Spanish Restaurants near Shirley, NY

La Placita Meat Market Spanish • $
58 Surrey Cir, Shirley

Customers` Favorites

Guacamole Pico De Gallo

“La Placita is a very welcoming and cozy place where you feel comfortable as soon as you walk in. The staff is friendly, kind, and always ready to help, which makes the shopping experience really pleasant. They offer a great variety of products, and everything is well organized and easy to find. The prices are very good, making it a perfect spot for everyday shopping. Overall, La Placita has a warm, community feel with excellent service, good prices, and quality products. I highly recommend it!“

3.5 Good97 Reviews
El Matador Restaurant Spanish • $$
680 NY-112, East Patchogue - 7.4 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ensalada de Espinaca
Camarones Al Ajillo
Relleno de Camarones
Pumpkin Cheesecake
Ceviche De Camaron
Pulled Pork Plate
Paella Valenciana
Chicken Francese
Besito Salvadore
Matador Fajitas

“Unassuming restaurant from the outside. Big mistake to drive on by. Just an exquisite meal we had. Wish I had a photo to share, but gobbled it down quick. Lovely meal from first welcome to last bite.“

4.7 Superb102 Reviews
La Buena Vida Spanish Restaurant Spanish • $$
714 Montauk Hwy, Moriches - 1.99 miles

Customers` Favorites

Dates Stuffed with Goat Cheese Wrapped in Bacon
NY Strip Steak & Seafood Paella
Crème Brulee Cheesecake
Stuffed Sweet Plantain
Chocolate Mousse Cake
Churros with Ice Cream
Homemade Potato Chips
Grilled Octopus App
Pulpo A la Plancha
Pulpo A la Gallega

“I recently had the pleasure of dining at a fantastic restaurant for my wife's 60th birthday, and I have to say it was an incredible experience from start to finish. The owners were truly amazing, going above and beyond to make our evening special. We were also fortunate enough to have the delightful Michaela and Samantha as our servers, both of whom were absolutely terrific. They were attentive, friendly, and provided excellent service throughout the night. The food was also top-notch, with a wide variety of delicious options to choose from. Overall, it was a fantastic evening and I would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for a special dining experience. Thank you to the owners, Michaela, and Samantha for making my wife's birthday celebration one we will never forget!“

4.4 Superb146 Reviews
Polo Deli Food Center Spanish • $$
16 Middle Country Rd, Coram - 7.64 miles

“Best Spanish Food in the area. Fresh, delicious and good variety. Nice little selection of South American Fruits and Vegetables and bakery items also. And if your looking for the best sandwiches you'll find those there as well.. The owners is friendly and seems to really care about his customers and his business. The employees are great and always provide excellent service.. It's a must if your a local or passing through.“

4.3 Superb6 Reviews
Island Empanada Spanish • $
2040 NY-112, Medford - 7.12 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Plantains Small - Pequeño
Latin Shrimp Empanadas
Pernil and Empanadas
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Platanos Maduros
Cuban Sandwich
Rice and Beans
Tostones Small
Pork Empanada
Chicken Wings

“My experience today Island Empanada in Medford was awesome! Staff so nice polite helpful. Store very clean! Food was absolutely amazing me being Puerto Rican and all it was like having my moms cooking. Definitely plan to go again and recommend this place for sure!!!!“

4.2 Good85 Reviews
Papa Juan Deli Deli • $
451 Rte 25A Store #12, Miller Place - 11.52 miles

Customers` Favorites

Birria Taco Barbacoa Taco Chicken Taco Ground Beef Taco
Pupusas and Horchata
Pollo Asado Dinner
Stree Tacos

“Awesome variety of food and service always with a smile. Would definitely recommend ❤️“

4.8 Superb32 Reviews
Las morenitas mastic 2# Restaruant Family • $
1495 Montauk Hwy suite 1, Mastic - 1.06 miles

“My third time eating from this restaurant and it won't be my last. There are many Spanish restaurants in the area but to my knowledge it is the only Guatemalan one. The first time I went we sat down and ate, this was some time last year. The service was welcoming and friendly, the restaurant is small but very clean and nice to sit in and enjoy a meal. I've tried a few different items off their menu, they never disappoint. I hope it stays that way. Delicious little gem in Mastic.“

4.3 Superb35 Reviews
Chicken Place Spanish • $
1761 NY-112, Medford - 7.3 miles

Customers` Favorites

Medio Pollo a La Brasa Con Papas Y Ensalada Half Chicken with Salad and French Fries
Arroz Chaufa De Pollo Peruvian Fried Rice with Chicken
Arroz Chaufa De Carne Peruvian Fried Rice with Beef
Lomo Saltado De Pollo Peruvian Style Saut
1 Pollo Entero a La Brasa 1 Whole Chicken
Ceviche Mixto Mixed Ceviche
Tostones Green Plantain
Maduros Sweet Plantain
Chicharron De Calamares
Ensalada Fresca Mixta

“November 2025. Staff is good and courteous. Peruvian food. Grilled salmon with salad and Yuca is really good. Prices are normal in the area. The house juice (chicha) is delicious. They have karoeke nights on weekends. Good classy establishment. Free parking available. Fully recommended.“

3.5 Good67 Reviews
Pollo Sabroson Colombian • $
350 E Main St, Patchogue - 7.46 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fried Sweet Banana
Chicken with Rice
Chaulafan Platter
Beef Patties

“My sons and I ordered takeout today; it was convenient to order online, and it was ready at the estimated time. The serving sizes are large. We ordered chicken, yellow rice, plantains, beef patties, and rice pudding. It was all delicious. And the woman who welcomed us in and packaged up our food greeted us with a smile. There's nothing better than authentic food.“

3.9 Good16 Reviews