9 Best Italian Restaurants in New Windsor

Ducktown Restaurant American • $
246 Walsh Ave, New Windsor

Customers` Favorites

Nachos with Carne Asada
Pan Seared Ribeye Steak
Pepperoni Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Surf

“Only took off 1 star because there's nothing on tap. Pizza is homemade from scratch in a proper pizza oven and DELICIOUS! Service is friendly and feels like home in the best of ways. Karaoke Thursday nights 7-10 PM, kind host and supportive, enthusiastic crowd!Parking: No spots in the small lot? Park next to the fence all along the block!“

4.6 Superb51 Reviews
IL TESORO RISTORANTE & PIZZERIA Italian • $$
1795 NY-32, New Windsor

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Scarpariello
Chicken Parmigiana
New Yorker Pizza
Linguini Alfredo
IL Tesoro Pizza
Burrata Special
Caprese Salad
Garlic Knots
French Fries
Margherita

“I was really hungry and in a rush. The pizza was wonderful and tasty. It wasn’t soft and greasy like other places around. The zapolis was a nice treat afterwards. It was made fresh at that moment nice, soft and warm. It’s a spacious clean establishment this place is a hidden gem in this community. I will certainly return and bring my family.“

4.5 Superb88 Reviews
LA CASA VICINA Italian • $$
1015 Little Britain Rd, New Windsor

Customers` Favorites

Stuffed Chicken with Mashed Potatoes Asparagus
Chicken Francese
Stuffed Mushrooms
Penne Alla Vodka
Chicken Marsala
Veal Scarpiello
Grilled Salmon
Chocolate Cake
Rack of Lamb
Creme Brulee

“Found this place after some googling and the reviews seemed promising so we decided to give it a try. All of the food and drinks were absolutely delicious and the service was great. All of the staff we interacted with were wonderful.. bartender, waiters, bus boys and possibly an owner/manager were extremely nice. My toddler ended up spilling his water on the floor and even though it was embarrassing for us no one made us feel as if it were a problem or inconvenience. The ambiance was wonderful as it seemed like a place where they have a lot of regulars, so it felt homelike in the best way. We will definitely be back.. (with a spill proof sippy cup!)“

4.5 Superb79 Reviews
Capri Restaurant & Pizzeria Pizza • $$
359 Windsor Hwy, New Windsor

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Broccoli Garlic
Tortellini Bolognese
Cold Antipasto Salad
Broiled Sea Scallops
Eggplant Parmigiana
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Sorrentino
Pasta with Sausage
Chicken Francese
Shrimp Francese

“Hands down, one of my very favorite places to eat. Food is always prepared fresh, attractively plated and plentiful. Their cheese pizza is the best in the area! The staff is welcoming, friendly and attentive; the atmosphere cozy and relaxed. Definitely worth a trip!Wheelchair accessibility: The parking area near the front entrance is small & fills quickly. I believe there is a handicapped parking space but no access isle next to it. There are additional spaces on the side of the building and around back. I've always been able to park my lift equipped van on the side of the building and get out of it without a problem. The entrance has a vestibule and getting through 2 sets of doors using a wheelchair is challenging. Once inside, there is ample space and bathrooms are accessible.“

4.5 Superb44 Reviews
A B C Pizza & Restaurant Pizza • $
198 Quassaick Ave, New Windsor

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Gyro with Tzatziki Sauce
Baked Ziti with Ricotta
Fettuccine Bolognese
Philly Cheese Steak
Small Pie

“ABC is a great local place that we frequent every once in a while with friends for low-key, informal dinner. The service is always great and the food is well-portioned, made fresh and a good value for the price. The atmosphere is "dated pizza place/diner" but there is a separate dining room and plenty of tables and booths. Comfortable, clean but far from fancy. They serve beer and wine at a reasonable price too...so that's a plus! It doesn't look like much from the outside but you won't be disappointed once you go in!“

4.4 Superb27 Reviews
Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery Pizza • $
374 Windsor Hwy, New Windsor

Customers` Favorites

Mama T's Italian Combo
Eggplant Parmigiana
Eggplant Rollatini
Chicken Parmigiana
Mama T Stromboli
Chicken Marsala
Fried Ravioli
Cheese Pizza
Garlic Bread
Cheesesteak

“Wife and I love the food..expensive but good...low atmosphere rating due to experiencing a strong cleaning chemical smell the past few times we've dined in..gets in your nasal passage and makes it hard to enjoy your food. We are not ever ones to complain but find it disappointing because otherwise love the place.“

4.2 Good36 Reviews
Ivana's Italian • $
145 Windsor Hwy, New Windsor

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti with Clam Sauce
Sausage and Peppers
Antipasto Italiano
Chicken Francaise
Strawberry Salad
Chicken Fingers
Harvest Salad
Cheese Pizza
Garlic Bread
Chicken Club

“Randomly came by for lunch with my son and was pleasantly surprised by how good and 'simple' the food is. We love that it's not over salted and has a clean/pure taste. The place is clean so we were able to enjoy a sit down meal. You can order pizza by the slice as well as larger pies, pastas and sandwiches. Note, try the breakfast pizza! We don't see many places with this and it's great to have in the morning!“

4.2 Good16 Reviews
Pizza Heaven Pizza • $
357 Old Forge Hill Rd #600, New Windsor

Customers` Favorites

Salami & Provolone Hero
Garlic Parmesan Wings
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Penne with Butter
Pepperoni Roll
Slice of Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Caesar Salad
Chicken Roll
Burnt Pizza

“Some of the best pizza in town! & they make one of my favorite Caesar salads. The staff is very friendly and attentive. It’s really easy to order off their website and by the time I get there my food is ready to go. Perfect for a Friday night!“

3.9 Good39 Reviews
Marcelino's Italian • $
1020 NY-94, New Windsor

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Cold Antipasto Salad
Eggplant Rollatini
Margherita Pizza
Bruschetta Pizza
Eggplant Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Garlic Knots
Meatballs
Soda

“My family just moved up here few years ago. I walked in this pizzeria one day for lunch and was like ok, and never went there again because of that experience. Other day we ordered from there and I was pissed that I never went back after that first experience. Pizza had a nice sweet and tangy taste. Garlic knots were amazing, fried ravioli and the sauce that went with it was enough for me to go again. So I just told my wife I want Marcelino’s tonight. Sorry I didn’t give it a second chance.“

3.7 Good41 Reviews
Loading...

Find More Tastes In New Windsor

map Map