5 Best Ice Cream Shops near Sackets Harbor

Straders Ice Cream Stand Ice Cream Shop • $
119 W Main St, Sackets Harbor

“It’s not the shop you must see to wake an inner child with in, but the whole experience of walking tranquil streets of the Sakets Harbor Town. The ice-cream stand with its little chairs is an add on bonus, thou ice-cream was delish, and portions are way over generous. Come late the evening to enjoy Sunset. I was bless by nice weather and absence of damn self-proclaimed “ influencers.“

4.7 Superb11 Reviews
Pennocks Icecream Ice Cream Shop • $
13162 State Rte 3, Sackets Harbor

“Great tasting ice cream from a classic roadside stand. Plenty of outdoor seating although the parking lot is oddly shaped, it only adds to the charm. A steady stream of locals were in line before and after my visit. The rainbow sprinkles were a bit too crunchy for my tastes.“

3.8 Good17 Reviews
Jodi's Dairy Bar Ice Cream Shop • $
19278 NY-12F, Dexter - 7.4 miles

“They are the only place that carries my wife’s favorite ice cream, Queen of Hearts. (I like it too). Their soft serve is also great! It’s not the closest ice cream place but we will go there just for Queen of Hearts, and to change things up.“

5 Superb24 Reviews
Lickety Split Ice Cream Shoppe Ice Cream Shop • $
215 Water St, Dexter - 5.52 miles

Customers` Favorites

Custard

“Best ice cream around, hands down. It's custard, so it's extra thick and creamy. Peanut butter soft serve is really excellent, but their basic chocolate and vanilla is tasty as well. Really nice outdoor seating area by the water, take a short walk across the little foot bridge for an almost always empty pavilion, or the village dock with ample parking is just down the road for some different scenery. Service is always friendly and quick. The only thing I don't care for is their chocolate sprinkles. They're the hard crunchy ones that don't taste like chocolate. Not a dealbreaker since the ice cream is so good on its own, but a switch back to the better ones would be much appreciated. Regardless, this is the best ice cream you will find in the area and I will always bring visiting friends here over anywhere else.“

4.5 Superb38 Reviews
Trolley Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
8355 State Rte 3, Henderson - 8.22 miles

“The only thing keeping this from being 5 star is it takes way too long to get served. I'm not sure why it takes so long. It's about 10 minutes per person. It's only scooping ice cream nothing fancy. If there are more than 5 people waiting we go down the street.“

4 Good17 Reviews
Loading...
map Map