Mama Mia 44SW
$$ • Italian Book a table: 7:00 PM 7:15 PM 7:30 PM MoreAbout Mama Mia 44SW
Customers' Favorites
Linguine Bolognese with Tomato Meat Sauce
Chicken Parmigiana with Penne Marinara
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Fettuccine Alfredo
Homemade Tiramisu
Penne Puttanesca
Penne Alla Vodka
Pizza Margherita
Chicken Francese
Chicken Marsala
Mama Mia 44SW Reviews
596 ratings
Share your opinion about Mama Mia 44SW
My sister and I have been visiting New York for the past 10 years! Mama Mia 44sw Restaurant has been one of the best restaurants I’ve been too.
I ordered the chicken Marsala. Everything about this dish was delicious. I was even contemplating on ordering another one to go and packing it in my suitcase. I kid you not! My sister ordered the margarita pizza! It wasn’t any ordinary pizza, everything was cooked perfect! We were very pleased with our last dinner in New York!
Connie...read full review
I ordered the chicken Marsala. Everything about this dish was delicious. I was even contemplating on ordering another one to go and packing it in my suitcase. I kid you not! My sister ordered the margarita pizza! It wasn’t any ordinary pizza, everything was cooked perfect! We were very pleased with our last dinner in New York!
Connie...read full review
This was seriously the most AMAZING experience in a restaurant ever!!!! Not only was the food AMAZING but the family is as well!!!!! Connie and Cristina are soooooo sweet and Mama Mia is the sweetest lady ever! They really make you feel welcome and by the time you are finished you feel as though you are part of the family! Thank you again for welcoming us and creating a new memory!!!
Excellent service from Tiago our waiter. Food was excellent and the staff was very accommodating. Can’t wait to return.
Hours
| Monday | 4 - 10:30PM |
| Tuesday | 4 - 10:30PM |
| Wednesday | 4 - 10:30PM |
| Thursday | 4 - 10:30PM |
| Friday | 12 - 11PM |
| Saturday | 12 - 11PM |
| Sunday | 12 - 10:30PM |
Mama Mia 44SW is a charming family-owned restaurant located near the theater district, making it a convenient choice for pre- or post-show dining. The owner, Connie, welcomes guests warmly, creating a home-like atmosphere. Diners have praised the delicious food, with standout dishes like Chicken 44, Chicken Marsala, and pesto penne with roasted peppers and chicken. The steak with mashed potatoes also received positive remarks. However, some guests have noted issues with slow service on recent visits, as well as occasional mix-ups with orders. While the ambiance is generally pleasant, there have been complaints regarding the air conditioning on hot days.
The restaurant offers a reasonable weekend brunch deal and is a fun spot to enjoy a drink at the bar. Guests should be aware that certain items, such as garlic bread, come with an extra charge, which may not be expected. Overall, Mama Mia 44SW is appreciated for its comforting home-cooked meals and friendly service, making it a worthwhile stop for those in the area, especially when attending a nearby show.