50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Stillwater

“Moreno's Pizza is our local "GO TO" even though there are closer restaurants. Tom has gone above and beyond over the years. After explaining our disappointment with his competitors inability to get a pizza order correct (over and over), he has taken care to see that our orders are on point every time. Customer service is superior! Thank you!!🍕“

“we drive from Halfmoon for joeys pizza best around“

“Good pizza? Good atmosphere. I only gave it a 4 star. The We got a meat lovers underneath. The toppings part of the crust could have been a little more well, all in all, very good pizza.“

“Food that I could eat was ok, but the staff really needs to have a book readily available that lists all ingredients in each dish.
Even if they don't show it to customers, it's critical that at least the staff have access to this information to be able to alert customers whether or not their allergen is in a particular food item.“

“The best pizza I’ve ever had! I highly recommend Villa Pizza in Clifton Park!“

“Every time im in malta I look forward to picking up slices from sergios. Throughout the years they've only gotten better. Today i was helped by a young man named tyler. I don't usually leave reviews but tyler was genuine, polite and really outgoing. Throughout the years a lot has changed in malta, but sergios stays consistent and I think their pizza might be the best in the whole region.“

“Very delicious pizza, very good recommended to anyone.“

“Great pizza and wings, our go to in Clifton Park!! Highly recommend checking out Paulie's.“

“The best pizza in Wilton / Saratoga. Yes, it's located in the Wilton mall food court which is always empty but you can't beat the prices and the Pizza is fantastic. Crust has a crunch but soft on the inside. The pizza doesn't have flop and the mouth feel is outstanding. Ha! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!!!“

“Amazing food and amazing people“

“The gal.at the jukebox was lovely I stopped in, in desperate need for a rest room locals at the bar were as expected totally local place the barmaid knew her customers, no real fancy drinks being poured. People felt entirely comfortable. They seem to have appetizers, on the bar again. Lovely people“

“The music , the food and service is excellent w the waiters that make u feel very comfortable ❤️ I suggest panzas especially for a celebration… My friends took me there and it was fabulous“

“First time at H&H and the shrooms pizza was outstanding! The crust was perfect, the flavor delightful. Truly looking forward to trying all the other varieties of pizza.“

“Excellent pizza! And chicken wings too…they have a great menu we look forward to sampling! We were just told about this place (off the beaten path) but close enough to Saratoga Lake that we brought home pizza and chicken wings and they were still hot and delicious!! We’ll definitely be back soon!“

“The food is great. The only complaint I have is that they open the doors at 10 AM, but when you arrive at that time, nothing is ready. You either have to pre-order and come back or wait until after 11 AM for food to be available. I don’t understand why they open before they’re actually ready to serve customers. Prep time should start earlier so customers can order when the business officially opens.

I only have a lunch break before 12 PM and my job is 35 minutes away, so timing matters. I went to Marino’s because I hadn’t had their pizza in decades and really wanted to try it again. Other than that, everything was okay.“

“First time here and was impressed with the food. I highly recommend this Pizzaria. I am a local guide for Google. See my review on this establishment. Mama Mia, you'll go, eat and be satisfied.“

“the gluten free pizza was AMAZING!! And the price was great!! Will definitely be going back!!!“

“Yo Venezia is the best dam Pizza & Pasta Shop !! Highly recommend this Old school family oriented restaurant. Been coming here for years. Food & service is outstanding.“

“I must express my utmost satisfaction; this pizza was truly exceptional! I thoroughly enjoyed it. My father and I intend to return soon, though I do wish it were not a forty-minute journey. We savored both the sausage and broccoli rabe slice and the blackened chicken slice—it was indeed the finest pizza I have ever tasted! The ingredients were excellent, wholesome, and fresh, and it was cooked to perfection.“

“Ordered here for my daughter’s birthday dinner last night. The food was delicious and prices on point. Thank you guys“

“So glad I picked this place tonight for dinner! A lot of friends talked about this place for years and tonight I got linguine and eggplant Parmesan. Outstanding perfect! The atmosphere, the owner everything was spot on great price definitely want to pass it on to people.“

“Great beer, perfect location, delicious food…“

“This was the first time I ordered a pizza from The House of Pizza. I knew before I ever tasted it that it was going to be delicious because restaurant was spotless, and the owners were polite and courteous. You knew the quality of the food was going to be at that high standard just because of those two things. I wasn't disappointed at all in fact I was quite impressed. I highly recommend trying The House of Pizza if you haven't already.“

“I have been here a few times and the service is great! The food is great and everyone is very friendly!“

“great prices huge pizza and insanely good wings“

“We are from out of town and stopped and grabbed a pizza quick on our way to a concert at SPAC....we definitely picked the right place! We walked in and ordered in person, was told about 20 min. Service was great and the pizza ended up being done even sooner and it was so delicious! But if you don't have that long to wait they even have a huge selection of different kinds of slices to warm up and take with you as well. We will definitely be stopping again the next time we are in town.“

