Tolleson's Pizzeria


419 N Main St, Newark
(315) 332-8008


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Tolleson's Pizzeria

Best pizza in the town, great deals on mondays and Tuesdays pizza is like $12. Might not be in the greatest part of town, but the town doesn't look that great to begin with. Don't judge a book by its cover, best pizza you'll find in Newark. I've never had any problems ordering and it's always been ready within 30 minutes

So we decided to try the new Marion location. We ordered 10 BBQ wings with an extra sauce and a medium THIN crust Greek specialty pizza. The total was over $28. What we got was not crispy flavorless wings with no extra sauce and a pizza that was anything but thin crust. On the plus side, the flavor of the pizza was good.

I've been ordering from Tolleson's for well over a year. I have never had a bad experience and customer service is always excellent. The Godfather pizza is my favorite and is very unique. I bring my grandsons here and they love coming down to see the pizza man.

More Reviews(47)


Monday 10AM - 10PM
Tuesday 10AM - 10PM
Wednesday 10AM - 10PM
Thursday 10AM - 10PM
Friday 10AM - 11PM
Saturday 10AM - 11PM
Sunday 11AM - 8PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.