one at Cancino's in Mexico City November 2019 and LOVED it. We've never seen it on another menu here. So, when she saw it on their menu, she ordered it right away! It was perfect! There was about 4 ounces of arugula and the $20 something a pound prosciutto on it. See the photo. No crispy cremated prosciutto chips nor wilted arugula arrived to the table. My friend had the red meat pizza. It looks like about a pound of sausage meat and a whole pepperoni was sliced and put on his pizza. He kept picking pepperoni off his pizza and putting it on ours. What we had looked like a normal pepperoni pizza; there was that much on his! There was a small group who ordered pasta dishes. They looked great also. Yelpers get a 10% discount.“

4.7 Superb18 Reviews
Arturo's Tavern Italian • $$
878 US-6, Mahopac

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Valdostano with Potato or Vegetable
Linguine and White Clam Sauce
Spaghetti with Meatballs
Chicken Marsala Lunch
Half Chicken Parm Hero
Chicken Scarpariello
Eggplant Parmigiana
Fried Calamari
Zuppa Di Pesce
House Salad

“Nice local New York Italian restaurant. Food is very good...but I gotta ding a place that charges you for each additional tiny cup of coffee. Things are expensive nowadays, at least give free coffee refills, especially with those tiny tiny mugs.“

4.4 Superb48 Reviews
Mimi's Kitchen Deli • $
928 S Lake Blvd, Mahopac

“Food was good. Service was quick the location is nice but it's a little small. I only had typical El Salvadorian pupusas. They were very good. I would go back for those again but seems like a lot of people came for the soups. Which I didn't try. It gets busy but mostly take out. I would order the Spanish food since everyone there is Spanish. I don't think the Italian side of the kitchen will be as good as the el Salvadorian one since there is not Italians cooking it.“

4.7 Superb7 Reviews
Benvenuto's Italian • $$
35 Secor Rd, Mahopac

Customers` Favorites

Peanut Butter Pie with Apples Whip Cream
Dinner Salad with House Dressing on Side
Calamari Fra Diavolo over Linguini
Rigatoni Ala Matriciana
Veggie Lover's Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana
Pizza Margherita
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken Madeira
Slice of Pizza

“Benvenuto's has delicious food. I moved a half an hour away from this establishment, but I still come back to get the best eggplant parmigiana in the world! Great garlic knots and a delicious marinara sauce to boot. Rocky, the owner, is a friendly and fantastic guy. If you want some scrumptious Italian food, check out Benvenuto's in Mahopac. You can't go wrong!“

4.2 Good83 Reviews
Cacciatori Pizza & Pasta -Mahopac Pizza • $
941 S Lake Blvd, Mahopac

Customers` Favorites

Eggplant Rollatini
Mozzarella Sticks
Slice of Pizza
House Dressing
Garlic Knots
Penne Vodka
Salad Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Sicilian
Alfredo

“The food is excellent. As a NYer from Queens and Brooklyn I know pizza. You will love it. Are there better? Perhaps if you search hard but these guys are consistent and delicious and they treat you with respect.It's a pizzeria. You don't go for the ambience. You either have your friends for a slice or you are taking out!I took off one star from service due to a high credit card surcharge which adds a burden. The staff are great.Terrific delivery staff.Parking: It's a busy part of town.But they deliver!“

4.2 Good38 Reviews
d'Berto Pizzeria Italian • $
995 US-6, Mahopac

Customers` Favorites

Creamy Square Spinach Pizza
Pasta Fagioli Soup
Grandma Pizza
Cannolis
Chicken
D

“Pizza and salads were excellent. I ordered thru an app and was informed to pick up at 5:30. When I arrived at 5:30, I had to wait another 15 minutes for the food to be ready. I counted 13 other people also waiting for pickup at the same time.“

3.8 Good22 Reviews
Mario's Wood Fired Pizza And Pasta Italian • $
225 US-6, Mahopac

Customers` Favorites

Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Pizza
Arugula & Prosciutto Pizza
Fresh Stuffed Cannoli
Mussels Marinara
Wood Fired Wings
Baked Clams
Octopus

“It's a pizzeria, nothing fancy, but the food, especially the pizza is beyond fabulous. If you like tender calamari, you must order it here. You will not find better anywhere. If you are lucky enough to come when Mario make his homemade bread, you are not going to want to share it.“

3.9 Good41 Reviews
Mike & Joe's Wood Fired Pizza & Pasta Pizza • $
944 US-6, Mahopac

Customers` Favorites

Apple Cranberry Walnut Salad
Chocolate Brownie Lava Cake
Meatball Parmigiana Wedge
Pappardelle Bolognese
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Francese
Margherita Pizza

“Mike and joes Mahopac has been a family favorite for years, the family is always welcoming and food is always good, many choices in the showcase so I can never decide because I have never had a bad meal! Bartenders are the best! Music is nice and, never have to wait long. This place is a FACTORY! Thank you Viktor see you again soon!“

3.8 Good63 Reviews
Dante's Trattoria Italian • $
135 US-6, Mahopac

Customers` Favorites

Ravioli with Marinara Sauce
Mozzarella Sticks Lunch
Italian Panini Lunch
Gnocchi Bolognese
Fried Mozzarella
Olives Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Meat Sauce
Calamari

“This is strictly regarding takeout:Lady that answers my calls is always graciously politeDelivery guys are just as graciously politeI haven’t ordered everything on the menu, however I have ordered ALOT of items (different apps, entrees, sandwiches and pies) and everything is always properly packed and deliciousHighly recommend?“

3.7 Good43 Reviews
Eduardo's Trattoria Italian • $$
115 Secor Rd, Mahopac

Customers` Favorites

Assorted Specialty Pizza by the Slice
Fried Dough with Hazelnut
Eggplant Caprese Panini
NY Style Cheese Pizza
Chicken Francaise
Tortellini Nonna
Fried Calamari
Garlic Bread
Baked Clams
Meatballs

“I've been going to Eduardo's for several years now with friends weekly, and I've never left disappointed. For a cozy spot tucked away on Secor Road, I remember thinking upon trying it the first time that the food was remarkable. Nothing has changed since...and I've sampled many dishes over that time. The service is impeccable, and one of the reasons I look forward each week to my visit. You never know where you're going to find a jewel.“

3.6 Good35 Reviews
Savor Restaurant and Bar Italian • $$
18 Clark Pl, Mahopac

Customers` Favorites

Traditional Fried Calamari
Shrimp Scampi Risotto
Savor House Salad GF
Chicken Parmigiana
Risotto Rice Cake
Truffle Arancini

“I have taken out and catered on several occasions from this italian restaurant and I have never been deceived. The Wild Truffle Mushroom Raviolis are a hit. Also excellent dishes are any of the seafood platters: grilled octopus, coconut shrimp, fried calamari… everyone raved about the food during our party gatherings. Our go-to local fare favorite.“

3.8 Good140 Reviews
Loading...
map Map