21 Best Pizza Restaurants in Newburgh

“Delicious food! Great service.“

“Regular at Pizza Mia, my favorite slot for a slice on a lunch break in Newburgh. Location is convenient and near places to shop. The creative slices are filling, tasty, and the people here care about their end product. Their service is always above and beyond. 100% recommend stopping in and trying a unique slice that catches your eye. You won’t be disappointed!“

“We ordered trays of wraps and salads yesterday for my daughter in laws baby shower. Every wrap was delicious, fresh and beautifully laid out on trays. The macaroni and potato salad were just like homemade! It was all perfect for the occasion! Will definitely use them for every party!!“

“Excellent marina We loved both the itilian hero and the eggplant pizza“

“AMAZING and DELICIOUS!!! We are from Savannah, GA and was celebrating my son's graduation and ordered lg pepperoni pizza for delivery 45min b4 closing 😳. After ordering, we get a call from here right away to inform us they were out of bread 😫 (ordered a sandwich as well) So we did a stromboli instead. They were so nice over the phone and fast delivery!! Everything was delicious!“

“Pizza is so cheap and HELLA good literally $1/$2 slices! The owner is so kind. The wings flavors are sooo good. I’m always tempted to ask for a bottle of the sauce. The fries are addictive. Haven’t had a burger yet but I’m definitely tempted. Highly recommend.“

“Best italian food around !😁❣️“

“J & F is, by far, one of the best pizzerias in the City of Newburgh. It is responsible for the inspiration of the fictional Little Nero's Pizza for the Home Alone movies. J & F Pizza is also an equivalent to Manhattan's Ray's Pizza, which also serves pizzas.“

“Loved it Tiana did a great job she’s the best waitress“

“The Best pizza I’ve had since coming back to NY!!!❤️“

“The best pizza in Newburgh and the service is always great!“

“Chicken Tacos were AWESOME!! Haven’t taste any other that good ??. Thank You, and keep up the good work!!“

“This place has become a perennial favorite for date night with my wife when we want to venture outside of our hometown.

As always the service was excellent from the bartender Christina, as was her recommendation of the sweet Thai ginger mussels.

I have yet to try something here that I don't like. From the appetizers, to the pizzas, to the blackened chicken alfredo (my wife knew I enjoyed it because it got the closed eye smile that I get when I'm depriving myself of sight to focus on taste )

I also thoroughly enjoyed the spicy pomegranate margarita that the spicy rum complimented just right.“

“I wanted to do a survey because I was not able to leave a tip (computer issue) and I know how hard these food service workers are working right now. Then my receipt didn’t have a code but I wanted to make sure that I was able to share my good experience. I had great service at the Newburgh location. I was greeted warmly by a sweet young lady, Aaliyah who had my two hot medium pizzas waiting for me and she was fast and friendly. Although it was late and I’m sure she worked a long shift, she still had a big smile as I walked in the door. Everyone enjoyed their food.“

“A great and always reliable pizzeria in Newburgh's Mid-Valley Mall. The pizza tastes great and their garlic knots are some of the best in the area. At $1 a knot, it's a great deal. The staff is friendly and accommodating. Their speed of service is top-notch as you will never be waiting a long time for your meal if you order at the location. Overall, this is one of the best pizzerias in the area and a convenient quick bite if you're doing business in the plaza.“

“best in the area ,the chef in amazing“

“It's Little Caesars. You know they use cheap ingredients for their pizzas, hence the affordable (Or once affordable) pricing. You know they're cutting corners, if you know anything about how they're able to sell pizzas at the price that they do. So you're not coming in here expecting the "best pizza of your life". But, it's pizza. It's decent and it's affordable. That's why we go to Little Caesar's. It's hit or miss, so I gave it three stars but when it's on point, it's on point. I usually just order and pick it up from the deploy machine to avoid the lines. I'd use the app, as you can customize if you want things like more sauce, less sauce, more cheese, etc. They usually hook me up with a free crazy sauce without being a sauce-protector lol.“

“This place is a casual pizzeria with really good other options as well.
Specifically my friends and I ordered a chicken parm sandwich, Italian combo hero, and the steak pesto combo, as well as drinks. The portions were generous and the food was delicious. We went there for lunch and they were fast enough for everything to go there as a lunch break again.
$10- $15 a meal including tip to the server.

Vegetarian options: Lots of sauces without meat, just ask.

Dietary restrictions: Very accommodating just let them know before you order.

Kid-friendliness: It’s a very casual environment you would have no problems with children being children“

“Best pizza, Stromboli and pasta ever and friendly staff! Whenever we go to NY from Massachusetts it’s our go to place!!! Thanks for the great Italian pizza!“

“Loved the pizza. It’s away fresh“

“I was at mister pizza last week and the pizza was excellent.“