Mimi's Pizza (3rd Ave & 86th)
$ • PizzaAbout Mimi's Pizza (3rd Ave & 86th)
Customers' Favorites
Rigatoni Pasta with Vodka Sauce
Denso Pepperoni Pizza Slice Sq
Denso Pepperoni Grandma Pizza
Bianca E Pepe Pizza Slice Sq
Garlic Knots with Mozzarella
San Gennaro Grandma Pizza
Bianca Square Pizza Slice
San Gennaro Pizza Grandma
Pepperoni Sicilian Pizza
Sicilian Style Pizza
Recent Reviews
348 ratings
Share your opinion about Mimi's Pizza (3rd Ave & 86th)
I'm sooo sad. I just found out about the closing today, because I wanted to drive to the city to get a favorite slice from my childhood days. My dad used to bring me home a plain slice on Saturdays back in the 70s, on his way home from Lyric HiFi a few blocks away. Best wishes to Mimi's. I'll never find another slice like yours.
I just tuned into an episode of The Best Food I Ever Ate to watch Bobbly Flay gush over how great Mimi's was. I miss my after work and school slices at Mimi's!
Was in town for a week, this spot was close and was a local favorite and it absolutely dis NOT dissapoint. True NY pizza. Delish!
Hours
| Monday | 10AM - 11PM |
| Tuesday | 10AM - 2AM |
| Wednesday | 10AM - 2AM |
| Thursday | 10AM - 2AM |
| Friday | 10AM - 4AM |
| Saturday | 10AM - 4AM |
| Sunday | 10AM - 2AM |
Mimi's Pizza (3rd Ave & 86th) offers a classic New York-style pizza experience with a focus on consistent quality. The thin crust and the perfect cheese-to-sauce ratio make it a favorite among locals. Customers often enjoy the square slices, which emphasize sauce over cheese, with the sauce being fragrant and slightly sweet. The pizza is known for its crispy crust, even for takeout, and the slices are praised for their delicious flavor and consistency, whether visited in the afternoon or late at night. The buffalo chicken slice is a standout, offering a tasty balance of flavors. Many visitors comment that the pizza has a unique, tasty flavor that is both distinctly New York but different, similar to a thinner, crispier mama too square style. The flavors come together well without being too saucy, and it’s also good cold.
The restaurant is kid-friendly and wheelchair accessible, with friendly and efficient staff. Though indoor seating is limited, an outdoor area near the Shake provides extra space. Customers often mention that the aroma of the pizza is so tempting that it’s hard to resist following their nose for a slice, and many say it’s the best grandma marg slice they’ve had. Besides pizza, the place also serves other popular items like spaghetti bolognese with garlic knots, making it a versatile spot for various tastes at reasonable prices. Visitors appreciate the perfect crunch, right price, and quick service, making it a real deal for pizza lovers.