10 Best Bakeries near Tannersville

“5 Stars ⭐️ Sandakan Bake is an absolute gem. The owner is nothing short of amazing — a true artisan whose passion shows in every detail. His pastries are works of art: beautifully rustic, handcrafted, and full of authentic flavor. From the towering whipped-cream-topped key lime pies to the golden, perfectly crinkled pecan pies, everything looks and tastes like it came straight out of a high-end European pastry boutique. The atmosphere he creates is warm, welcoming, and uniquely charming — a mix of farmhouse elegance and old-world bakery magic. Every visit feels personal, and his kindness and professionalism make the experience even sweeter. If you appreciate real craftsmanship, unforgettable flavors, and a bakery with soul, Sandakan Bake is an absolute must. Truly one of the best pastry artists around.“

“This is a bakery you do not forget! We moved away from 5 years ago but knew if we needed desserts there’s only one place to go. Nina is so kind and desserts are always amazing!“

“This French bakery hidden in the heart of Windham NY. The pastries are delicious. We make sure gave we go to the bakery every year when we come up for our family trip. This year we tasted an assortment of cakes, his quiche, donuts and his gluten free cake. You have to try it when you visit Windham mountain.“

“You guys were such a great part of my visit to Catskill. Your almond babka was AMAZING and I am still dreaming of it 5 days and 3,000 miles later.“

“We love their breads (the croissant bread is amazing as French toast or grilled cheese) and their pastries. Haven’t had a bad choice at all.“

“Excellent and delicious food! I highly recommend.“

“We just had the iced almond joy latte and the lemon poppyseed cruffin and both were delicious! First time there and we will definitely be back :) Loved the atmosphere and that this cozy little place exists in Cairo!“

“Everything was excellent and our server (Mia) was especially great! Thank you - we would love to come back!“

“Celiac accommodating and aware! used a separate pan for my daughters eggs and toasted her toast on the grill to avoid cross contamination in the toaster and griddle! Priceless knowing my daughters meal was safe. absolutely delicious..she cleared her plate! gluten free rice Krispy treats too!“

“Both the hot and iced vanilla oat lattes were flavorful, with homemade vanilla syrup. We have been to Fellow twice and grabbed merch (they have great shirts!).The wait this time was awful, with only one employee working the espresso machine. We waited almost 30 mins for two lattes! Overall I like the place, and they have cute outdoor seating too, but they need to staff better.“