37 Best Italian Restaurants near Montgomery

1 Amalfi Trattoria

4.4 Superb 85 Reviews

631 NY-17K, Montgomery

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I went to lunch with my friends. First time here and we all loved it. Great staff. Nice atmosphere and the generous portions of our orders was amazing. The food was excellent. Don't miss ordering the fried dough for dessert. There was enough for the 4 of us to share. Give it a try. You want be disappointed. Next time we will go for dinner.”

2 88 Charles St Restaurant

4.7 Superb 313 Reviews

88 Charles Street, Montgomery

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Went to 88 last night with 18 people we had reservations for 8:30 pm , the accommodations , service, and and food were phenomenal . I highly recommend this restaurant. I cannot wait for my return trip to try that tomahawk steak. Eric L”

3 Cascarino's

4.7 Superb 308 Reviews

121 Hawkins Drive, Montgomery

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I had to check this joint out. They signed sealed and delivered. As a culinary professional, this establishment has perfected and been able to execute true delivery on a product. The pizza dough don’t flop, the cheese has no grease. My son and I killed a half a pie on the way home without a single napkin. They wrapped the food like they’re wrapping a present. They make homemade semolina rolls and the garlic knots are bathing in olive oil and fresh garlic. Don’t forget to check out the counter with extra products that you will want to add to your order like the chicken cutlet à la vodka slider. The staff is friendly efficient and have a very positive attitude. I even caught one of them saying we are going to have a great shift tonight. that’s all you can ask for when you work in this business. Make sure you try the Italian combo (with hot peps)”

4 Frankie T's Kitchen & Catering

5.0 Superb 66 Reviews

886 NY-17K, Montgomery

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Food is excellent! Especially the creamy turkey soup! Carmen at the counter is very friendly. I look forward to the daily specials.”

5 Carmela's Restaurant Pizzeria

4.2 Good 211 Reviews

1021 NY-17K, Montgomery

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We go about once a week and have never had a problem. Their 9.99 large cheese pizza on Tuesdays has become a ritual (of course we order other items and there is plenty for leftovers for a day or two). Service is always great whether eating in or take out. Happy to have a great Italian restaurant near by.”

6 Mike's Deli & Pizza

4.4 Superb 107 Reviews

135 Union Street Suite 1316, Montgomery

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I’ve been going to Mike’s Deli and Pizza since I was little, like, really little. So yeah, I’m a little biased—but honestly, it’s easy to see why it’s stuck around. They’re a bit pricey, not crazy, but you’re paying for quality. The meats are solid, the subs are good, and the pizza? Definitely good. For a pizza shop, it’s run by actual Italians—well, Italian-Americans—but you can tell they know what they’re doing. The owner, Mary Ann, is a very sweet lady. She’s always treated me nice. Overall, it’s a reliable spot, and I can’t imagine going anywhere else for deli or pizza around here.”

7 Francesca’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

4.1 Good 163 Reviews

201 Ward Street, Montgomery

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Amazing food, great environment. This is our go to place to eat out. Highly recommend”

8 IL TESORO RISTORANTE & PIZZERIA

4.7 Superb 188 Reviews

1795 NY-32, New Windsor · 11.69 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Terrific place. You would be a surprised as I was. Go and enjoy”

9 LA CASA VICINA

4.6 Superb 264 Reviews

1015 Little Britain Road, New Windsor · 6.96 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“the staff here are great. they make you feel so welcome the food is the best”

10 Il Cenacolo

4.6 Superb 262 Reviews

228 South Plank Road, Newburgh · 6.44 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Came here for a girls’ night with friends who had never been before, but we were all intrigued by margarita night — and it did not disappoint! We each ordered something different for dinner, and every dish was better than the next. The prices were spot on for the quality. The food was top-notch, made with fresh ingredients, and you could truly taste the difference in both the meals and the drinks. Both said it’s the same feeling you get when your in Italy! The staff was outstanding, and the owner, Rita, is doing a fantastic job running the restaurant. If you haven’t tried this place yet, you absolutely need to — it’s a true gem!”

