Bagels Restaurants near Shirley, NY

“Us New Yorkers know good bagels ! This establishment is ON POINT ! The bagels are so fresh and soft . Try the chicken salad on everything bagel ! It’s Like my grandma made it back in the day . Friendly staff …. Let’s put it this way . I live in Manorville 4.7 miles away from said establishment. . I have a bagel store literally 3/4 mile down the road and I’ll travel the 4.7 to get QUALITY AND CONSISTENCY. I wish them loooooong term s success and are around FOR VERY LONG TIME! It’s definitely not easy to find establishments that you know what you’re going to receive each time. In my picture you’ll notice some chopped tomatoes that’s because I add them.“

“Great egg sandwiches. Service ok. Great price. Took a LOOOOONG time to get our egg sandwiches, that were called in PRIOR to arriving. 🤷🏻‍♂️ oh well. I’ll be back though, all good.

Parking: Fine close lot

Kid-friendliness: Sure“

“Honestly this place has made a complete Change very Sorry to Say. There is one specific young woman...That is very nasty with a Attitude Problem. When I was waiting for My Order I saw how all the staff works. Unfortunately there are some of the staff that have Attitudes. This is not how to run a business Very Sorry to Say and no disrespect to The Owner or Management. This Problem needs to be Corrected. Otherwise The Food is Okay. The Bagels are always fresh. Thank You...“

“One of the best stores in Shirley. The family running the store are very nice, kind hearted, and hard working people. They will go above and beyond when it comes to customer service and accommodations. And they're sandwiches breakfast/lunch always on point. Thank you guys for everything you do and many blessings to you all.“

“Best Home Fries Ever! I get them with melted mozzarella and bacon in top! So good! My husband loves their breakfast sandwiches! The fact that I work next door is a bonus for sure! If you’ve never been here you’re missing out!“

“Just had an excellent wrap and the staff was extremely nice. Highly Recommended!!!!!!!!“

“Always great food and friendly staff…. A favorite spot of The Founding Sons LE/MV MC Mother Chapter.“

“I love this place. The food is always delicious!!!“

“Been going to Joel's bagels forever! Rolando and family are such beautiful people, warm, welcoming, and funny. I moved to patchogue some years back and began the hunt for a good bagel spot. I walked in and couldn't believe how friendly everyone was. Instantly it became my #1 go-to. The food is tasty and the people treat you like family. Now I'm a few towns over and worth the trip back each and every time!“

“Just an amazing place overall. Food is awesome and great staff. Trust me when I tell you.. the black and white cookies are delectable. See you guys there!“

“I hadn't had a New York bagel in over 20 years, so I knew when I brought my teen for a visit to Long Island that's what we had to get. Pete's did not disappoint! I got the everything bagel with lox and that was the best bagel I've had in ages. My teen had an everything bagel with cream cheese and they agreed theirs was the best ever too!“

“Good service, I recommend people from mastic to go there, best restaurant to go eat in the morning, you can place order over the phone too. In overall the restaurant is really good.“

“We've been going here for a long time n it's our ONLY go to spot for bagels. ALWAYS great n friendly service n delicious bagels. No matter what day or time their bagels are ALWAYS FRESH. We highly recommend BETTER ON A BAGEL in MILLER PLACE. Thank you Better On A Bagel crew. 💗🥯🥯🥯🥯“

“My daughter recommended this place said it looked interesting. The food is unbelievably good. The bodega food is exceptional as well as the pizza that is well above most of the places in that area. Pizza in Patchogue is a little tough to find good quality. On top of that The service is fantastic always served with a smile and great attitude.“

“I've had the opportunity to enjoy an occasional bagel from a slew of bagel shops stretching from Ohio all the way to Delaware and I must admit, the bagels at Bagel Buddies are EXCEPTIONAL! So much that I travel all the way from Nassau County once a month to stock up! Additionally, the staff is always friendly and the store is always well kept. I HIGHLY recommend Bagel Buddies! Quite possibly THE BEST bagels I've had. Ever!“

“That’s definitely a amazing breakfast spot, they all are so loving and always go above and beyond for their customers and I witnessed it but today whoever lady was on register I guess related with owners or one of the Owner I’m not sure about it and I don’t want to because for one coffee and for a few cents, she became so rude and it was an embarrassment because other customers were standing over there. I went there like hundred times I never had such bad experience which I had today and I don’t want to go there anymore. No, you would not professional at all the face you made I don’t know why was not welcoming in the way you insulted doesn’t suit your business. I’m very sorry. I had to write it, but you would not professional an ethical.“

“It’s always a pleasure to eat here. The atmosphere is excellent. The employees are friendly, quick, and efficient. The wait times are minimal. This is how a bagel shop should be operated. As busy as they get, I still don’t have to wait very long at all. Food, customer service, and atmosphere are all in A+.“

“Bagel Patch in Medford, CT, holds such a special place in my husband's heart—it's the bagel spot he grew up with, where his dad would always pick up fresh bagels on the weekends. We made sure to stop by over Easter weekend to keep the tradition alive, and it did not disappoint! The bagels were just as delicious as he remembered—fresh, perfectly chewy, and full of that classic flavor. It was such a sweet and nostalgic experience, and a reminder that sometimes the best places are the ones tied to the best memories.“

“The employees are always delightful and willing to go above and beyond in order to satisfy our taste buds! We have been here a couple of times and our breakfast/lunch sandwiches never disappoint! I hate drinking coffee from bagel stores because it always tastes watered down but this one always exceeds my expectations, definitely a must visit!“

“I ordered a breakfast bagel of sausage, egg and cheese on a toasted sesame bagel with a side of the potatoes.
I have to say it was the best breakfast bagels I have had in well over a year!!! Thank you!!!
I had to have it delivered and honestly thought it would be cold, boy was I happily suprised!!! It was still hot after a 20 minute car ride!!
I will definitely order from this deli again!
Once again thank you, I look forward to tasting other items off your menu, as will many others I recommend you to.“

“Just had for my first time and actually leaving a review. PHENOMENAL. BLT was gigantic and perfectly done. Salad - build your own and price can’t be beat with the freshest ingredients. Seriously top notch“

“Friendly staff, decent food, the store itself could use some upgrades though. Lots of makeshift signs with random stickers. There's a counter but the seats are dirty and old and the counter is coming apart so you can't sit and eat comfortably.“

“Great bagels, fantastic staff and all around great place!!“

“Easily the Best bagels in Rocky point. This place is seriously underrated. Great service and kind staff. The bagels are better than anywhere else around. Seriously, you want a classic bagel exactly the way it should be, soft on the inside and nice blistered on the outside. Cooked at a perfect temperature, really you're missing out if you aren't coming here every morning. Btw did I mention the prices are incredible, they have not increased the prices like other places have. 5 bucks and change gets you a CC bagel and coffee. Inflation who? Not here my man... Not to mention this is a LOCAL spot. People talk about small businesses, GO OUT AND SUPPORT your LOCAL small businesses!!! Why sit here reading reviews? Go get a bagel.“

“Got Great 5 Egg Omellette with Unlimited Toppings for $13.50
they Dont Skimp on the toppings I got Bacon, Ham, Sausage, Tomato, mushroom, Chedder Cheese (plus 2 Egg add on to make 5 Total eggs)
Tasty & Chock Full of every topping
Great Place for Omelletes & Breakfast“