Mel's Eatery
$ • Pizza, Chicken WingsAbout Mel's Eatery
Customers' Favorites
Chicken Blue
Loaded Fries
Sheet Pizza
Meat Lovers
Sub Salad
Wings And
Sauce
Mel's Eatery Reviews
83 ratings
Share your opinion about Mel's Eatery
I am in Nunda just about every weekend and is a sad time when I can't get there once. Have had several different categories of food and all have been awesome. Owner is super friendly and knows alot of people by name. Is a good place to stop if your in the area.
Amazing fish fry! The coconut shrimp is excellent as well. Best Pizza in town! tasty wings and the subs are good too! Nothing mediocre on this menu--- 👍
Ordered fish and the meals were excellent. Best fish fry I have ever had.
Hours
| Monday | 3 - 7PM |
| Tuesday | 3 - 7PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 7PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 7PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Saturday | 12 - 8PM |
| Sunday | 12 - 7PM |
Mel's Eatery is a charming and clean small-town restaurant that offers a welcoming atmosphere and a variety of delicious meals. Visitors consistently praise the friendly and cheerful service, with staff who are helpful and make guests feel at home. The restaurant is known for its generous portions and affordable prices, making it a popular spot for both locals and travelers.
The menu features a range of tasty options, including excellent pizza, chicken wings, fish fry, and specialty dishes like the Messy Mel, which is a version of the famous garbage plate. The pizza is often described as crispy, flavorful, and topped generously with high-quality ingredients, reminding visitors of nostalgic small-town pizzerias. The garlic chicken wings are highly recommended—crispy, flavorful, and spicy, with just the right amount of garlic and heat. The fish fry is also praised for its well-cooked, sizable piece of fish served with a roll and sides. For those seeking comfort food, the homemade ranch and mac and cheese are standout sides.
The special dishes, such as beef on weck and the cheeseburger pizza, receive high marks for their savory flavors and freshness. Guests appreciate the spotless kitchen and inviting interior, with some noting the cozy seating by the window where they can enjoy their meal. Overall, Mel's Eatery offers a satisfying dining experience, with quality food, friendly service, and a warm atmosphere that keeps visitors coming back.