Carnegie Deli at Madison Square Garden
$ • Deli
4 Pennsylvania Plaza Sections 105/106 and 219, New York
(212) 465-6225
About Carnegie Deli at Madison Square Garden
Customers' Favorites
Recent Reviews
Share your opinion about Carnegie Deli at Madison Square Garden
The food, history the hustle, the people, and desert were outstanding!!!
The sandwiches are outstanding
wish I could say the food is great, but I cant because I never got to try it. I ordered the pastrami sandwich kit. They sent frozen food in a bag with dry ice and 2 day ship?? The first order came and it was 80 degrees inside box. They resent another and packed the same way and sent 2 day. Order came and was 78 degrees. In the trash a second time. I contacted customer service once again and they sent out a third order, packed the exact same way and first two orders and this one...read full review
Menu
Carnegie Deli at Madison Square Garden offers a high-end diner experience with great food and friendly service. Guests have praised the staff, particularly Penny and Felipe, for their attentive and personable service, ensuring drinks are full and food is served hot. The restaurant is known for its quality sandwiches and cheesecakes, reminiscent of the beloved original location, though some feel it lacks the charm of its predecessor. While many reviews highlight enjoyable meals and a pleasant atmosphere, there are criticisms regarding the quality of certain items, including dry sandwiches and small portions of coleslaw. Despite mixed opinions, the establishment maintains a loyal following, with visitors appreciating the overall dining experience and the helpful workers.