16 Best American Restaurants near Old Chatham

“I look forward to eating here every time I’m in the area! I love the food! The service is awesome! Every! Time! I especially appreciate the gracious and generous nature of the people who work here. And the owners are wonderful. They have an establishment that consistently provides an excellent meal and the perfect place to catch up with old friends.“

“For the sake of full disclosure I’ve worked with the owners for over twenty years in the television industry. They have brought the same dedication and amazing attention to detail that has resulted in their tremendously successful careers, to their wonderful new restaurant. They have thought of EVERY detail from the whimsical videos playing in the rest rooms to the sugar cubes for your espresso... they have missed nothing. The menu is inventive and perfectly executed... Watermelon Gazpacho?! Whoa! The unique presentation of the Calamari appetizer was wonderful. Bouillabaisse?! You don’t find that as the seafood option very often... what a treat. Others in my group enjoyed perfectly cooked steaks and the slightly smoky Mac & Cheese. Of course the cheese plates are spectacular. This is one of those meals you won’t forget! But wait did I mention the speakeasy downstairs? The perfectly appointed room features an amazing menu of craft cocktails AND six draft beers to choose from... including Ommegang Rare Vos... you simply don’t find that on tap anywhere!! Finally a word about the service. It was impeccable, perfectly attentive without being stuffy. Chris and Ellen have created a destination restaurant!“

“absolutely loved it, stopped during a road trip and wish I lived closer.“

“I have never had food I didn't love. The soups are amazing, all of them. It is a favorite for the locals but after going there just a couple of times they remember my preferences. Staff is great, friendly, efficient, top notch. The crowd is friendly and lively.“

“My family has had some of our best nights here. Zachary, my son absolutely loves Jeffrey that’s here! I haven’t met a single person that wouldn’t go out of their way to accommodate. This by far is one of our favorite home town go to places!! Try em out you won’t be disappointed 🤟🏻🫶“

“My favorite is the Chicken Parm...more than I can finish in one serving. I also love their Black and Blue Salad... with their Blue cheese dressing! I've never been disappointed with the food at Main Street! Hope you stop in for a very reasonable priced meal. Enjoy! 💕🌹🌻🥗🍝♥️“

“Great bagels, super fresh pastries and excellent coffee. This is our go-to breakfast treat.“

“We have been going to Zias since 2009,the service has been poor, disrespectful, cocky.It used yo be good but has gone the way their old place pieros.was good and went to crap. shame we were loyal. go to riveria down the street better nicer and they appreciate you. ZERO STARS“

“Yum. Thank you for a tasty takeout breakfast this morning.“

“Good food and drink with excellent service, for a fair price. Check it out!“

“I had an absolutely fantastic reasonably priced lunch today. Way more than I could eat., Burger was cooked perfect, toppings were fresh and delicious. The service was friendly, fast and efficient ! So glad we decided to look around before we ate.“

“OMG We live in CT and came to NYC for an appt and things. For fun, we went to the farmer's market in Union Square and bought some of your incredible, amazing, delicious, gluten-free brioche buns and we're amazed! We can't wait to get back to The City so we can load up! We'll totally place an order before we come with our empty back packs! I have celiac disease, so it's a huge deal to me and my guy to find such an awesome bun! We're not even huge bread eaters and we think these blow everything else away with or without gluten! They also keep well in the 'frig and toast up beautifully in the air fryer. We can't wait to try more of your GF options, too. Thank you so much!“

“Always an amazing time!
A welcoming cozy pub vibe with cheerful and attentive staff!!
I fully recommend the BLT Wedge Salad it is to die for!!!
The angel wings with a dry rub seasoning FABULOUS

I love love love“

“Great place! Was shopping in Chatham, stopped in for a margarita (it’s Cinco de Mayo) met some really nice people!“

“Went here for dinner before show at MacHaydn Theatre. Waitress Nicole was very friendly and attentive. Got a senior special which comes with soup and dessert. I had pot roast with fries. Very tasty soup. Roast beef was a little well done for my taste but it was flavorful. For dessert I had the bread pudding again a little overcooked but was tasty. Would definitely go back. $25 with the tip.“

“Love their Food .. love the atmosphere. Max the people there“