Island Empanada Shirley
$ • Empanadas, Latin American, Puerto RicanAbout Island Empanada Shirley
Customers' Favorites
Rice & Beans with Sweet Plantains
Rice & Beans with Sweet Plantains
Mini Mac & Cheese Balls 2 Balls
Chipotle Chicken Pollo Chipotle
Chicken & Rice Soup Small 12 Oz
Corned Beef Empanada
Oreo Cookie Empanada
Pastelon Empanada
Four Cheese Combo
Dipping Sauce
Island Empanada Shirley Reviews
96 ratings
Share your opinion about Island Empanada Shirley
Great service the guy Jacob there was very helpful
The variety and the taste of all wow!! you have to try them!!
Best empanadas and mac and cheese balls! Recently, had a superior experience where I had ordered through uber eats to be delivered to my house. Part of the order was incorrect. I tried to reconcile it with Uber eats to no avail. So I stopped down at the store and spoke with the manager, and he graciously replaced the incorrect part of my order. He technically did not need to do that. Because if you order through uber eats, it is between you and them. But he did it anyway since...read full review
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 8PM |
Island Empanada Shirley is a go-to spot for delicious empanadas. The service is fast and the food is yummy, making it a perfect choice for a quick lunch. With a great assortment of empanadas, including veggie options, it's a hit for catering orders too. Whether it's for a Halloween party or any event, the empanadas, wings, mac and cheese balls, and rice and beans are all a big hit. The staff is friendly and ensures that catering orders are ready on time. Island Empanada Shirley is a crowd-pleaser for any occasion. Customers praise the authentic Puerto Rican flavors, calling them on point and the only authentic place left in Suffolk County. The tostones and maltas are very good, and the employees are very nice. The atmosphere has a good balance of fun and professional. While some found the utensils flimsy, the food is consistently hot and delicious, with many recommending the pastelon empanada, pernil empanada, and Philly cheesesteak empanada, and tostones.