Pizza Restaurants near Nunda

Mel's Eatery Pizza • $
19 North State Street, Nunda

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Blue
Loaded Fries
Sheet Pizza
Meat Lovers
Sub Salad
Wings And
Sauce

“I am in Nunda just about every weekend and is a sad time when I can't get there once. Have had several different categories of food and all have been awesome. Owner is super friendly and knows alot of people by name. Is a good place to stop if your in the area.“

4.6 Superb85 Reviews
Doughboys Pizzeria Pizza • $
28 North State Street, Nunda

“We had ordered from here last night and it was our first time and we just had moved in the area and they were so welcoming and friendly!! Gave us some brownies with our pizza with a little bag that said welcome! The pizza was real good too!! 10/10 for sure!!!“

4.4 Superb87 Reviews
Wolf Creek Deli Pizza • $
104 North Main Street, Castile - 9.16 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mac\u0026 Cheese w 2 Chicken Tenders
Large Cheese and Pepperoni Pizzas
Mac& Cheese w 2 Chicken Tenders
Large Chicken Finger Pizza
Butter and Cocktail Sauce
Cheese Pepperoni and Ham
Small Roast Beef Sub
Fried Shrimp Dinner
12 Cheeseburger Sub
Large Assorted Sub

“Wandered into Wolf Creek Deli after another rough afternoon fighting an opossum for half a gas station hot dog. Immediately knew this place would be a local gem.

Their sandwiches and quesadillas are excellent, but the homemade soups are the main event. Absolutely DELICIOUS. Made from scratch. Warm, creamy, and comforting. Much better than the mysterious liquids I’ve been drinking out of a Campbell’s soup can behind the bowling alley.

Then I discovered the homemade cookies. ENORMOUS. Bought one for later, ate it immediately. Went right back for another and told them it was for my children. I do not have children.

Five stars. Left with crumbs in my fur and a renewed sense of purpose. Will absolutely return no matter how many times they tell me I can’t bring my own Tupperware and fill it directly from the soup pot.

🦝 5/5 would be their substitute assistant manager.“

4.5 Superb181 Reviews

You May Also Like