7 Best Italian Restaurants near Sherrill

“We love checking out local food establishments, and the reviews on this one did not disappoint. We were staying at Turning Stone RV Park, could have gone anywhere, but chose this one for lunch before afternoon of golf. Start with the server...she was excellent, helped us make choices , did not oversell us...and she was VERY honest and helpful. Started with Italian Antipasto salad we split between the two of us...she gave us a few dressing options and the salad was absolutely amazing! Next we had small Calzone with cheese and pepperoni, again amazing, with side of excellent Marinara sauce, best we have ever had! The place is unassuming, but absolutely has the local flair and comfort that makes you feel at home.... compliments the awesome food and service perfectly. They also sell meats, cheeses, jarred goods (I bought a jar of pickled hot eggs... amazing)! We will be back, love supporting excellence of service and food quality in a small town atmosphere... 💯 Recommended!“

“Let’s start with the food… nothing short of AMAZING. We got an array of food, chicken, veal, pasta, shrimp, calamari. The portion sizes are UNREAL. Enough for at least two meals after you eat. Now our waitress Brenda. She is everything a waitress should be and MORE. Unbelievable people skills. She made us feel like family, like we’ve known her forever. She was absolutely INCREDIBLE!❤️ we’ll be back for sure!“

“Food is great, service was pretty good. Everything is made on location, even bread & desserts. Best restaurant in Rome, easily. I had a "lobster tail" for dessert (flaky pastry in shape of lobster tail filled with chocolate mousse). It was off-the-charts-GREAT. Go! Prices are very decent, food is great.“

“First time trying your place out, we went to the one in Oneida. Ordered the pizza and wing special from Facebook and it was truly amazing! Pizza had just the right amount of sauce and cheese and looked great. The wings were cooked perfectly, just like I asked. Customer service was excellent also! Thanks so much and we will definitely be back again!“

“Ended up here when our grill wouldn’t work while camping. We had Stefanie and she was fantastic. Great recommendations and super friendly. The food was delicious and we would absolutely go again. We sat outside but inside was super cute + cozy.“

“In response to our most recent review from Kris Baldwin.

Thank you for taking the time to leave a review. We're glad to hear you enjoyed the service and the BBQ burger.

However, after looking into your comments, it appears this review may have been intended for a different restaurant. We do not serve Gold Peak tea, we don't use Ken's dressings, and we do not serve mahi mahi.

As the kitchen manager, I take great pride in the quality and freshness of the food we prepare, so I wanted to clarify this in case there was a mix-up. If you believe you may have reviewed the wrong restaurant, we'd greatly appreciate it if you could update or remove the review.

Thank you, and we hope you'll visit us again soon.“

“Stopped and ordered a slice and a soda while on a walk with my dog. Not only was the slice better than expected with perfectly crisped thin crust , the owner filled a bowl of ice cold water for my dog and brought it out to him on the patio. Its the little things that make a business better than the rest. Thank you for your food and hospitality. We will be back.“