Café Colmado
$ • Coffee ShopsAbout Café Colmado
Café Colmado Reviews
93 ratings
Share your opinion about Café Colmado
5 stars without hesitation.
From the moment I walked in, this place took me back home to Puerto Rico. The service was warm, the atmosphere felt familiar, and the food brought back memories I didn’t even realize I was missing.
It’s more than just a good meal.. it’s that feeling of home, nostalgia, and pride all wrapped into one experience.
If you’re in the area or anywhere in NYC. This place is absolutely worth the ride. I’ll definitely...read full review
From the moment I walked in, this place took me back home to Puerto Rico. The service was warm, the atmosphere felt familiar, and the food brought back memories I didn’t even realize I was missing.
It’s more than just a good meal.. it’s that feeling of home, nostalgia, and pride all wrapped into one experience.
If you’re in the area or anywhere in NYC. This place is absolutely worth the ride. I’ll definitely...read full review
Cafe Colmado is such a gem! The coffee is always on point, and the staff is incredibly sweet and welcoming (Mia is my fave). I especially love sitting here and sipping my coffee because the atmosphere is so inviting and cozy. It’s the kind of spot that makes you want to stay awhile, and enjoy the moment. Definitely one of my favorite local spots!
The Coquito lattes here are absolutely incredible! That said, I was really disappointed to find they were out of Mallorcas during my visit—I’d been looking forward to one all day. I’d love to see them stock a wider variety of Puerto Rican pastries and sandwiches, and keep them consistently available. The drinks are a home run, but expanding and restocking the bakery case would make this spot a total 10/10.
Hours
| Monday | 9AM - 6PM |
| Tuesday | 9AM - 6PM |
| Wednesday | 9AM - 6PM |
| Thursday | 9AM - 6PM |
| Friday | 9AM - 6PM |
| Saturday | 8AM - 6PM |
| Sunday | 8AM - 6PM |
Café Colmado is a welcoming and lively spot known for its authentic vibe and friendly staff. Visitors appreciate the excellent coffee selection, with standout drinks like the Coquito Matcha and passionfruit Matcha, which are highly recommended. The staff take the time to understand customers' preferences, offering tastings and great recommendations, creating a personalized experience. The atmosphere is warm and cozy, featuring plastic-covered couches and a domino table that contribute to a relaxed, inviting environment. The cafe often hosts pop-up events, bringing in lively music and a fun crowd, which adds to its vibrant ambiance. While some find the music loud and the coquito latte a bit pricey, most reviews highlight the quality of the drinks and the enjoyable environment. The place is also praised for its good wifi, making it a perfect spot to work or relax. Overall, Café Colmado offers a mix of good coffee, friendly service, and a fun, authentic atmosphere that keeps visitors coming back. It’s a great place to spend a morning or meet friends, with a unique vibe that feels both lively and cozy.