“Weds-Sun full order spaghetti & meatball is on special for $7. It's a generous helping for the price. Mash the meatballs to make an excellent meat sause.sauce. The blue cheese salad dressing is very good. The onions rings are fair. Service is unexcelled especially if busy.“
“Good Italian food.2-6-2024: We enjoyed our meal tonight.I had the Chicken Spiedie Salad, which was quite good. Another person had the Chicken Marsala which was unfortunately heavily breaded. The third person had a dinner salad and slice of pizza, which she enjoyed.“
“From the time we were greeted on entering until we paid the check, it was a great experience. Intimate, comfortable, balanced atmosphere - lighting, conversation, as well as music. The menu is not especially large. However it is varied , with each dish made upon ordering. The prices were surprisingly fair, making you feel your money and time were well spent . What a local gem.“
“Stopped here for dinner while on vacation in the area, First thing is our waitress was super nice and friendly great personality perfect waitress. I ordered the NY Strip steak and it was cooked perfectly temperature wise, a little too much charred flavor for my liking but overall a well cooked steak. Got broccoli as a side it just came steamed not sautéed or anything. The other thing is they are cash only didn’t realize that till the end of dinner so good thing they have an ATM in the restaurant. I would try this place again if I was in the area for sure. If you are near by give it a try it’s worth the stop. NY Style cheesecake with strawberries was good.“
“AMAZING PRIME RIB AND AU JUS. So tender and cooked perfectly. The pan seared scallops were overcooked by a mile, definitely a waste of $20. Never have not eaten scallops at a restaurant before, just very chewy and no flavor even when dipped in lemon butter. Our server Andrew was very kind, attentive, and knowledgeable. Atmosphere was very laid back nothing fancy or upscale. Reasonable prices for big portions. Will be returning for more prime rib!“
“Lived here for years. First time ordering a full Stromboli (no peppers, add bacon)HIGHLY Recommend!! It’s big and full of meat, it’s great. New favorite item on their menu.DO NOT FORGET TO GET EXTRA RANCH!Photo doesn’t give it the proper justice“
“I go to Mario's or have them deliver about once a month over the past 16 years so I'll base this review on my approximately 192 experiences with Mario's. Always a top notch 100% authentic New York thin crust pizza baked to perfection! Every single time! Now here's where they shine: if you put veggies on your pizza like onions, peppers, olives etc, it's hard not to get a soggy pizza. Not at Mario's, the crust is always crispy, never soggy and in the 200 times I've ordered their pizza, it's perfectly cooked. I probably should have written a review years ago, guess I took this place for granted but man they are a class act. I've eaten inside a few times and the service has always been friendly and prompt. The ambiance is quintessential local pizza joint--wonderful. My employer is about 3 miles away and we always go to Mario's for special lunch events or order for on-site visitors. It's just a well rounded perfect pizza joint and the price is super affordable. Love this place!“