Cookie Jar
$$ • Bakery, Pet Friendly, Gluten-FreeAbout Cookie Jar
Customers' Favorites
2 lb Rainbow Petit Fours Aka 7 Layer Cookies
1 Dozen Red Velvet Cupcakes
1 Dozen Assorted Cupcakes
2 lb Assorted Cookies
Cookies & Cup Cakes
Chocolate Explosion
Feeling Nutty
Cookie Jars
Cookie Trays
Sandwich
Cookie Jar Reviews
209 ratings
Share your opinion about Cookie Jar
From one business owner to another, I couldn't be more happy for the lovely treats James and Maria Carozza at Cookie Jar delivered to me as a gift! This speaks to the generosity and thoughtfulness of Cookie Jar as a whole, and I only wish for this business's continued success!
Got my princess an elf cookie jar that they literally just held for me and I had forgot about it lol
the staff here is so sweet and down to earth and their cookies are the perfect gift 🎁 I can’t wait to go grab my next cookie jar!!
the staff here is so sweet and down to earth and their cookies are the perfect gift 🎁 I can’t wait to go grab my next cookie jar!!
I wish I had fotos of the cookies I bought, but I ate them before I had the chance.😂
Cookie jar has the best cookies in New York, I had grown up in the neighborhood but never tried them and WOW are they wonderful. I love that they have so many options you can chose from, I had a vanilla cookie with coconut and raspberry filling in the middle, another one that was a mix between a brownie and a cookie as well as the classic Italian Rainbow Cookie. Will definitely...read full review
Cookie jar has the best cookies in New York, I had grown up in the neighborhood but never tried them and WOW are they wonderful. I love that they have so many options you can chose from, I had a vanilla cookie with coconut and raspberry filling in the middle, another one that was a mix between a brownie and a cookie as well as the classic Italian Rainbow Cookie. Will definitely...read full review
Hours
| Monday | 10AM - 7PM |
| Tuesday | 10AM - 7PM |
| Wednesday | 10AM - 7PM |
| Thursday | 10AM - 7PM |
| Friday | 9AM - 8PM |
| Saturday | 9AM - 8PM |
| Sunday | 9AM - 5PM |
Cookie Jar is the ultimate bakery experience, serving up absolute perfection with gooey centers and crispy edges in every bite. Their rainbow cookies and salted caramel brownies are a must-try, alongside the hamentashen and Italian cookies for something lighter. The selection includes a variety of soft cookies, with particularly notable chocolate chip cookies that are fresh and not excessively sweet, making them enjoyable. The staff is helpful and courteous, with vegan options like the highly praised vegan chocolate chip cookies. There is a drink of the month, The Cosmic Brownie, which pairs nicely with a matching cookie, and the hot chocolate, made with melted down chocolate chips, is rich and satisfying. Cookie Jar also offers a whole jelly collection, nuts collection, and chocolate collection, plus plenty of cupcakes and drink options. The dine-in area has small tables along the wall, perfect for enjoying the impressive cookie jar collection. Parking is available on the street. Whether a fan of chocolate fixes or delightful treats, Cookie Jar is sure to satisfy sweet tooth cravings with a delightful visit.