The Cider Mill

$$ • Comfort Food, Salad, American

4221 Fay Rd, Syracuse
(315) 487-0647

Customers' Favorites

The Cider Mill Reviews

Restaurantji Rating
4.6 (297)
Restaurantji Rating

Visited for the first time last month to celebrate my husband. We were a party of 8. Making reservations ahead of time was easy and they even reached out to confirm the day of.Ashley was our waitress. She was super friendly and patient with our table (we had one person late to show up). With it being all our first time there she explained the menu well for us.Appetizers:Focaccia Bread w/ Sauce (so addicting)Calamari (huge pieces but lacking in flavor)Clam Chowder (delicious) full review

Restaurantji Rating

Loved our first visit here. Excellent food and service. I had the short ribs - meat fell off the bone and very tasty Plenty of beer and wine options. We asked to not be rushed, so we could enjoy our meal and the server was very accommodating. Dessert was strawberry shortcake and ice cream - yummy!!!

Restaurantji Rating

The focaccia, deviled eggs, salmon, and the carrot cake were fantastic! Our server Maggie was wonderful. The atmosphere was great. The people who work there were very friendly and happy.Dietary restrictions: They had vegan, gf, and vegetarian options.

More Reviews(297)



Add a Menu
The Cider Mill Menu
The Cider Mill Menu


Add a Photo
The Cider Mill
The Cider Mill
View All Photos


Monday Closed
Tuesday 5 - 8:30PM
Wednesday 5 - 8:30PM
Thursday 5 - 8:30PM
Friday 5 - 8:30PM
Saturday 5 - 8:30PM
Sunday Closed
Updated on: