Shelter Island Whale's Tale

CLOSED
$ •

About Shelter Island Whale's Tale

Shelter Island Whale's Tale is a charming spot for a quick ice cream stop and a round of mini golf. The place has a cute, charmingly cute vibe, and the ice cream is bursting with flavors, though it's only a solid 3/5 rating. The staff is incredibly sweet and friendly, adding to the overall positive experience.

The mini golf course has seen some recent improvements, with the greens back to normal and the 18th hole revamped. The addition of a wheel at three of the holes, where players spin and must complete a task, is an inventive and inexpensive way to change up the game. While the food and drinks inside can be expensive, the proprietor, Eric, works hard to keep the place running smoothly.

Despite the need for some renovations, Shelter Island Whale's Tale is a must-visit for exceptional ice cream and a fun game of mini golf, especially for families looking for a low-key, family-friendly entertainment option on the East End.