10 Best Pizza Restaurants in Mahopac

“A cozy Italian-American in Mahopac on Route 6, that is worth a trip from anywhere! The review, may sound like hyperbole, but it's not! A friend mentioned it had good food, great prices, and table service and he was going down there, so we all stopped in for lunch. Great decision. The prices are very reasonable! One of the best Italian-American restaurant/pizzerias I've found in years; and I've eaten more than my share of pizza in many countries. Only top quality ingredients are used! We each ordered a different 12" pizza, one for each of us. In hindsight, we could've ordered one pizza that the three of could have shared and would we have been satiated! My significant other ordered a prosciutto and arugula pizza. She had one at Cancino's in Mexico City November 2019 and LOVED it. We've never seen it on another menu here. So, when she saw it on their menu, she ordered it right away! It was perfect! There was about 4 ounces of arugula and the $20 something a pound prosciutto on it. See the photo. No crispy cremated prosciutto chips nor wilted arugula arrived to the table. My friend had the red meat pizza. It looks like about a pound of sausage meat and a whole pepperoni was sliced and put on his pizza. He kept picking pepperoni off his pizza and putting it on ours. What we had looked like a normal pepperoni pizza; there was that much on his! There was a small group who ordered pasta dishes. They looked great also. Yelpers get a 10% discount.“

“Benvenuto's has delicious food. I moved a half an hour away from this establishment, but I still come back to get the best eggplant parmigiana in the world! Great garlic knots and a delicious marinara sauce to boot. Rocky, the owner, is a friendly and fantastic guy. If you want some scrumptious Italian food, check out Benvenuto's in Mahopac. You can't go wrong!“

“The food is excellent. As a NYer from Queens and Brooklyn I know pizza. You will love it. Are there better? Perhaps if you search hard but these guys are consistent and delicious and they treat you with respect.It's a pizzeria. You don't go for the ambience. You either have your friends for a slice or you are taking out!I took off one star from service due to a high credit card surcharge which adds a burden. The staff are great.Terrific delivery staff.Parking: It's a busy part of town.But they deliver!“

“My favorite pizzeria in Mahopac! The staff is really friendly, great environment, plenty of seating, parking and delicious food. Salads are always fresh and they have Italian ices!!!! My family and I look foward to ordering from Zach’s on pizza Fridays.“

“It's a pizzeria, nothing fancy, but the food, especially the pizza is beyond fabulous. If you like tender calamari, you must order it here. You will not find better anywhere. If you are lucky enough to come when Mario make his homemade bread, you are not going to want to share it.“

“Pizza and salads were excellent. I ordered thru an app and was informed to pick up at 5:30. When I arrived at 5:30, I had to wait another 15 minutes for the food to be ready. I counted 13 other people also waiting for pickup at the same time.“

“Mike and joes Mahopac has been a family favorite for years, the family is always welcoming and food is always good, many choices in the showcase so I can never decide because I have never had a bad meal! Bartenders are the best! Music is nice and, never have to wait long. This place is a FACTORY! Thank you Viktor see you again soon!“

“This is strictly regarding takeout:Lady that answers my calls is always graciously politeDelivery guys are just as graciously politeI haven’t ordered everything on the menu, however I have ordered ALOT of items (different apps, entrees, sandwiches and pies) and everything is always properly packed and deliciousHighly recommend?“

“I've been going to Eduardo's for several years now with friends weekly, and I've never left disappointed. For a cozy spot tucked away on Secor Road, I remember thinking upon trying it the first time that the food was remarkable. Nothing has changed since...and I've sampled many dishes over that time. The service is impeccable, and one of the reasons I look forward each week to my visit. You never know where you're going to find a jewel.“

“Food is always delicious and no matter how crowded it gets the service is fantastic!Dietary restrictions: They are able to accommodate my gluten and dairy allergies easily. Always delicious food and have never had a problem with allergic reactions or cross contamination.“