15 Best Sandwich Shops near Peekskill

“Amazing sandwiches!!! So sad I missed the interior decorator but hopefully it comes back!“

“I was on and out of town visit when I dropped by the store. The sandwich I usually get consists of vegetables only: spinach, cucumber, tomatoes, olives and banana peppers. Many stores act as if the spinach is just a topping rather than the base of the sandwich. This shop made the sandwich nicely. I had no complaints. They staff was also very patient while I signed into the subway app as I had forgotten my password and it took more time than usual. Overall, it was a very pleasant experience.“

“Kathleen’s Tea Room ambience transports you to an ethereal place in time! The lovely ladies there present you with a menu filled with culinary delights. My granddaughter and I selected the Princess. The three tiers were filled with delicious small sandwiches, fresh fruit and sinfully good desserts. The tea was one I had never tasted! Delicious! I recommend you frequent Kathleen’s often with friends and family. I’m already planning my next trip to taste their great sandwiches.“

“I had the opportunity of meeting the owner during Aug, 2026....He is by far the nicest person I have met in the last few years and his food is the same as his personality...Superb!!!“

“Oh my god. This was delicious. Just finished devouring my hero Philly cheese steak. Found this place on a whim after finishing a nearby hike. Service was great, smooth jazz in the background. I'm going to sleep like a BABY tonight. Will be back after the next hike.“

“great sandwiches terrific people who there and Frankie...!!“

“This is the best subway store I’ve ever been to! It has everything you want as a customer: delicious and fresh food, very clean, and VERY friendly and professional staff. They inform you of meal deals, so you pay less and get more. 10/10 highly recommend supporting this business!“

“The manager and crew are so welcoming, polite and friendly. Sandwiches were delicious!! The place itself was immaculate. Will definitely be coming back. My first Jersey Mike’s experience was in Nanuet and because of the rude manager I would rather drive further to Stonypoint where the energy is positive.“

“I order Buffalo wings and they never put any sauce on them just dry wings fix your wings cheapskates“

“I got there just as they were about to close and they still made me a hot lunch, that alone would have been worth 5 stars to me. But wow that was the best chicken parm hero Iv had in Rockland in the 5 years Iv been working down here. Thank you!“

“Nice subway Harry good guy Nice food i like this place“

“Food is good always when I come here and sew the service. But when I tried the new footlong pretzel by the time I Was home? It was hard and not really soft or good to eat. I guess you have to eat these in a certain amount of time within getting them.“

“Great food! Great people! 🙏 Had amazing chicken soup yesterday from Vic's Deli. 😋 Everyday delicious AUTHENTIC Spanish food.“

“I get the sub of the day everytme I go and make it a meal all for less than 7.00, plus 10% more if 6ou use the military star card on the base. Sandwiches are what I remember from years ago. Flavors and developed a little, but thie sauce are a great addition. Dining area was clean, good ambiance with music, all you can drink sodas and teas.“