Southold Fish Market
$$ •About Southold Fish Market
Southold Fish Market Reviews
Always the best! Staff work so hard. Very great food, staff, and fresh fish. Family owned!
We come here all the way from FL! The freshest, most delicious seafood you can get anywhere! Never disappointed! They even guarded my cc and asked hubs for ID when he went to pick it up! � � �
My absolute favorite on the North Fork for fresh, local, delicious fish. Whether prepared or fresh, the meals I cook or order from Southold Fish always exceed expectations. That staff is incredibly talented and kind and the fish sublime. Definitely one of the best places on the North Fork.
Hours
| Monday | 9AM - 6PM |
| Tuesday | 9AM - 6PM |
| Wednesday | 9AM - 6PM |
| Thursday | 9AM - 6PM |
| Friday | 8AM - 7PM |
| Saturday | 8AM - 7PM |
| Sunday | 8AM - 5PM |
Southold Fish Market is a charming place to enjoy fresh seafood. The shrimp cocktail and lobster roll were delicious, and the fresh seafood for sale looked amazing. They offer a variety of meals like Sesame Seared Tuna Tacos and Bay Scallop basket, both with a choice of fries or salad. The tacos were flavorful with a tasty sesame ginger sauce, while the scallops were sweet and tender. The New England chowder and Lobster BLT were also freshly made and tasty. The market has a great selection of fresh fish, shellfish, smoked fish, eel, and white fish, making it a perfect place to buy seafood. It is a busy spot, especially on weekends, with limited indoor seating and outdoor picnic tables, making it a nice place for a meal, especially in the summer. Everyone at the market is polite and welcoming, and the staff are always helpful. The place has a charming seaside vibe that makes visitors feel like they’ve found a local treasure. Watching people come and go, and buying fish at the counter, adds to the fun experience. Many customers love the fresh, warm lobster roll with bountiful lobster and toasted bun, and enjoy the substantial side salad with juicy beefsteak tomatoes. A variety of oysters, raw and steamed little neck, and mayo mahi tacos with a wonderful coleslaw are also available. The smoked trout was amazing and the cod sandwich superb. Ahi tuna over greens and mahi fish taco are also really good. It is packed for lunch in the middle of the day. Overall, Southold Fish Market is a wonderful seafood spot that offers both a small market and eat-in options, making it a favorite for locals and visitors alike.