11 Best Italian Restaurants in New City

Mille Luci Pizzeria Italian • $$
170 N Main St, New City

Customers` Favorites

Prosciutto E Burrata Pizza
Snow White Pizza 1 ft Pala
Margherita Pizza Slices
Sausage & Peppers Pizza
Pistachio Ricotta Cake
Vodka Margherita Pizza
Asparagus Bruschetta
Meatball Panuozzo
San Daniele Pizza
Nonna's Meatballs

“Excellent! Food was so fresh and fabulous and so was the service. Pizza crust was delicious and light. Everyone was so very nice and accommodating. Great atmosphere and concept of Pizza by the foot. So good that weekends are packed, so make a reservation or try a weeknight. You will not be disappointed!“

5 Superb260 Reviews
Alfredo’s Restaurant Italian • $$
189 S Main St, New City

Customers` Favorites

Veal and Eggplant Parmigiana
Linguini in Clam Sauce
Eggplant Rolentini
Pasta Primavera
Chicken Marsala
Chicken Piccata
Spicy Calamari
Bread Dip
Tiramisu
Veal Chop

“My wife and I have been there 4 times in a row and each time have had a fantastic experience! The food , drinks, service , and the staff are excellent. It’s a very affordable place to Dine out. We highly recommend this restaurant! It really is a hidden Gem in New City. Go and invite your friends, you will all be pleasantly surprised!!! Reservation is definitely recommended…it get busy! Enjoyyyy😎“

4.7 Superb81 Reviews
Dom To Go Italian • $
145 S Main St, New City

Customers` Favorites

Caesar Salad

“Every single thing I get from here fabulous , delicious! So thank you guys so much!“

4.9 Superb26 Reviews
La Terrazza Italian • $$
291 S Main St, New City

Customers` Favorites

Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken Cutlet
Fussilli with Grilled Shrimp
Filet Mignon with Mushrooms
Crabmeat & Mango Salad
Mozzarella En Carozza
Cappuccino Ala Jimmy
Tortellini Carbonara
Chicken Scarpariello
Roasted Vegetables
Rigatoni Bolognese

“Just finished Sunday Brunch at La Terrazza, and we cannot say enough good things about this restaurant. Brett and his crew never disappoint. The food is delicious, the ambiance is amazing and the service is the absolute best! The staff is friendly, attentive and makes us feel like family. Our server today was Lee, and she was absolutely fantastic! We have also had excellent experiences with Leslie, Maryanne, Margaret and Jeanie. If we could give more than 5 stars, we would.“

4.5 Superb116 Reviews
Mangia Pizza & Restaurant Italian • $
68 N Main St, New City

“Outstanding, delicious Italian food, the best pizza- we love this place.“

4.6 Superb37 Reviews
Ella New York Pizza and Pasta Italian • $$
137 S Main St, New City

Customers` Favorites

Greek Salad with Chicken
Chicken Parmigiana
Fettuccine Alfredo
Chicken Francese
Pepperoni Pizza
Mom's Lasagna

“Great little spot. The food has been spot on. Wait staff is friendly. Will go again. And will recommend“

4 Good755 Reviews
Norcina Italian • $$
186 N Main St, New City

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Melon with Grilled Marinated Shrimp Salad
Pizza with Arugula Mushrooms and Olives
Charred Brussels Caesar
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Homemade Doughnuts
Short Rib Lasagna
Housemade Burrata
Rigatoni Ragu
Chicken Parm
Caesar Salad

“Great atmosphere. comfortable not snotty“

4.1 Good85 Reviews
Michael's on Main American • $$
381 S Main St, New City

Customers` Favorites

Pork Chop with Mashed Potatoes and Broccoli
Linguini with Clam Sauce
Chicken Parmigiana
Angry Lobster Tail
Grilled Pork Chop
Chicken Milanese
Shrimp Cocktail
Chicken Marsala
Lobster Risotto
Patatas Bravas

“Great Place,Great Food,Very Friendly people working, Been there 3 times in two weeks and have had nothing but good things to say. Thanks for a great experience“

4.8 Superb87 Reviews
Leonardo's Italian Deli & Catering Deli • $
14 N Main St, New City

Customers` Favorites

33 Cowabunga Pizza Bread
Chopped Cheese Sandwich
American Combo Sandwich
Gabagool Egg & Cheese
Eggplant Cutlet Salad
Turkey Club Sandwich
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Eggplant Parmigiana
Kiki's Greek Salad
Chicken Cutlet

“The best BEC in all of Rockland and most of North Jersey. It's a 2 napkin sandwich that is so good and under $8 bucks, how can you go wrong.“

4.7 Superb78 Reviews
Napoli's Pizza & Catering Pizza • $
48 Germonds Rd, New City

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Cutlet with Lettuce Tomato and Mayo
Chicken Fingers and French Fries
Plain Slice of Cheese Pizza
Penne Vodka with Chicken
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Chicken Wings
Garlic Knots
White Pizza

“Napoli’s Pizza & Catering easily earns a full 5 stars from me. This place is exactly what you hope for when you’re craving real, quality pizza made by people who clearly care about what they’re serving. From the moment you walk in, the place has that classic, comfortable pizza-shop feel—warm, welcoming, and filled with the smell of fresh dough baking.

The food is the star here. The pizza has that perfect balance: a crisp crust with just the right chew, flavorful sauce, and cheese that actually tastes like something—not the bland stuff you get at a lot of places. You can tell they use good ingredients, and everything is prepared with pride. Their slices come out hot, fresh, and full of flavor every single time. We also tried a few other menu items, and everything was just as good as the pizza.

Service is fast, friendly, and genuine. You don’t feel rushed, and you don’t feel ignored—they strike the perfect balance. The staff treats you like you’ve been coming there for years, even if it’s your first time.

The atmosphere is simple but clean and relaxing, making it great for grabbing a slice, eating with family, or picking up a larger order for a gathering.

Overall, Napoli’s is absolutely worth 5 stars—great pizza, great service, and great people. A must-stop spot for anyone who loves real, quality food“

4.4 Superb49 Reviews
Paisanos Pizza Pizza • $
730 NY-304, New City

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Knots with Side of Sauce 6 Pieces
Grilled Chicken Salad
Plain Cheese Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
Margherita Pizza
Slice of Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
Marinara Sauce
Garlic Bread
House Salad

“The food is great here and I absolutely love the girl who answers the phone & takes the orders and does deliveries, she is so sweet and kind and the pizza here is really great. The dough smells wonderful and they do a great job with delivering in a timely fashion. Thank you so much Paesanos!“

4 Good57 Reviews

You May Also Like