12 Best Italian Restaurants in Fishkill

“This restaurant is amazing! The food is incredible and the service is first rate! Our server, Caesar, was fabulous - attentive, informative, and so congenial! We were impressed! Many thanks for a delightful evening!“

“We went in to AMA expecting a pizzaria but instead found a beautiful Italian restaurant. They use fresh ingredients to create the most amazing dishes. Our server Libby is a fantastic ambassador for the restaurant - enthusiastic & knowledgable about the menu and ingredients they use. We ordered everything she recommended - eggplant parmesan appetizer, Caesar salad, pesto & burrata pizza and the figura pizza. Every first bite was an "eyes roll back in your head" moment. We took the chocolate mousse cake home for dessert - absolutely delicious. Luckily we have leftovers of everthing to enjoy again! In addition to incredible food, the service was spot on. Libby was attentive and the hostess, Shay, checked in as well. It was a great experience all around. My husband and I are self proclaimed food snobs and we were very impressed. We are looking forward to returning to AMA with friends and trying out some of their other dishes. Everything about AMA is fantastic - atmosphere, service, and incredibly delicious food.“

“great food great service“

“Was very excited to have my birthday dinner here only to arrive and see that it is closed and under construction! Not sure if they are only renovating or if they are closed forever. There was no indication on the website that they were closed.“

“Absolutely the BEST food and service! Portions are HUGE!! Have ordered trays for holidays and more than enough to feed a crowd. Highly recommend making reservations. We were lucky they had one table left at 5pm. Servers never rush you, they have perfect timing of when to check on you!“

“Everything is great there especially the meatballs“

“Can’t go wrong with a pizza from this place nice thin crust . Definitely recommend“

“By far the best carne asada around! A must when I'm in town!“

“I can not say I have found a product I did not like. the staff are so friendly and the product is amazing“

“Best pizza in town, hands down. The Margherita pizza is a must-have. I always find myself comparing pizza to Florina's wherever I go, and in my opinion, Florina's always wins. They are consistent with their recipes. You're always greeted with a smile. It's family-operated and owned, which I'm a huge advocate for. Keep up the great work, guys!“

“Popped in without reservations to grab pizza for dinner. Beautiful interior / dining room with live music. 15-20 minute wait for take-away, about what I expected. Tasted like it was made with love.

Parking: Sal's is located in a small shopping strip that has its own parking lot.“

“DELICIOUS! Authentic Italian food. The eggplant and broccoli rabe are amazing!!! Nothing special in terms of atmosphere but great staff and food is the best!!!

Dietary restrictions: There is something for everyone including gluten free and vegetarian“