26 Best Italian Restaurants near Pine Bush

“A HUGE THANK YOU to Siena’s Pizzeria & Restaurant!!!! I ordered various full pan and half pan dishes along with a 3’ sub for my son’s 30th birthday party 9/22/24. Everything was absolutely delicious and guests raved about the food! Great & friendly staff! 10/10!!!“

“Fresh and delicious food! 🍕🥗“

“Melissa and Antonio are the best, a long with their kids. I grew up with them. They are all hands on deck. Food is immaculate. Every time you go you find a new favorite on the menu. The flavors and spices that mix together are truly amazing, it’s a family tradition to have birthdays or any type of celebration at Antonio’s in my family. Highly recommend“

“Lombardi’s of Middle Island is a true gem for lovers of classic Italian cuisine. From the moment you walk in, the warm ambiance and attentive staff make you feel like family. The setting is cozy yet upscale, perfect for both casual dinners and special occasions.
I ordered the Chicken Parmesan, and it was absolutely phenomenal. The chicken was perfectly breaded—crispy on the outside, juicy and tender inside. It was generously smothered in a rich, tangy marinara sauce and topped with a blanket of melted mozzarella that added just the right amount of creaminess. The portion size was hearty and satisfying, served alongside a bed of al dente pasta that soaked up the sauce beautifully.
What really stood out was the balance of flavors. The tomato sauce tasted fresh and homemade, with a hint of garlic and basil that elevated the dish. It’s clear Lombardi’s takes pride in using quality ingredients and traditional recipes.
Service was prompt and friendly, and the staff made great recommendations. The garlic bread starter was also a hit—crispy, buttery, and loaded with flavor.
Parking was easy, and the overall experience was smooth from start to finish. Whether you're a local or just passing through Long Island, Lombardi’s is a must-visit. Their Chicken Parmesan alone is worth the trip.
Highly recommend for anyone craving authentic Italian comfort food done right.“

“Went there for my wife's birthday dinner it was 4 of us my wife and my friends wife had prime rib I had chicken Sorrento and my friend had a huge steak and fries plus a calamari app plus we had 4 drinks and the wife took home a piece of cake for later all of us took food home portions were huge food was great service was great our waitress was Alicia she was awsome and we git the bill and it was only $155 total will definitely be going there again 😀“

“Compared to neighboring places, this beats them hands down. If you plan to eat and it beats other pizzeria options, it’s my number one place to go for pizza and more. The ingredients are fresh and the food tastes absolutely awesome.“

“My food was alright i cant complain too much, I got the chicken franchese and they were decent not the best but I enjoyed them very much. a couple family members didn't enjoy their meals but they still enjoyed the atmosphere and the drinks. cool little place for a local Italian restaurant that's not in the major NY area with the best Italian food.“

“I am a retired law enforcement, I have eaten all over the state, for an Italian pizza place, Franko’s is one of the best Italian food pizza/ restaurant I have eaten in.. great pie to, and they load up the wedges.. respectively RG“

“I really liked my meal and the staff was attentive. Now I have to decide what to get next time. I kept looking around and wanting to try something different. Eventually I guess. Good place.“

“The food was great and the people were really nice. I will be coming back soon.“

“We had my son’s 5th birthday here today and they could not have been better to us! They opened early so we had the dining room to ourselves. The pizza was fabulous, the staff was extremely helpful. Thank you guys!!!“

“I Ordered a few catered sandwiches for a local business 2 days before Christmas as a gift from Cascarino’s. Anthony took care of payment, delivery, cutlery etc for me and delivered to the local business as promised. Food was amazing!“

“Went to 88 last night with 18 people we had reservations for 8:30 pm , the accommodations , service, and and food were phenomenal . I highly recommend this restaurant. I cannot wait for my return trip to try that tomahawk steak. Eric L“

“We’ve been going here for years. The food is great, the people friendly. There has been a learning curve with reopening, as a lot of the staff are new but it’s still one of the best places around.“

“Just had another small party with food from Littlepops. Everything was wonderful as always!“

“Food is excellent! Especially the creamy turkey soup! Carmen at the counter is very friendly. I look forward to the daily specials.“

“I’ve been going to Mike’s for many years now and they never disappoint!! From their breakfast sandwiches, to their pizza, to their Italian combos, you can’t go wrong ordering something from here. I get a sausage, egg and cheese for lunch quite often and my tastebuds thank me everyday. The owners and employees are super nice and always greet me by name when I walk in; they’re very personable. If you’re looking for something yummy to eat, definitely try Mike’s Deli!!

Parking: Right next to the building, plenty of parking room

Wheelchair accessibility: They have a ramp right out front!!“

“everyone is nice n the food there is great“

“My first time here and it won’t be my last. I described a salad I was in the mood for and he the owners made exactly that. It was fresh and delicious. I recommend this restaurant and look forward to returning and trying different dishes.“

“Food is amazing! Fast service and possibly the best Bacon, egg & cheese sandwich I’ve ever had! Kudos for having a generator and not skipping a beat when the power goes out!“

“We have been going here since we moved to Middletown in 2016. Hands down the best pizza place in Middletown. Donaldo and his team are awesome!“

“I order every weekend and the food is fantastic, from the sandwiches to the pizza , Great Service and Great Atmosphere, Try the Lucy’s Pizza 👍🏻“

“from the I r dinners to pizza ALWAYS VERY GOOD FOOD!!!!! PORTIOB SIZE,SERVICE & FOOD VERY GOOD!!!“

“Pizza and 4 cheese quesadillas were great!“

“Whoever said the garlic knots were overcooked and burnt lied so hard. These are absolutely perfect, and whoever said the people that run the place aren’t Italian, NEWS FLASH not all pizza places are run by italians. Relax Karens, thanks for great garlic knots. (i’m fully italian trust)“

“They have GIANT pizzas every night which are awesome and large pizza every Tuesday only $10.99, you can’t cook for much less and in the summer no one wants to they always say 20 minutes but they have it ready in less than half the time Definitely going through the summer every week, after we go back to giant pizzas but they are so big we ask them to double cut“