5 Best Sandwich Shops near Tonawanda

“food is amazing and the staff is so nice!!“

“Food and staff are amazing! Would order from there again.“

“This is my favorite subway to go to! I go every lunch and dinner and the employees welcome me and make my subs perfect every time! Honestly amazing how they can handle a rush understaffed and with a smile on their faces :)! I am a little upset about the teriyaki sauce changing I really missed the original but thats not really in their control. That being said If you’re hungry and want a quick sub and a positive presence you gotta go to this subway !!“

“I love this subway location!!!!!! I won’t go to another one. They have the nicest staff ever. I always get a footlong BMT and the meat and veggies are always soooo fresh! You can see them slicing it fresh right behind the counter! As for the employees I am always met with a smile and everyone is very professional, kind and hard working. Their store manager is the best! I promise you will keep coming back just for one of her sandwiches and a good chat. I couldn’t recommend this spot any more!! Thank you Tonawanda subway, for your consistency and positivity that makes everyone’s day.“

“There’s something to be said about a place that doesn’t chase every new trend but instead focuses on getting the fundamentals right—and this restaurant does just that. From the moment you walk in, there's an unpretentious charm. The ambiance isn’t trying too hard; it feels lived-in, in a comforting way, like it’s been part of the community for years.
Service was timely and polite. You won’t find over-the-top presentation here, but the warmth and attention to detail are very real. Our server remembered small requests and had a great sense of timing when it came to checking in.
The menu isn’t massive, which I see as a plus. They do fewer things, but they do them well. Everything we ordered came out exactly as described, and there’s a clear consistency in how the kitchen approaches flavor and preparation. Even the side dishes felt intentional.
There’s a casual rhythm to how everything flows—from the greeting at the door to the final check. It feels genuine and steady, which is why I’ve come to trust it as a go-to.
If you want a dependable place with character, one that won’t let you down, this one checks all the boxes.“