Carmelina's

Name: Carmelina's
Address: 61a NY-111, Smithtown, New York, 11787, US
Telephone: (631) 257-5888
Price range: $
Rating: 4.1

$ • Pizza, Salad

Hours:
61a NY-111, Smithtown
(631) 257-5888

Menu Order Online

Take-Out/Delivery Options

delivery

take-out

Customers' Favorites

Create Your Own Cheese Pizza 18

Meatball Parmigiana Hero

Chicken Marsala

Garlic Bread

Garlic Knots

Baked Ziti

Meatballs

Margherita

Half Hero

Carmelina's Reviews

4.1 (48)

Write a review

March 2024

Got the family meal deal (takeout) from Carmelita's and was really impressed with the amount of food you get for the price! I also like that you can customize the deal and pick which chicken, pasta and side dish you want. The inside of the place is new and modern. It is also immaculately clean. The staff is so friendly as well! Will definitely be back! They had a lot of options that looked really good in the display cases as well. Another time On Christmas Eve I ordered fried...read full review

February 2024

Sometimes I go there often and their plain slice leaves much to be desired. They are always friendly with me. Some days their pizza is burnt sometimes it's too small or too thick needs quality control. Make sure it doesn't come out burnt or too small or too thick just right. Free refills on drinks and that's very generous. A couple of times they made it way too thick 2 times and couldn't finish it. I don't want that to happen again Pepperoni slice is good.They don't add too...read full review

January 2024

I decided to try Carmelina's after seeing or several times. The pizza is excellent as is the service. I tried the regular cheese pizza and the Grandma Square which is made with Vodka sauce. Both were excellent. The cheese pizza was dripping with oil and the bottom was cooked to perfectionGive this place a shot. I spoke with the owner who said they've only been there about 5 months and they are trying to get the word out about their excellent pizza. You won't be disappointed!

More Reviews(48)