14 Best Sandwich Shops near New Windsor

“As soon as I walked in, Joshua greeted me. He probably would have started my order right then if I yelled it to him. He was attentive, engaging, and very pleasant throughout.

The restaurant was clean, the beverage fridge was fully stocked, and he seemed to be on his own. Great experience. Keep up the great work, Josh.

And the soundtrack was primo.“

“Great food and great staff the Big Mac tots are amazing gluten free friendly and the burgers are very good also just wish they had them all the time“

“Got a small cheesesteak sub cheese whiz was good sloppy but good frelies are good also“

“It was very good I was with My mom and she even said she enjoyed it we will be back again to eat their“

“I swung by Jersey Mikes a couple of days ago because I was too lazy to cook. I ordered a gluten-free sub, and you know how it is—ordering gluten-free can feel like I’m asking for trouble, with everyone having to sanitize everything and the staff looking a bit frazzled. But the Jersey Mikes staff was amazing! They greeted me with a smile and a “no worries” attitude, which I always love. A young man, who I believe is named Travis, or a name that starts with a T took care of my sandwich with such care, making sure the knife was spotless and nothing else touched it. I’m definitely coming back!“

“My first time to Jersey Mike’s was today. I ordered my favorite sandwich, a BLT and it was delicious. Plenty of perfectly cooked bacon! The store is very clean and it’s nicely decorated. I will definitely be returning.“

“Stopped by while riding my bike, got a steak and take which was so much more than I was expecting. Def coming back for the fish“

“This was my first time trying jersey Mike's, and at the beginning, I thought it was going to be something similar to Subway. But I was so wrong, my big surprise was to see them preparing fresh meat on a grill, no a microwave heat. The taste was excellent. Really happy with the experience.“

“Friendly, efficient, fresh, clean. All good!“

“Nice subway Harry good guy Nice food i like this place“

“This Subway is great with the food quality, but the atmosphere and service aren't above average. I also find it difficult to get the drinks I order with my meals in the mobile app. They always seem to not carry what I pick from the menu.“

“best in the area ,the chef in amazing“