13 Best Pizza Restaurants in New Windsor

“Mamma Mia Cafe and Pizzeria is a a venue that excels in providing mouth-watering dishes, attentive service, and a welcoming environment that feels like a home away from home.“

“After calling several pizza places yesterday (that said that they were not delivering and one which was very rude )we called Pizza Heaven they were very nice and professional on the phone and got our order to us real fast !the food was awesome! Being a very busy business we don’t have time for the nonsense if you deliver then deliver !don’t tell us one day you deliver and one day you don’t (this is our experience with the OTHER pizza places NOT Pizza Heaven! )We had a great lunch because of them “thank you”!!!!!we will order again for sure!“

“Always good But the best today Ty George you’re daughter and your staff“

“Mama’s Theresa’s in New Windsor is a fantastic spot for both takeout and dining in with the family. The food is always fresh, flavorful, and consistent—everything tastes like it’s made with care, not rushed out of a kitchen.

The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, perfect for a relaxed family meal. On top of that, the service is excellent—staff is friendly, attentive, and makes you feel right at home from the moment you walk in.

If you’re in the area and want great Italian food without the headache, this is definitely a go-to spot.“

“Great slice ALWAYS , regardless of day of week. Other pizza places have old undercooked slice pies that taste old and undercooked even when they are re heated . Not here never a bad slice
One day I will order a pie im sure it will be juat as good!“

“Delicious food and great deals!“

“Terrific place. You would be a surprised as I was. Go and enjoy“

“I give 4 stars bc this is the 1st time here. It's probably 5 based on food, service, atmosphere and most importantly customer friendliness.
Looking for a great laid back place for great, fresh food, and a beverage? This is it.“

“We love midway villa Roma!great food,fast delivery,always professional on the phone,we have never had a bad meal!we highly recommend them!!from the girls @baby your baby pet grooming“

“Great Italian food, family friendly“

“First I want you to give a raise to the girl who works there. Every single time I’ve been there she is great, she has a smile on her even if she is tired, she will make sure you leave the place as a happy costumer. I usually go to the plaza because I do laundry next to this pizzeria and when I get hungry I go there. Food is great. I’m not a big fan of pizza but for some reason this place has the best pizza ever. The other guys that also work there are very nice and hard working people. I went last night and lost my wallet. This girl helped me looking around… basically great food and great costumer service. 5 out of 5 :)“

“I always do pick-up. Never had any issues - always professional, good service. The one time they caught a mistake on their own and gave me an extra pizza for having to wait an extra 5 minutes while they remade the one pizza. My order is always ready for pick up when the app says it will be done.“

“People friendly good food Bronx bread that's a plus veal marsala was great. service was awesome. if you're in that area that would be the place to go.“