“I ordered a BBQ chicken pineapple calzone with extra sauce. This thing was huge! It ended up being lunch and dinner. Best calzone I have ever had!“

“Had lunch & dinner dining in on the same day! While I was shopping &;getting my hair done. The Chicken Bacon Ranch slice was very tasty! Also the Breaded Zucchini Sticks were Excellent with Marina Sauce made there! The garlic knots are also a treat! Abdul was so kind to me, as I am disabled and use a walker. I will be back, the next time I am in Clifton Park.“

“I don't normally leave reviews but I had to my first time here looking for a buffalo sub after work came across this place I am kinda picky on my buffalo subs normally drive n hr for my favorite spot until now lol ordered close to closing time they happily toke my order which was surprising (most place have a cut off time) the people were so nice felt very welcomed and i enjoyed the old signs and history tid bits on the walls got my subs and couldn't wait to try um (ate half in my truck)lol it was an amazing sub chicken was perfect the flavor was just as good as what I travel n hr for saw so many other things I cant wait to come back and try and of course I'll b back again for my next sub craving lol and its alot closer to home which is even better if you havnt tried sub king you should I had to give 5 stars all around 😊 best part was the people and the prices are very reasonable“

“Richies is always a great place to eat. None of those fancy rolls that some sub shops make with added saw dust. Richie has a bakery make his rolls and he focuses on the meats and cheeses that go inside. I hate a roll that takes away from the taste of the ingredients.
As for his pizzas, it's nearly impossible to find a better pie and I've been in Italy. Those Italian pizzas made me miss America but mostly, miss Richies pizzas.“

“Stopped in for drinks, great bar selection Ordered the tuna tartare, beet salad and French fries. All exceeded expectations. So delicious and generous sized portions. Wish we were staying in town longer so we could return.“

“Dinner was fantastic as always. Thank you“

“First time trying Napoli’s. We are new to the area from Long Island. The Margherita pie and meatballs were good. ( It’s hard to please a Downstater who’s Italian)!? The sauce was very good. We will definitely return. They were polite and efficient“

“We came for trivia night and were blessed with a tacos and margs special. Tacos and margs were good! We assumed it would be busier because of the trivia and thus service a little slower, so we kept ordering another round of drinks when our server delivered a round. When we ordered the third round (only 2nd drink for one of us) it took about 25-30 minutes and several check ins about the missing drinks for them to bring his tap beer, and another 5-10 after that for the margs. We did also question if the wait staff had to make their own drinks too which would have obviously contributed to the delay and be understandable with the timing and busy-ness of things. Not sure what it's like on non trivia nights. Overall would definitely go again, but make sure to order several rounds of drinks at once and do not wait to order food either (though they had a food runner so that was mostly pretty quick)“

“The food here is fabulous. The quality of the food here is way above the cost. I have never had such a delicious eggplant parm is the best I have ever had and my friends burger and sweet potato fries with raspberry dip was HUGE and just as amazing.“

“Have never had a bad meal there. looking forward to annual visit in July. Great food and great service.“

“The Oböy: I was told by locals that I HAD to have one, so I did. Oh Em Gee they’re fantastic! Delicious flavor and juicy chicken, this thing is in its own class. I could have eaten 3-4 more!!“

“best pizza around definitely recommend trying“

“UPDATED 2026: Still consistently good service. Like using the app. Pizza always hot, always right. It's our usual pizza place now - easy, coupons, no hassles, no long waits (iykyk).

We've had great experience with this location. Pizza is always hot and fresh.“

“Great service and very friendly. Pizza and cannoli were excellent.“

“Great atmosphere and great beer“

“Best Egg Sandwich in town!“

“the hot delivery driver who wore shorts all winter.“

“Best doughnut I’ve ever tasted 10/10 would try again. Super soft“

“Awesome, best place to be in Saratoga“

“I tried the wings. They were cooked pretty well. I got the medium sauce. It was ok. There was not a lot of flavor or heat. The wings were pretty good quality, I did get one broken bone. There are only a couple seats. The staff was friendly. The place was fairly clean. I did not try the pizza.“

“Really great food, great atmosphere and friendly staff. Definitely check this place out if you’re around!! The cheese pizza is fantastic!“

“Great service very helpful and polite!!!“

“Lived in Toga my whole life and only just ordered from West Ave tonight and they have the best tenders and hands down the best ranch i have ever had 😳🤤 Honestly you should sell that in bottles if its homemade! The West Ave Sampler is perfect to share for 2!“

“Threat place to entertain. All staff treat you like family. The food is plentiful warm or cold as needed and delicious You will never be sorry you went“