20 Best Pizza Restaurants in Utica

“I got the best pizza! My neighbor got gluten free, extra cheese garlic and she said it was the best! My mom and I got dairy free cheese and it was the best! The kids said that it was the best also! Our favorite pizza place!“

“the price, the food, the quality is to perfection. my favorite go to spot. people know me and I love pizza. one of the best I ever had. 11 out of 10“

“The pizza here is delicious and the customer service is amazing. Thank you for making my son’s day. Will definitely come back again.“

“Delicious food! I order every other week at work and everyone is very happy with quality of the food.“

“The pizza, fries, and garlic bread were all delicious. The staff was very friendly and the overall feel was very comfortable with everyone in a good mood. On top of all that the prices were good as you get alot of food for your money, I'll have leftovers for a while. Thanks again!“

“Food is Great! Atmosphere Great! Gluten free options Great!“

“While growing up in the Adrian terrace, my family and I would go to eat here many times! It was our favorite spot! This is by far the best pizza I’ve ever had. Moved to Tampa fl in 1994 and brought my kids to visit utica first time in 2017, my first stop was here… pizza was still delicious as I remembered … brought back childhood memories and tears🥰 best pizza ever“

“My son is autistic and will ONLY eat Tony's pizza...that says something! awesome food all the time with great prices. and Tony the delivery driver is always great! he's super sweet and has a great sense of humor! stay awesome!“

“Asked if I'd recommend. Well... I didn't want to hit no because maybe it was just an off day with the chef. Everybody has one. Husband enjoyed his Chicken Parmesan, Utica Greens were good (1st time eating them). My Chicken Salvatore was dry and hard. Not enough sauce to even try to soften it up to make the dish enjoyable. Way overcooked. I guess the green beans and mashed potatoes were good. Might go back to see if it was just a fluke. Might not.. who knows.“

“I cannot say enough good things about Joey’s @ 307. From having dinner there for the first time about a year ago, to falling in love with their food and having them cater my wedding, everything they do is amazing. Truly the best chicken parm and chicken marsala I have ever had. They made the entire process easy and stress free (which if you’ve ever planned a wedding you know does not happen often!!). They made sure my husband and I had our own food first to make sure we ate, and made us out own to go meal at the end of the night. Every person I spoke with there was incredibly nice, helpful, and funny! Matt and Kathy helped make our wedding day perfect! Thank you guys again ?“

“If you are looking for a great place to have a gathering or your next party, Lukins Brick Oven Pizza did a wonderful job catering and hosting my son's graduation party yesterday. Every one of our guests kept raving about how good the pizza and wings were. The staff was so accommodating that were working. The owner Tom went above and beyond to provide the best experience possible as we had to move inside due to weather. There were also several gluten allergies that were accommodated with pasta that was said to be very good and all our wings and salad were also made gluten free. The back patio/bar area is beautiful and a great private area for a gathering also. Thank you Tom and staff for a wonderful day. Coming from Florida to have a party was a lot and it went very smoothly.“

“We ordered the pizza and wing special, it was excellent!“

“Excellent Excellent Excellent! Prices, quality, service, atmosphere A++ i will be finding another show at the Stanley to attend just to come back and eat again. Our server Alison, fantastic!“

“My son and I came in here yesterday afternoon/evening to pick up a pretty big order for my family. I can’t say enough good things about this place! I ordered here yesterday after deciding not to order from a place closer to me because of a very rude phone ordering experience. Everything was fantastic. From the pizza to the wings to the mozz sticks. By far the best in town. Everyone was beyond happy with their food. You guys are our new permanent spot because every part of the experience was great from the phone order, to the super polite service upon pick up, to the over all quality. All three kiddos say it’s the best pizza they’ve ever had. Thank you!!!“

“I have eaten their food for years! Always a worthy stop. The best Tomato Pie.“

“Great people, great food!“

“I ordered today; the employee who answered the phone had excellent customer service. I also had my pizza delivered to me within 20 minutes of the order and the employee delivering was very kind as well. Thank you for working in this heat and making the best pizzas in Utica!“

“My family and I loved this little place. Stopped by here on a whim traveling through town, and were pleasantly surprised. Subs, pizza and pasta were all great, and the staff was excellent, especially the front of the house. Inside was small, but clean. Only knock is no public restrooms, but I get why they wouldn't be open. Would definitely recommend this place!“

“My boyfriend and I order from slice almost every time my 3 nieces and nephew sleepover and their food is always exceptional. Unfortunately the last time we ordered, they messed up our order but we didn’t complain because all the kids still devoured it and we understand mistakes happen. But we did notify the workers and the owner reached out to us personally and said our next meal was on the house! This pizza place has the BEST pizza in town and everything sauce, and on top of that amazing service!!!“

“A great place to grab a bite. I recommend the sports bar portion of the restaurant. Always have good service over there and never a complaint about the food. They even made my steak just the way I like it. Highly recommend.“