Hill and Bay

$$ • New American, American, Cocktail Bar

Hours:
581 2nd Ave, New York
(212) 245-5554

Customers' Favorites

Hill and Bay Reviews

Restaurantji Rating
4.2 (61)
Restaurantji Rating

Cute bar/cafe atmosphere in the city. Old movie posters on the wall and exposed brick give the space character. Our server was super friendly and knowledgeable about the menu. We did not have a wait at all but that may have been because it was Easter Sunday. I had the eggs Benedict and my only complaint was that the hollandaise was bland. The cucumber ginger juice blend I had was delicious. Others in my party enjoyed their food. The French onion soup was good, the waffles...read full review

Restaurantji Rating

Hill and bay has now become one of our favorite eating places. Good atmosphere, great food, and the service was on point. Our server was patient, friendly, helpful, and kind. I enjoyed the date night with my wife that evening. Thank you.

Restaurantji Rating

Hill and Bay has become an integral part of my morning routine, thanks to its convenient walk-through window for coffee enthusiasts like me. This spot has elevated my coffee experience, and I can't help but appreciate the fantastic service, especially from the energetic and friendly barista, Jose.The walk-through window is a major plus for those on the go, providing a quick and efficient way to start the day with a freshly brewed cup of coffee. The convenience of this service...read full review

More Reviews(325)

Ratings

Hours

Monday 8AM - 9PM
Tuesday 8AM - 9PM
Wednesday 8AM - 10PM
Thursday 8AM - 10PM
Friday 8AM - 11PM
Saturday 8AM - 11PM
Sunday 8AM - 10PM
Updated on: