Shelter Island Craft Brewery

55 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island
(631) 749-9051

Recent Reviews

Gráinne

I was here with my family and our dog in November and we had a great time! They were friendly and welcoming from the moment we walked in. Delicious beer and great vibes :)

MG L

so many great changes! my favorite local IPA and the new Pilsner is amazing. Can’t wait to go back.Very impressed with the improvements over the past few years!

Justin S.

Awesome spot!!! Great beer. Friendly spot and very warm and welcoming!! Highly recommend grabbing a beer!!!

david daly

Under new ownership and the improvements are impressive! The IPAs are now fantastic, the setting is so comfortable with indoor and outdoor seating, and awesome to-go food right next door at Marias. Don’t miss this wonderful small craft brewery on your journey across Shelter Island and stop by for a pint or a local wine or cider.

Benigno Gonzalez

Great local brewery! A perfect location for a birthday party or a rehearsal dinner. So cute! We are big fans of their summer craft beers!

G W

An amazing spot with great beer and wonderful staff and owner.

%%%%%

I was just driving around that corner of the island trying to find my way back to the ferry, when I run into this brewery, the bartenders were super relaxed and helpful about what to order. I tasted the 114 IPA, it was just a great refreshing beer. Now that I know my way around I will make a stop at the brewery when I visit the island.

Brian G.

Stopped in here on a dreary day during our trip, and had a wonderful time. They have a very small food menu, that essentially includes a giant pretzel and personal pizza. We got two of the pretzels and they were actually giant, which isn't always the case. There is also a mexican deli next door that they recommend, and is very good. The building is SMALL. We lucked out that our party of 5 (+ our baby) arrived just as another party was packing up, because there is literally one table inside. Clearly on more busy days the few tables outside provide more seating. The Nude Beach beer was delicious!

Danielle Bremer

Great tasting beers and great vibes! We will definitely be back here.

Michele E

Delicious beer, friendly bartenders, lots of outdoor seating and some indoor seating, and best of all, dog friendly! They even carry a “dog beer!”

AllenFein

Gave this a mediocre review three year’s ago because I could not find a beer that I liked. This time I found their Pilsner style fresh pour absolutely delicious. Friendly helpful staff too. Nice outdoor tables where the wonderful beer can be savored. Will stop buy whenever passing through!

Tim Feldis

Great brewery. Very impressive sour. I will be back.

Lee

Ok super disappointed. Walked a lot my way there from the ferry and … it was closed (on a Friday!). Bummed.

Matthew Regan

Under new ownership I believe. Very friendly owner and great service. Everything was awesome!

John Collins

Great spot for a break from the water.Always interesting brews. I like to grab a beer while my order at Maria’s kitchen next door is being made.

Load More