50 Best Italian Restaurants in Staten Island

“Everything was beautiful , service food & decor !“

“Great Service! Excellent Food and Delicious Pastries“

“Everything was great at even greater prices for the quality of food and service you receive here“

“si pranza divinamente con prodotti di qualità. Il proprietario è molto simpatico. lo consiglio.“

“BUEN LUGAR EXCELENTE COMIDA MAGNIFICAS RECETAS GRACIAS VOLVEREMOS 🇲🇽💚🇮🇹💜🍀🎁“

“Giuliano’s Restaurant is a place where the food is absolutely fantastic. I’ve never ordered something that I didn’t love. The staff are all wonderful. From the first time you walk-in the doors they make you feel like you’re part of their family. I highly highly recommend this restaurant.“

“The food never ever disappoints“

“I was at a family affair at Angelinas on March 30 2025. I was so impressed with the food, service and atmosphere that I needed to express how amazing the experience was! The food was outstanding! If you are looking for true authentic Italian food, Angelina's is the one. I was so impressed with the service that I needed to shout her out. Her name is Ida, she is from Italy and she was amazing! She ensured that each person was taken care of throughout the event. It is very hard to find a restaurant with a rating of a perfect 10, but Angelina's is! Loved it!“

“Amazing service and food, absolutely delicious!!“

“Food was fresh and very good“

“Definitely one of the best thin crust pies out there!!

Can't go wrong with these three pies!

Denino's A Salute pie with arugula and Prosciutto

Denino’s “M.O.R.” Pie

(Meatball, Fresh Onions & Ricotta)

Denino’s Margarita Pie

(Fresh Mozzarella, Basil, Marinara Sauce

with Grated Cheese)

Clam pie on garlic sauce

Parking can be hard to find but there is street parking in front and around neighborhood.“

“Excellent food, excellent service and excellent atmosphere. I promise if you try this place, you will be extremely satisfied and for sure you will go back again! This restaurant serves the best Italian food in Staten Island.“

“Great food and service. .we went with a group of 10 people and everyone enjoyed their food .we been back many times and even had them do a party for us :)“

“Mona Lisa has a large variety of selections that can feed anyone. Their New York pie is a must try! 10/10“

“I recently had the pleasure of dining at Pizza Kitchen, and it was an exceptional experience! The pizza was outstanding, with a perfectly cooked crust and a generous amount of fresh, flavorful toppings. Every bite was delicious, and it was clear that they use high-quality ingredients.The staff at Pizza Kitchen were warm and attentive, ensuring that we had everything we needed. The atmosphere was inviting and comfortable, making it an ideal spot for a relaxed meal with friends or family. If you're in search of delicious pizza and a great dining experience, I highly recommend Pizza Kitchen. I’m looking forward to my next visit!“

“Had an amazing experience today! Our server Roberto was the best! We came to Staten Island from North Jersey after seeing your IG videos Great food and atmosphere. Glad we came on a Tuesday at 2:30. Not as busy and had a very nice meal. Delicious !!!“

“We had an intimate Repast at Farington's Cafe after the sudden death of my nephew. We were all so impressed with the food... a delicious salad and one of the best penne vodka dishes ever. These were followed by the main course...choice of lemon sole, flank steak or chicken parm. Each and every dish was superb! Beyond this, the compassion shown by the staff was so consoling. I recommend this restaurant to all. You will thank me!“

“Hosted my husbands birthday party in their private party room this weekend and I must say this restaurant was fantastic!!! The service was awesome and the food and drinks were on point! I highly recommend Boccelli!“

“Excellent service , cozy atmosphere. Place is second to none !“

“We had our daughters Sweet 16 dinner there last night with about 30 people. Everything was perfect! The staff was attentive, the food was delicious and the prices are just right. This was our second time here and we will continue as customers.“

“Had a dinner party for my daughter . Jimmy and Marco were super accommodating. Everything was perfect . Never felt rushed . At end of night had guests lingering and waitstaff was very understanding . Thank you again for our 4th celebration there .“

“Great food and service ! Love the atmosphere“

“I have always loved Bella Mamas,, and now it's has gotten even better, with the grilled pizzas , the new menu, the portion are huge and you are definitely taking left overs. very inviting atmosphere.“

“The food was delicious!!!“

“place is GREAT.Been there with my dates and with the boys. and the eye candy of bartenders are nice as well... food, service, latmosphere, staff and owner.. all great!!!!! very highly recommend“

“Went to Osfizio last weekend and it was great! The food was so good, the waiter, and all the staff were so nice and polite. There were food options for everyone. Willie was our waiter and he went above and beyond for our table. Will definitely be returning! 10/10“

“First time visiting tonight! The dining experience was great and the food is delicious! The service was very friendly! I'd definitely go again and recommend to anyone in search of a good Italian restaurant! :)“

