50 Best Mexican Restaurants near Oyster Bay

“We just ordered here for the first time and the food was amazing ! The grilled buffalo chicken wrap was delicious! The breaded buffalo chicken wrap and avocado corn salad were huge hits as well.“

“When is the most beautiful places I eat at me and my aunt went there is Lily had a great lunch ain't got left over for today and had a nice drink she had a beer and like I said the portions were nice and fresh and good you cannot get a better meal for 30 bucks in your life like I said these big chain restaurants that is exactly how they cook and change one meal after another that is microwave and hand it to you they cook it for you fresh in your face while you wait beautiful view a shout out to Lourdes and and her daughters for running a comfortable beautiful place amen“

“Fish tacos and baby corn is yummy 😋“

“Very nice inviting decor. Service was just ok. The server was basic, didn’t tell us it was happy hour? Nor did she mention and food selections. For a new establishment I guess I was expecting a bit more … maybe ask if we had been there before? Check back to see how our food was( it was outstanding), we got more help from the water girl Had to ask to clear table. Had to ask for check from the water girl? The server had much support. Seems she took our order and disappeared. But the server assistants were on point. Dinner was really good. We will go back… because of the food. Even the manager walked pasted us a dozen times. There were 6 tables.. perfect time for manager to mingle… just saying. Place is very nice, great menu too. Just left feeling ignored. Nice music too. Maybe the server was having a bad day? Like I said we will go again !!! Great food.“

“As a Texan native, everywhere i go, I ask local for food advice..
You know those little hole in the walls full of flavor and traditions...
Well my friend Al, recommend us this place, he was so excited talking about this place, so I couldn't help visit this place, at first it looks like a regular place, once I sit at the bar the Journey begins...
I got a beer the bartender he was so cool and helpful... then this beautiful lady pass by with some Greek empanadas and oh boy from there it was straight to heaven 🥰🥰🥰
The flavor the mix of Ingredients are amazing, not forgetting the Greek hot salsa Man I'm telling you,
This is one of those places we call in Texas you must eat there!
The food was beyond Amazing Delicious!!! And the Atmosphere of this place is so great and cozy,
Like I belong here! Thank you guys

Like we said in Texas

Y'all did so good!! 🤠

PD: i definitely will be back 🥰“

“Food was outstanding, just finished my meal and had to write a review. Hidden gem as another said. Probably ordering again Sunday.“

“Had an amazing meal at Rocco’s Tacos in Huntington! Camden was our bartender and was so personable and attentive. Joe took great care of us and made the most delicious tableside guacamole. We’re thrilled to have this new spot in town and will absolutely be back—often!“

“Have ordered many times from Ole’s. The food is delicious and service friendly and warm. Today, decided to eat in so we could try the nachos crispy and warm in the store. They were amazing!!! The other items were also great, my kids loved all of it. At the end, we had a chance to meet one of the owners, Manny. He was very friendly and warm, chatted with my boys and then surprised them with a warm churro. Needless to say, we’ll be coming back even more frequently now. Yum yum yum.“

“Never disappoints Great portions and staff Love the music and the atmosphere food comes out fast and hot love the decorations in the place overall a great experience“

“We came here on a thurs even around 6pm...Was pretty crowded but got a table in the middle..The sound level is pretty high at 3/4 capacity but somehow you seem to flow with it because of the atmosphere... People enjoying good mex food are more enjoyable to be around for some reason..anyway...lighting as with most place is difficult to read menu but once the order was in,alot of fun...I noticed the food to be very FRESH...I immediately tasted that in the beans on my Mexican special and the Flautas,chimichanga etc were all delicious stuffed and perfectly cooked!..Fajita steak was so nicely marinated and charred but med inside..Perfect!..Wait staff were all very pleasant....I enjoyed my visit and will defin visit during a slow day,maybe lunch for a lil more quiet....“

“food is tasty and fresh. service is very pleasant atmosphere is welcoming I will be back“

“Amazing and deliciously 🤤 addictive . The fundito with chorizo is so good !!!“

“I’ve been ordering from Orale for months now, but as soon as I crack open the container, the food hypnotizes me and makes me forget to take a picture. Every dang time. Not sure how I broke the spell this time, but let me tell you, still amazing.

I live on Long Island, so in my opinion, our average Mexican food is terrible. It’s either because too fancy and expensive trying to be more than it needs to, or it’s gone commercialized that’s overpriced and inconsistent quality-wise (looking at you tacombi). In steps Orale. Food is always amazing, fresh, consistent. Best chicken quesadilla I’ve had anywhere, hands down. Their carnitas burrito is also so savory and indulgent. My wife can never finish it in one serving.

Bonus: their red and green homemade sauces are so special. Really incredible balance of heat and flavor. I never have enough of it. I’m considering applying to an unpaid internship there just to learn how to make it myself. Or maybe I can get paid in sauce. Still working through the details here.

Double bonus: their staff is personable and attentive. Feels more like getting food from a friend.

