The Eccentric Bagel
$ • Pet Friendly
Hours:
25 W Neck Rd, Shelter Island
(631) 749-5363
About The Eccentric Bagel
Customers' Favorites
Piled High Hash Browns with a Side of Extra Thick Cut Bacon
Lox Spread Cream Cheese with Freshly Baked Onion Rolls
Homemade Bread Bowl w New England Clam Chowder
Sesame Bagel with Scallion Cream Cheese
Wades Beach Bagel Sandwich
Eccentric Lox Spread
The Eccentric
Pizza Bagels
Woopie Pie
The Eccentric Bagel Reviews
Ratings
Menu
Add a Menu
Hours
| Monday | 7AM - 3PM |
| Tuesday | 7AM - 3PM |
| Wednesday | 7AM - 3PM |
| Thursday | 7AM - 3PM |
| Friday | 7AM - 3PM |
| Saturday | 7AM - 3PM |
| Sunday | 7AM - 2PM |
People in Shelter Island Also Viewed
Isola
Italian, Cocktail Bar, Pizza
The Islander
Family, Burgers, Pet Friendly
Crabby Jerry's
Seafood, American, Pet Friendly
The Eccentric Bagel is a highly-regarded restaurant, known for its exceptional bagels that meet New York City standards. It is the only bagel shop on Shelter Island, making it a unique and popular destination. The friendly staff serves a wide variety of options, including the popular jalapeno cheddar bagel. Their bagel chips are a standout, with many customers enjoying samples of the everything bagel and cheddar bagel chips. The owner, Darryn, is known for being extremely friendly and welcoming. The croissant is perfectly toasted, and the turkey + cheese bagel is generous and satisfying. Customers praise the delicious bagels, especially the best everything bagel, and the flavorful options like smoked bacon bagel, which is available on weekends. The bagel chips are highly recommended as snacks. The restaurant offers great flavors and a cozy vibe, making it a must-visit spot when in the Hamptons for a satisfying and delicious meal. It is often praised as the best bagel place on the East End and is loved for its eccentric and mouth-watering flavors. The coffee, muffins, and cookies are also noted as delicious, adding to the overall experience.