11 Fusion @ Union

4.4 Superb 256 Reviews

1400 NY-300, Newburgh · 6.75 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The food and atmosphere is good . My reason for service is the non-chalant respond to delivery platform. The bags must be secured it’s food being transported. All we ask is that the containers be placed in a bag and stapled / tied to protect food from unscrupulous drivers who will open food container etc. the bags gone with name on it .. still open. Many restaurant in Newburgh- Golden Krust put all in one bag and tie bag / staple.. I’ve called and ask that they secure my food … doesn’t always happen”

12 Franco's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant

4.3 Superb 230 Reviews

74 Oak Street, Walden · 0.95 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I am a retired law enforcement, I have eaten all over the state, for an Italian pizza place, Franko’s is one of the best Italian food pizza/ restaurant I have eaten in.. great pie to, and they load up the wedges.. respectively RG”

13 Nu-Cavu

4.3 Superb 225 Reviews

857 Plains Road, Wallkill · 5.7 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Excellent service…the two young gentlemen (one was Xavier, I apologize for not catching the others name) who waited on us were so polite, and attentive. The food was delicious and the atmosphere, so cozy. Can’t wait to come back to have cocktails on the outside patio & watch the planes. 10/10!”

14 Marcelino's

4.3 Superb 139 Reviews

1020 NY-94, New Windsor · 9.6 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“People friendly good food Bronx bread that's a plus veal marsala was great. service was awesome. if you're in that area that would be the place to go.”

15 Eduardo's

4.3 Superb 124 Reviews

2130 NY-94, Salisbury Mills · 8.89 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“👍👏👏 sulit sa mga cheesecake lover ..😍😍 worth the wait sabi nga nila😅😅😊🤗🤗🤣 must try!!!👌👌🤩 😋”

16 F & J Pizzeria

4.5 Superb 225 Reviews

7 Goshen Avenue, Washingtonville · 8.58 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Thank you to F&J Pizzeria for the excellent catered food for our employee luncheon! Frank went above and beyond to make it excellent!”

17 Four Brother’s Pizzeria, Restaurant & Bar

4.1 Good 164 Reviews

2877 NY-94, Blooming Grove · 9.94 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“First time at this location and greeted by the Chef behind the Pizzeria. My friend and I just went to the bar area and ordered a couple of beers. The pizzeria/bar scenery felt very welcoming and will definitely come by the next time to try out their plates. So, stay tuned for another review.....”

18 Cosimo's

4.4 Superb 391 Reviews

1217 NY-300, Newburgh · 7.26 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Delicious food! Great service.”

19 Capri Restaurant & Pizzeria

4.5 Superb 150 Reviews

359 Windsor Highway, New Windsor · 9.61 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I don't know what's going on at Capris Restaurant. Everything is over saturated with garlic. Maybe it's a new chef. Won be going back.”

20 Little Pops Pizza

4.5 Superb 134 Reviews

87 Homestead Avenue, Maybrook · 4.99 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Just had another small party with food from Littlepops. Everything was wonderful as always!”

21 Pizza Heaven

4.3 Superb 165 Reviews

357 Old Forge Hill Road Suite 600, New Windsor · 9.64 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“After calling several pizza places yesterday (that said that they were not delivering and one which was very rude )we called Pizza Heaven they were very nice and professional on the phone and got our order to us real fast !the food was awesome! Being a very busy business we don’t have time for the nonsense if you deliver then deliver !don’t tell us one day you deliver and one day you don’t (this is our experience with the OTHER pizza places NOT Pizza Heaven! )We had a great lunch because of them “thank you”!!!!!we will order again for sure!”

22 Joe's Pizza & Deli

4.2 Good 230 Reviews

198 South Plank Road, Newburgh · 6.65 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We ordered trays of wraps and salads yesterday for my daughter in laws baby shower. Every wrap was delicious, fresh and beautifully laid out on trays. The macaroni and potato salad were just like homemade! It was all perfect for the occasion! Will definitely use them for every party!!”