Triple bonus: I walked in one time to get a pickup order and there was a 70th birthday party there and everyone was drinking tequila. Atmosphere was electric. Fired me up. I will now plan my next birthday there.“

“Enjoyed brunch today w/ my daughter we both enjoyed everything!!! Definitely going back the horchata was AMAZING!! So was the service !“

“Great food and service. Highly recommend“

“The food was absolutely amazing! The tacos were bursting with flavor, and the margaritas were the best I’ve had in a long time. Can’t wait to come back!“

“If you want authentic great Mexican Food & Drink.. Ruta Oaxaca is the best ! Great service , friendly staff and great variety.“

“Staff was beyond friendly and helped me with some suggestions since it was my first visit. Everything was so good and I really liked that the protein you picked was cooked fresh right in front of you. There are so many things I didn't get that I want to try. Will definitely be back.“

“Very delicious food. I work in East New York, and I saw many truck drivers, workers stopping at lunchtime. I went to the restaurant, the vibe is so cool, and the tacos I ordered had different and good flavors. Fresh food, tasty, and good customer service.“

“great food, fun atmosphere and great music!“

“Simply the best….. better than all the rest. Our go to spot for authentic food and it always delivers. Family owned, not some soulless chain. Support a local eatery today!“

“This place was awesome! The atmosphere was definitely one for the books. The Margarita flight was sooooo good along with the food. The customer service was definitely top notch. Everyone was smiling and had a positive attitude. Constantly checking in to make sure you're doing okay. 10 Stars, will be returning“

“Buena comida las muchachas muy atentas se los recomiendo“

“Great place Gentlemen with glasses and hat backwards was awesome. Great portions very flavorful. Will be back.“

“The food was great, the staff was very friendly and accommodating. Tanya was our server and she was great. We spoke with the Manager as well about the decorations and he was very friendly. Can't wait to go again and try something different.“

“Mesita hosted my wedding yesterday. The staff were incredibly helpful from start to finish. And the food was ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!!!!!! 10/10 recommend!“

“Great place Great drinks fun place to be“

“Best Delivery Food Around! Food is always hot, delivery is extremely quick, people are great and the food is the BEST!!!!“

“❤ My husband and I love Curbside in South Hempstead. Their crunchwraps are big enough to share. Our favorite is the Cowboy Crunchwrap with extra sauteed onions. I could eat only this for the rest of my life, provided, of course, we have sour cream!“

“One thing I miss about living in Long Island are the Tex-Mex restaurants. Yes, they're not of the highest quality, and usually they're in a cheap location, and the horrible customer service is always a given, but I do enjoy the food every once in a while.

After searching for a Tex-Mex restaurant, I stumbled across Taco King. This location is actually pretty big with plenty of sitting space. My usual go-to dish at a Tex-Mex place is the Grilled Steak rice platter, so I decided to stick with what I like. I thought the steak here was excellent. It came with one flour tortilla, rice, beans, salad, guac, and chili. The quality and proportion was better than what I expected.

However, it was crazy expensive. I know I sound old, but I remember that only a few years ago, the same dish was about $8 or $9. Now it's over $17! I would gladly eat here more often if the price was cheaper.“

“Excellent service great food“

“No one was in the restraurant. A mexican restraurant empty on a Tues. I was skeptical but ate anyway. Food was great. Just apps but we were both pleased. 2 for 1 drinks as well. Only complaint was that we decided to pay cash after reading a credit card incident in the past“

“Restaurante familiar, Rica comida 🌮“

“My burrito was the size of a 10 pound baby. All of the food was delicious! 🤤“

“This is insane how big the burritos are! Holy cow! They were very good too. Had no idea what to expect. This was our first meal in NY and it did not disappoint! Only downside was the burrito fell apart and no silverware was included so it was a mess. But that was it. Otherwise it was a slam dunk. Loved it. -Some fat southern folk.“

“Excellent quality, excellent service, guac is not extra!

They treat you with respect and dignity. When you order triple chicken, they give you triple. They do not scrimp.

This is the only Mexican chain restaurant that I will go to. The other one's portions are disrespectfully small.

QDoba gets an A+“

“I love this place. The food is so Fresh and Delicious and most importantly consistent. The owner and staff are very accommodating and there are plenty of Veg. Options.“

“Excellent service! Welcoming, clean, nice vibe and atmosphere! I will definitely return plenty more times!!!“

“Excellent meal and wait staff“

“I’m obsessed with the new team at Nelly’s. Alba and her team are whipping up delicious food that we can’t get enough of. If you’re looking for well made Mexican, you have to give Nelly’s a shot.“

“This place was great I tried it today and i had no complaints what so ever, I’ve read the reviews and honestly i think it’s the customers who last out on the resturant for not telling the resturant how they want it because the service here is amazing from the cooks down to the front desk workers, when i requested a specific order to be chosen to my liking they went through with it. I would recommend this again and again, Amazing resturant“

“Had amazing cinco de Mayo!! Thanks for the t shirts ! Great service great food best drinks and beyond great dessert.“

“Picked up lunch and it was delish!!! Thank you!!! Queso is fantastic!“

“meseros muy lentos y la comida pesima“

“awesome menu items great service“

“Wow what a fantastic find! We decided to try this new Mexican place, and it did not disappoint. Every single dish was packed with flavor. The tamale was perfectly moist and savory, and the taco Pescadero was fresh and perfectly seasoned. We also devoured the steak quesadilla, which was cheesy and full of tender steak. Don't even get me started on the empanadas—both the chili empanada and the chicken and cheese empanada were phenomenal. We can't wait to go back and try more!“

“Fantastic food cooked by wonderful people. My bf and I frequent this restaurant a bunch. Their food is so so good and my favorite meal is the steak fajitas, and their sides are all too good as well as the guacamole and chips. Jarritos and margaritas are also fantastic as always. We love that this is a family ran restaurant. They really make you feel like at home. The restaurant is very cute and has a warm feeling. You also get quite a view as it is beachfront!!“

“Food was good, staff friendly and they had sports on.“

“good food , quick service“

“Love the food obviously 🙄 love the location delicious 😋“