“Apps and entrees are delicious...have eaten here 5 times and had something different each time...was never disappointed. Always have really good specials too...just don't ask for olive oil with your bread...I don't think it was even olive oil...very bad...otherwise is great.“

“Love, love, love The Manor. If you want a nice, sit-down dinner, some quick apps, or just some pizza, The Manor has it all. The food is delicious, the portions are huge and the price is fair. The staff is extremely friendly and helpful. The atmosphere makes everyone feel at home. The Manor is a family favorite!“

“We had a wonderful family dinner at Lava. The food was excellent and the service was outstanding!! We can’t wait to return!“

“Absolutely the best Italian restaurant in NY. I'm extremely picky and very critical. so many places through the years came and went but Ninos was always on point. and the people from bus boys to owner are always perfect. make u feel like u are family“

“Alfredo and his team are masterful! Accommodating of a group that grew from 16 to 26. A son couldn’t wish for a better place to celebrate his mom’s 85th birthday!! The staff were attentive and very well spoken… while I heard they do take out, I recommend going there for the experience!!!“

“We can’t recommend Osteria Santina enough! The food is spectacular, one dish better than the other, large portions, and something for everyone on the menu. The drinks are affordable and delicious. The staff are curious, personable, and present, never leaving an empty plate in front of you or a drink empty. Whether it is for a large party or an intimate meal, Osteria Santina is your place! Highly recommend and I can guarantee you won’t be disappointed!“

“We had our daughter's surprise graduation party at Max's Esca last night. Every single thing was outstanding- from the atmosphere, to the service, the drinks and the food. They created a beautiful, private space in the main dining room for us to decorate. Christina and Chrissy (& the rest of the staff!) took excellent care of everyone, and Nicole's cocktails were spot on. The food was incredible, as usual! Highly recommend!“

“The service was Excellent and the food was outstanding highly recommend!!!“

“We love this place! The homemade pasta is phenomenal! The service here is always outstanding and the drinks are fabulous! However, it gets very loud. Almost to the point where you can't hear the people sitting across from you. With that said, it never deters us from returning and the little almond biscottis they serve with espresso makes up for it!“

“Wonderful Italian restaurant. The food was delicious, service: extraordinary and the atmosphere intimate. Perfect date night restaurant. My wife and I enjoyed our night out. Sangria was beyond tasty. Highly recommend this restaurant as I will be returning.“

“Excellent food and service. A hidden gem.“

“Great food & ambiance We were there for a Christmas party before Covid“

“Enjoyed a delicious birthday dinner with a few close friends. Everything from the wine to the apps , dinner and dessert was so very good. The staff did a great job singing “Happy Birthday” adding a special touch for a most enjoyable evening with my dear friends. If you have something special to celebrate , reserve a table and enjoy your evening there. You won’t be disappointed!“

“Wow what an AMAZING place. Service and Food were both outstanding. We definitely will return again. Thank you Giacamo for everything.“

“Thank you to Rob and staff. Everything was great last night.“

“Aunt Butchies has outstanding food and an amazing atmosphere. They never disappoint. The service is always impeccable. Always my place to go for a surperb meal and cocktail.“

“There's is no picture. Why you ask? Because it was the best spaghetti with oil, garlic. Broccoli and eggplant I've ever eaten. I'm not a red sauce food lover but I will travel from Laguardia Airport again to come sit here and drink and eat my non red sauce dinner again . 10 stars from me.“

“Antonio’s is our family’s favorite spot to grab lunch and dinner items. Every holiday we host has something from here as well. Their food is delicious and fresh. Every time we bring something to an event, everyone asks where it was purchased. It is extremely clean. The nicest part of this business are the people who run it. They always have a warm welcome and could not be more accommodating. Tottenville is lucky to have this neighborhood gem. Keep up the great work.“

“Loosing cafe Luna on Paige ave was tough. It was family and it was my go to! Always knowing of this, Luna on Hylan Blvd, was told to try it. It's Pretty much the same, try it! Being apprehensive I went and I'm glad I did! I'm establishing another family real fast. The pizza is outstanding. There are different flavors. Don't get me wrong but still Stella food and service. I recommend going there if you're in the same boat as me with losing out on Paige Ave Luna. Alex and his staff are fantastic! Very attentive and it's a family atmosphere. A++++“

“We had the eggplant and rice balls it was delicious we will be going back great friendly staff I love the frozen cappuccino“

“Best pizza on island“

“In my opinion, this is truly the BEST restaurant on Staten Island. It blows away some of the finest steakhouses in the world. They also make their own fresh pasta and bread daily. The staff goes above and beyond always to ensure your pleasure.

They have the most ❤️ BEAUTIFUL ❤️ party room too & host wonderful events/experiences.

If you need a GUARANTEED greatly successful meal/date/party/family gathering/wedding -
Trattoria Toscana is your best choice.“

“it's a new local place and both the pizza and wings were delicious. we will be going back.“