Mama's Pizzeria
CLOSED$ •
About Mama's Pizzeria
Mama's Pizzeria Reviews
Good pizza
One of the best pizzas by the slice in
It's okay. For the price, I feel like it could be better. But a solid option if you're someone who loves a lot of cheese.
Mama's Pizzeria is a popular spot for delicious pizza, known for its traditional New York City style. Many customers praise the authentic slices like pepperoni and grandma, which are considered some of the best "normal" pizza options on the UWS. The pizza is fresh, and orders are served quickly, making it a great choice for a quick, satisfying meal. The restaurant has a simple setup with big windows, though wind can sometimes be an issue. The staff are friendly, prompt, and helpful, providing good service even during busy times. Vegetarian options are available upon request. The restaurant accepts cash only, but an ATM is on the premises. Overall, Mama's Pizzeria offers consistent taste and quality, making it a favorite for locals and tourists alike.