20 Best Pizza Restaurants near Oakfield

“Love coming here. Really home town feel, lots of sports memorabilia on the walls, super friendly service and food is ALWAYS on point!“

“I ordered a chicken finger sub last night. No lie, it was the best sub I’ve ever had. Great job“

“The customer service is outstanding! We picked up an order, and when we got home we realized part of it was missing. The owner made a fresh order and personally delivered it to our house.“

“Wings are killer!!! Great hidden gem“

“Always fast and friendly service. My favorite pizza. It’s hard to find places that have good chicken fingers that are plain, but theirs are always top notch.“

“Great food & great service!“

“I stopped in yesterday for lunch and had an awesome time! Great food, great people. Definitely looking forward to my next visit.“

“Sicilian style pizza is worth the price. Cup and char, sweet sauce with garlic crust. Seasoned well so if you’re not a garlic fan go with regular crust. Eggplant parm sub is great, like the steak and cheese. The Royal will be the next one I try. Always have my order ready on time. Thanks Tim“

“the Chinese food was excellent and would get the tacos again“

“It's a plain atmosphere with good conversation amongst locals and the interior looks the exact same as it always has. The sauce was delicious, the cheese was stretchy and melty. The crust had a nice crunch yet soft at the same time. The customer service was professional and helpful. My partner asked for extra cheese. If you want to eat the pizza from a Goofy movie, order with extra cheese, it looks the exact same! It's not really a necessity tho. I definitely recommend!“

“Best Pizza around hands down. We've had every slice from every joint around Genesee County. If you haven't tried Mattys, do yourself a favor and order one from them. You won't be disappointed.“

“The pizza is awesome! The sauce is flavorful, the crust isn't too thick and is soft yet has that satisfying crisp on the outside. The pizza isn't overly cheesy and all of the ingredients are quality. The hot wings are juicy, too! The customer service was professional and welcoming! My partner and I will definitely be coming back!“

“I got on a sub kick about two weeks ago and I have then recently had a whole sub at all the local sub shops. Today I took a gamble and got a sub from the tine subshop - Dougs Pizza and Subs. Oh My goodness. It is the best sub I have ever had, not even close and also the cheapest one I have had during the past month - the local sub shops. I ordered the smiley spicy italian sub with extra lettuce tomatoes and onions with mayo and italian dressing. It came back toasted, that surprised me and the owner said, we toast all our subs. The sub itself was huge and heafty and the flavor was stunning. It was so good. Then what surprised me was the price $12 for the best sub in town, avantis marks, subway, jersey mikes, firehouse subs, daves subs and cusimanos all were more expensive and this one was the best by far tasting of all of them. Give Doug's another try. wow. its good.“

“Best Pizza in Batavia! Friendly service and great food!“

“I had my bridal shower here on the patio and it was absolutely perfect!! Mary grace was super helpful and easy to work with while planning. They allowed us to come in early to set up and were extremely attentive during the entire shower!! Food was absolutely delicious and everything went perfectly 😀“

“We love Ficarella's. I can't recall any time we've had an issue because we keep going back. We got dinner from them 2 times this week and both times our order was 100% correct. Their online ordering is super simple and allows you to make almost any modification you want. They also have a drive up window if you can't/don't want to go inside.“

“I stopped in yesterday for lunch and had an awesome time! Great food, great people. Definitely looking forward to my next visit.“

“thank you Cusimano's for the awesome service and fixing us up with a few slices to go! you made my pregnant wife very very happy as always! highly recommended if you are in the area.“

“Staff was super friendly and smiling! Greeted me as soon as I walked in the door! We ordered the stuffed crust pizza and it was delicious! With other pizza places that have stuffed crust, the pizza is usually so thin and floppy but not Dominos! It was perfect!“

“Been coming here multiple times a month for over two years. If you’d like to set up the bar, the bar can get pretty busy around 6 o’clock every day. I have probably ordered their bolognese 20+ times. Their caprese is incredible. A lot of people enjoy their gnocchi. They have a wide variety of beer and wines with a full bar. The service is always great. There’s outdoor seating and indoor seating, it’s best to call ahead if you have a large party. This is my favorite restaurant in Batavia. The atmosphere is great, the staff are wonderful, and the food is always consistent!“