18 Bay
CLOSED$$$$ •
11 Stearns Point Rd, Shelter Island Heights
18 Bay Reviews
Very special experience: great food; wonderful chefs, delightful and knowledgeable waitstaff, charming and helpful management; no hype, razzle dazzle, pretense or raucous noise. All charm and great food. One of party had a birthday and the staff helped us celebrate. One in our party could not eat clams and they sweetly and humorously fixed something else. Prix fixe menu was exceptional. Fun wine pairings and tasty cocktails. Worth the cost. New location was roomy, stylish and...read full review
Prefix menu. Food is always delicious. High end restaurant, it's about $125 per person. So we always go there for a celebratory dinner. Highly recommend for a special night out.
Ratings
Menu
People in Shelter Island Heights Also Viewed
Best meal and experience of our vacation - friendly, yet professional staff, idyllic setting (we sat on the porch), incredible food (we love making little or no decisions!!), only place I have ever been that every wine is available by the glass (brilliant). Thrilled to hear that you are possibly staying open past the Summer season. We will be back.