23 Pizza 300

4.2 Good 160 Reviews

1208 NY-300, Newburgh · 7.33 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Excellent marina We loved both the itilian hero and the eggplant pizza”

24 Siena's Torteria Pizzeria

4.2 Good 104 Reviews

2412 NY-52, Pine Bush · 6.43 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“A HUGE THANK YOU to Siena’s Pizzeria & Restaurant!!!! I ordered various full pan and half pan dishes along with a 3’ sub for my son’s 30th birthday party 9/22/24. Everything was absolutely delicious and guests raved about the food! Great & friendly staff! 10/10!!!”

25 Magnanini Winery, Restaurant & Distillery

4.1 Good 87 Reviews

172 Strawridge Rd, Wallkill · 3.9 miles

• Take-Out

“We love Maganini winery, the food is amazing, we love the wine, the staff is fantastic, and so are the owners. We go to Maganini whenever we are in the area, sometimes that’s every weekend. The live music is great, and we love the fact that they host different events. You have to try one of there 6 course meals.”

26 Guido's Pizza Parlor

4.1 Good 136 Reviews

35 East Main Street Suite 3, Walden · 0.81 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Excellent passionate owners! Tonight at 8:40pm I called not sure if they were willing still to make a dinner since they close in 20 mins and I explained how my mother was getting home after major brain surgery and without hesitation they made a chicken Marsala dinner for my mother. Thank you guys so much and thank you making my mom’s night. Greatly appreciate you guys! Thank you Niko!”

27 Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery

4.1 Good 167 Reviews

374 Windsor Highway, New Windsor · 9.54 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Was nice and cosy! The garlic knots are delicious, got the sausage and peppers on capellini and tomato sauce was very good and definitely have enough for a second meal. The waitress was very sweet and did great even though we were a big group.”

28 Pizza Hut Express

3.4 Good 17 Reviews

50 NY-17K, Newburgh · 7.68 miles

• Delivery

29 Leo's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria Newburgh

4.0 Good 130 Reviews

1431 NY-300, Newburgh · 6.64 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The food is always delicious here. I've done take-out and dine-in throughout the years and they never disappoint. Their Grandma Pizza is SO good!! And the staff are always so nice. One time while waiting to pick up our order, the owner let my daughter cut our pizza, showing her the best technique. She has talked about that moment often! Great place with great people!”

30 Paesano's Pizzeria

4.0 Good 136 Reviews

1914 US-44, Modena · 9.36 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“So many great things to say with Kim and TJ taking over, the daily posts, the new pies, the friendly faces throughout the team. A pizza place that I don’t need to order through door dash! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️”

31 Johnny's Pizzeria & Restaurant

4.0 Good 193 Reviews

455 NY-17K, Rock Tavern · 3.53 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Good food but be careful using your debit card here. It took them 2 weeks to process their transactions for the charge to finally hit my bank. No joke!!! It took 2 WEEKS for the charge to hit my bank account!!!”

32 Villa Italia Ristorante

4.0 Good 208 Reviews

1663 NY-300, Newburgh · 6.75 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Best italian food around !😁❣️”

33 Pasquale's Pizza & Restaurant

4.0 Good 249 Reviews

135 Main Street, Gardiner · 9.21 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Wonderful”

34 Pasquale's Pizza & Restaurant

3.9 Good 100 Reviews

26 Wallkill Avenue, Wallkill · 3.83 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“from the I r dinners to pizza ALWAYS VERY GOOD FOOD!!!!! PORTIOB SIZE,SERVICE & FOOD VERY GOOD!!!”

35 Brother Bruno's Pizzeria & Restaurant

3.7 Good 166 Reviews

40 Brotherhood Plaza Drive, Washingtonville · 8.51 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Delicious and great service!”

36 Frank's Pizza

3.6 Good 193 Reviews

154 South Plank Road, Newburgh · 7.08 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Best pizza, Stromboli and pasta ever and friendly staff! Whenever we go to NY from Massachusetts it’s our go to place!!! Thanks for the great Italian pizza!”

37 Tosco's Pizzeria

3.4 Good 180 Reviews

1431 NY-208, Wallkill · 4.29 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“They have GIANT pizzas every night which are awesome and large pizza every Tuesday only $10.99, you can’t cook for much less and in the summer no one wants to they always say 20 minutes but they have it ready in less than half the time Definitely going through the summer every week, after we go back to giant pizzas but they are so big we ask them to double cut”