11 Best Steakhouses near Rye

“Great local Rye steakhouse! Owner was very engaged and aware of the business. Great menu and selections! Ordered the Porterhouse for 3, bacon, cream of spinach and hash browns. The steak was delicious! It was a little over cooked in some areas but delicious! Similar to Peter Luger but less steak juice. I would definitely go back. Server was attentive and clean and welcoming atmosphere. Nice to see an owner so engaged with customers and staff.“

“Best steak I have had in a long time, service was impeccable. Will be back“

“Lenny's Steakhouse is always fantastic! The food is consistently excellent, the steaks are cooked perfectly, and the service never disappoints. The staff is welcoming, attentive, and makes every visit feel special. You can always count on a great meal, a wonderful atmosphere, and an all-around exceptional experience. One of our favorite places—we look forward to coming back every time. Highly recommend!“

“Pete's Steakhouse is superb — the food, the ambiance, the service, all absolutely amazing. We always look forward to dinner here. Everything on the menu is delicious, and the service is unbelievable, they truly go the extra mile to cater to your needs in such a pleasant, friendly way.“

“Phenomenal experience. Top notch food, atmosphere, and wait staff. Have been here multiple times, and every time is an amazing experience all around. The food is always superb and the bar is amazing. Definitely a lifetime customer!“

“Terrific, but pricey. About $250 pp with tip.“

“The food and service were fantastic.“

“If you want to experience the finest steakhouse dining in NY look no further!! From food Quality, ambience, to exceptional service Benjamins steakhouse has it all. It’s an absolute must! Cannot recommended highly enough.“

“Probably the most beautiful steak you will ever see eevr was made here. I had a sirloin with bacon mashed potatoes and corn and till today I'm still thinking about it. The service was great also and the bread is to die for. Looking forward to my next visit.“

“Recently held a conference in this hotel and the entire staff at this hotel made it amazing! From the delicious catering to the rooms and amenities, we had a fantastic experience! Dinner at Tony’s was incredible and it was even more amazing when Tony came and played a trivia game with all of us! The laughter and fun we had was just what we needed and it really was fantastic! I received nothing but amazing feedback and I truly cannot thank the staff enough! If I could give you more than 5 stars, I would!!! Thank you!!!“

“If you’re looking for a steakhouse, this is definitely the place to be! 🥩 Everything was absolutely delicious. The meat was so tender and literally melted in my mouth. The mac and cheese was a HIT, and everything we ordered was cooked to perfection.
Even the vegetables were on point — crunchy, fresh, and definitely not wilted. The salmon was also delicious, soft, and came with a creamy sauce that I couldn’t wait to get home and enjoy all by myself 😂.

Z Prime is a great spot for family dinners or a romantic date night. Depending on what time you go, you might have the place mostly to yourself, which makes for a nice, intimate setting. They even sing Happy Birthday! 🎂

Job well done, Z Prime! I shall definitely return. Steak lovers, make your way there — you won’t be disappointed! 👏🏽🥩“