Cookie Jar

Name: Cookie Jar
Address: 1226 Forest Ave, Staten Island, New York, 10310, US
Telephone: (718) 448-3500
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.7

$$ • Bakery, Pet Friendly, Gluten-Free

Hours:
1226 Forest Ave, Staten Island
(718) 448-3500

Menu Order Online

Take-Out/Delivery Options

take-out

delivery

Customers' Favorites

1 Dozen Red Velvet Cupcakes

2 lb Assorted Cookies

Cookie Jars

Cookie Jar Reviews

4.7 (51)

Write a review

March 2024

Consistently my favorite cookie shop, they make the best rainbow cookies (each individually coated in chocolate.) The brownies are great if you want a chocolate fix, I especially love the salted caramel brownies. They also have great hamentashen and Italian cookies if you want something lighter.I haven't found anything here that I haven't loved except maybe the cookie/brownie. I prefer brownies to be gooey and chewy, while I prefer chocolate chip cookies to be thin and crispy....read full review

March 2024

Ordered a selection of cookies for an event. Staff was very helpful and courteous. Our guests loved the cookies and were grateful to take home an abundance of extras.Vegetarian options: Vegan chocolate chip cookies were highly praised by our vegan guest.

December 2023

Clean location, fresh baked delicious products. Very friendly staff. Sometimes a little tough to get a close parking spot ( I'm handicapped) but worth to extra steps. Many different cookies and cookie platters. Great collection of cookies jars on display, some for sale. They also have a few other locations, ALL worth a visit.

More Reviews(225)